Garage conversion and two storey rear extension and dormer to rear

📊

See the success rate & inspector analytics

Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.

Sign Up Free

Technical Issues Heatmap

Parking Provision
Conversion/Use
Policy Weight

Inspector’s Reasoning

Appeal Decision Site visit made on 26th September 2018 by Alison Roland BSc DipTP MRTPI an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State Decision date: 16th October 2018 Appeal Ref: APP/C2741/D/18/3207676 42 Crossways, York, YO10 5JQ.  The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a refusal to grant planning permission.  The appeal is made by Mr P Patel against the decision of the City of York Council.  The application Ref: 18/00029/FUL, dated 10 January 2018, was refused by notice dated 10 May 2018.  The development proposed is garage conversion and two storey rear extension and dormer to rear. Decision 1. The appeal is dismissed. Main Issues 2. The main issues in this appeal are (1) whether the proposal would lead to an unacceptable intensification in use of the existing House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) in the light of others in the area and (2) the adequacy of the parking, bin, cycle and internal storage arrangements. Reasons Intensification 3. The appeal property benefits from a Certificate of Lawfulness as a HMO for up to four occupants and both parties agree that it could be used for up to six without further planning permission. The Council refer to the Draft Supplementary Planning Document Controlling the Concentration of Houses in Multiple Occupation (Approved 2012 amended July 2014). Section 2.1 states that it will remain a draft until such a time as there is an adopted Development Plan in York. This limits the weight I give to it. 4. Moreover, I note that page 2 states that the guidance relates to planning applications consisting of a change of use from a C3 dwelling to a large or small HMO (my emphasis). It further states that it will not apply retrospectively to existing HMO’s. It therefore appears to me that the guidance does not apply to the appeal proposal, which amounts to an existing HMO and not a change of use from Class C3. Likewise, Policy H8 of the City of York Local Plan Publication Draft (February 2018) is a similar Policy to the SPD, but again it is quite explicit Appeal Decision APP/C2741/D/18/3207676 2 that it relates to applications for the change of use from dwelling houses, which is not the case here. 5. Either way, the SPD sets a threshold beyond which the further establishment of HMO’s would unbalance the community; this being 20% of all properties across the neighbourhood and 10% at street level and the Council concede that the levels in the vicinity of the appeal site are 16.2% and 18.03% respectively, meaning that only one of the thresholds is breached, albeit by a considerable margin. I note the Badger Hill Residents Community Group (BHRCG) claims the Council’s figures seriously underestimate the number of HMO’s on Crossways and suggest the street threshold figure is 27.8%. It is however, impossible to reconcile this figure with that given by the Council in the absence of further evidence. 6. The exterior of the property appears well maintained and there is nothing in its appearance to set it apart from other dwellings in the street. Whilst the Council refer to noise and disturbance from comings and goings, no evidence of particular problems in this regard has been drawn to my attention. I appreciate the argument about the concentration of such uses potentially unbalancing the community, but I have been furnished with no compelling evidence to suggest that why the addition of two additional bedrooms to an existing HMO would tip the balance. 7. I thus find on the first main issue that the proposal would not lead to an unacceptable intensification in the existing HMO use. Parking, bin, cycle and internal storage arrangements 8. The submitted plans depict bin and cycle storage to the rear of the property. The Council say that the retained space to the side of the property would be 600mm and the appellant puts it at closer to 800mm. It is difficult to reconcile these two measurements as the dimension is not given on the plan. Either way, both would fall short of the 900mm minimum sought in the Draft House Extensions and Alterations Supplementary Planning Document (December 2012) and would not be convenient to manoeuvre bins and cycles down. 9. It is also evident that were the two tandem parking spaces utilised as depicted on the plan, it would effectively render the passage of pedestrians with bins or cycles difficult if not impossible. The corollary of this, would be the likelihood of bins and cycles being stored in the front garden of the property, which would lend it a cluttered and unsightly appearance. This is especially pertinent bearing in mind there would potentially be six unrelated residents in the property and it is likely that their bin and cycle storage requirements would be greater than those of a single family household. 10.The parking space alongside the house appears substandard in size (both length and width) which would make it difficult for occupants to get in and out of vehicles, especially with shopping. In addition, the proposed parking arrangement with two tandem spaces and one in the front garden would effectively be difficult to manage in practice with the potential for the driveway space blocking the two others. Whilst I appreciate there may be some level of conviviality between occupants, I nevertheless consider it likely that some may Appeal Decision APP/C2741/D/18/3207676 3 well opt to park on street for the sake of convenience, in the event they might be asked to move their vehicle or be blocked in. 11.The ward Councillor refers to parking negatively impacting on the street scene, and the BHRCG refers to damage to verges by cars parked thereon. Local residents also refer to on street parking being oversubscribed in the area. I saw at my visit several cars in the vicinity of the appeal site parked on grass verges, due in part to the restricted carriageway width. Whilst I saw no damage to grass, this is likely due to the exceptionally dry summer and is a situation likely to change in winter. In these circumstances, I consider that the identified deficiencies in the proposed car parking arrangement would tend to exacerbate local on street/verge parking, which is clearly injurious to the amenity of the area and a concern to the local community. 12.The appellant refers to a similar scheme at No 6 Crossways (16/01096/FUL) and I viewed the frontage of that property at my visit. However, in the absence of further details of that scheme and without entering third party land, I was unable to satisfy myself as to the extent to which it is comparable to the appeal before me, which I must determine on its merits. 13.In relation to internal storage requirements, the Council say they require an internal layout to be suitable for the proposed number of occupants, but no specific size thresholds for internal storage space have been brought to my attention. Although the proposal would result in the loss of the garage and store, there is a significant communal area internally at ground floor. Given this and the generous size of the proposed bedrooms, I do not find against the appeal on this particular issue. Overall balance and conclusion 14.I have found in favour of the appeal in relation to the first main issue and also partially on the second in relation to internal storage arrangements. However, I have found that the proposed car parking, bin and cycle storage arrangements would be substandard and likely to lead to bins and cycles stored in the front garden and an increased incidence of on street/verge parking, which would be to the detriment of the character and appearance of the area. 15.This would bring the proposal into conflict with Policy GP1 criterion a) and GP4a criterion i) of the LP, the City of York Council Highway Design Guide and the City of York Council House Extensions and Alterations Draft Supplementary Planning Document (December 2012). These seek to ensure that development respects or enhances the local environment and makes adequate provision for car parking and the storage and collection of refuse and recycling. Although the LP is not adopted as a Development Plan, these objectives are consistent with the policies of the Framework (July 2018) at paragraph 127a) to ensure developments will function well and add to the overall quality of the area. These concerns are sufficiently weighty to lead me to the view that the appeal should be turned away. ALISON ROLAND INSPECTOR
Expert Representation

Don't leave your appeal to chance.

Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.

Get Free Review How it works →