External works and extension to existing building to create annex accommodation and the erection of a car port
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Residential Amenity
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 28 August 2018
by Neil Pope BA (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 5 September 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/D0121/D/18/3207521
Redshard House, Redshard Lane, Langford, Bristol, BS40 5EZ.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Ian Croker against the decision of North Somerset Council.
The application Ref. 18/P/2146/FUH, dated 19 January 2018, was refused by notice
dated 3 May 2018.
The development proposed is external works and extension to existing building to
create annex accommodation and the erection of a car port.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The Council disputes that the area where it is intended to erect the proposed
car port lies within the curtilage of the appellant’s dwelling. As pointed out by
the Council, this is a matter of fact and degree and involves an assessment of
complex case law, as well as the history of the land. It is not for me to
determine whether or not this area of land lies within the curtilage of Redshard
House. The Council processed the application under its “Householder
Application” 1 service. I have determined the appeal accordingly.
3. The local planning policies that I refer to below are the most relevant local
policies to the determination of this appeal.
Main Issues
4. The two main issues are: firstly, the effect upon the character and appearance
of the area and; secondly, whether the occupants of the proposed annexe
would have satisfactory living conditions, having particular regard to the
proximity of the proposed car port.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
5. The appeal site lies within the countryside to the north of Langford. A public
right of way runs along Redshard Lane immediately to the south of the site.
1 I note that under The Town and Country Planning (Development Management Procedure)(England) Order 2015 a
‘householder application’ means “an application for planning permission for development for an existing dwelling,
or development within the curtilage of such a dwellinghouse for purposes incidental to the enjoyment of the
dwellinghouse…”
Appeal Decision APP/D0121/D/18/3207521
2
6. The building which it is intended to adapt for use as an annex is a traditional,
single storey, mainly rubble stone and corrugated metal sheet roof structure.
This roughly triangular-shaped building abuts the boundary with the above
noted public right of way and lies to the south west of the appellant’s dwelling.
7. On behalf of the appellant, it has been calculated that the appeal building has a
floor area of 81.5m2. Notwithstanding the somewhat ‘run down’ appearance,
this traditional building adds to the distinctive qualities of the local
environment.
8. The development plan permits annexes2 outside of settlement boundaries only
where they are a physical extension of the main dwelling. Proposals which are
not designed as an integral part of a house are not permitted. The proposed
separate, detached annex would be contrary to PLP policy DM43.
9. The proposed annex would provide accommodation for the appellant’s parents.
There are social benefits to be derived from elderly parents living in very close
proximity to their relatives, not least for the care and support that can be
provided. This weighs in favour of an approval and I note that the Council did
not withhold permission on the basis of the conflict with PLP policy DM43.
10. Instead, the Council, amongst other things, has identified conflict with PLP
policy DM45. This permits the re-use of rural buildings for residential use
subject to specified criteria. These include a requirement for extensions not to
be disproportionate to the original building and to respect the scale and
character of the building and its setting.
11. The proposal would include a rendered extension along the northern side of the
building with three sets of tri-folding doors. The appellant has calculated that
this addition would measure 15 metres x 2.5 metres. A new roof would also be
constructed. This would be about 0.5 metres higher than the existing and
would comprise a mix of dual and mono-pitch roofs.
12. I understand that the PLP does not define ‘disproportionate’. Whilst the
proposal would entail a sizeable extension to the existing building and a small
increase in height, it would not be so large as to amount to a disproportionate
addition to this particular building. The proposed works would also not be out
of scale with the original building.
13. However, the proposed mix of roof shapes would result in a ‘confused’ roof
design and would give the building a rather awkward appearance. This would
detract from its pleasing distinctive qualities and result in a minor adverse
impact upon the character and appearance of the area. This would conflict
with the provisions of PLP policies DM45 and DM32 and weighs against granting
permission. On its own, this would be insufficient to withhold permission.
14. The Council has calculated that the proposed car port would measure 17
metres x 11 metres. The appellant has informed me that the eaves height
would be 2.5 metres and the roof ridge would be 6.7 metres. This new building
would be sited alongside the proposed annex and would replace an existing
carport3 which would be demolished. The new car port would be finished with
2 Policy DM43 of the Sites and Policies Plan Part 1: Development Management Policies (PLP) adopted in 2016.
3 The Council has calculated that this measures 7 metres x 5 metres. During my visit it was being used to store
various items other than cars.
Appeal Decision APP/D0121/D/18/3207521
3
blockwork rendered walls and roof tiles and would be used for the appellant’s
collection of “high value” cars.
15. The proposed car port would be a sizeable building/structure. From the public
right of way to the south east it would be seen in association with the
appellant’s house and the proposed annex. However, by virtue of its length
and height it would intrude into the mainly rural scene and, to a limited extent,
detract from the character and appearance of the area. This would conflict
with the provisions of PLP policies DM32 and DM38.
16. On its own, the adverse impact of the proposed car port would also be
insufficient to withhold permission. However, when combined with the harm
that I have identified in respect of the proposed annexe this leads me to
conclude on the first main issue that the proposals would unacceptably harm
the character and appearance of the area.
Living Conditions
17. The Council has calculated that the proposed car port would be approximately
2 metres from the proposed annex. The outlook from the facing windows in
the proposed lounge and bedrooms would be onto the tall, solid, rendered flank
wall of the car port. This would result in an overbearing and oppressive
outlook for those living within the proposed annex and would be at odds with
the objectives of PLP policy DM32 and the provisions of the National Planning
Policy Framework that are aimed at securing a good standard of amenity for
occupiers of adjacent buildings. In addition, given the height and close
proximity of the proposed car port to these north facing windows, the proposals
could also result in a rather gloomy environment for those living in the annex.
18. I conclude on the second main issue that the occupants of the proposed
annexe would have unsatisfactory living conditions due to the close proximity
of the proposed car port.
Overall Conclusion
19. Given my findings above, and having regard to all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should not succeed.
Neil Pope
Inspector
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.