Single storey rear extension; hip to gable roof extension and front and rear dormers; erection of detached garage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Rural Impact
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 15 October 2018
by Martin Andrews MA(Planning) BSc(Econ) DipTP & DipTP(Dist) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 1 November 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/P1425/D/18/3207477
Rocky Bank, Valebridge Road, Burgess Hill RH15 0RT
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Mark Parrott against the decision of Lewes District Council.
The application, Ref. LW/18/0184, dated 18 February 2018, was refused by notice dated
8 May 2018.
The development proposed is a single storey rear extension; hip to gable roof extension
and front and rear dormers; erection of detached garage.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is whether the proposed enlargement of the dwelling together
with previous additions would be appropriate as regards the Council’s aim of
maintaining a range of properties in the countryside and the effect of its
appearance on the site and its surroundings.
Reasons
3. The appeal dwelling is within the countryside for the purposes of the Council’s
development plan. Extensions to such a dwelling ‘outside the planning
boundary’ are therefore subject to Policy RES14 of the Lewes District Local Plan
2003. This includes the proviso that extensions in excess of 50% of the
‘original’ floorspace (defined as being in September 2008) will not normally be
permitted. Supporting paragraph 5.39 for Policy RES14 says that ‘Care will be
taken to ensure that any extensions do not result in loss of character of the
main building by, for instance, a small cottage becoming a large house’
4. In this case the Council says that the original dwelling’s floorspace was 76.3sqm
but this was increased by about 48% through the implementation of a 1997
permission. On the Council’s calculation the appeal scheme would add a further
111sqm or thereabouts of habitable floorspace which it considers would
dominate the existing building. And in respect of the original building it would
alter the percentage increase in floorspace far beyond both the 48% already
added and the 50% limit.
5. It seems to me therefore that both on an individual and cumulative basis the
appeal proposal would increase the size of Rocky Bank to an extent that would
be in clear breach of Policy RES14. The reference to the figure of 65% for an
Appeal Decision APP/P1425/D/18/3207477
2
increase in floorspace (24% ground floor plus 41% first floor) in the grounds of
appeal exceeding the 50% limit appears to be a misunderstanding, because the
officer’s report explains that this is an increase on the existing already extended
building and not the original. The actual percentage increase would therefore
be much greater.
6. Furthermore, unless there are extenuating circumstances, this scale of the
increase beyond the limit would be inherently harmful given that the policy is
one relating to the principle of restraint for the stated purpose of maintaining a
range of properties in the countryside. Referring back to paragraph 5.39 and
noting also the proposals include the construction of a two storey garage with
ancillary accommodation, I consider it reasonable to conclude that if the appeal
scheme were to proceed, the original modest bungalow would have become a
substantial house and this would have changed the character of the original
building.
7. In this regard, as the policy is one of precluding the incremental erosion of
small dwellings in the countryside, the appellants’ argument that there is
already a wide range of dwellings in the area, including within the planning
boundary in Burgess Hill, is not particularly relevant. Unless there is a
demonstrable excess of supply of such dwellings, the objective of the policy
remains valid.
8. In this context I agree that the fallback position of permitted development (pd)
is a factor. However, for it to be given significant weight in this instance I
consider that any calculations should be supported by a Lawful Development
Certificates together with convincing evidence either that the pd alternative
would be more harmful to the character and appearance of Rocky Bank or that
a planning permission would be, for one reason or another, clearly more
advantageous. I understand that it was these factors that were material in the
permissions given at Valebridge on the adjoining plot to the north. (I also note
that the recent application to Mid Sussex DC for a new dwelling on the
Valebridge site has now been refused).
9. Turning to the Council’s site-specific objections, bearing in mind the significant
increase above the policy threshold in the dwelling’s floorspace, I am not of the
opinion that the planning histories of nearby sites are in themselves a reason
for allowing the appeal on the basis of an inconsistent approach by the Council.
Whether all the sites mentioned are the rural side of the planning boundary is
not made clear, but nonetheless in addition to Valebridge mentioned above
(where the Council was clear in explaining in its appraisal for that scheme why
an exception had been made as regards size), the 4 dwelling permission at
Double Bass was granted as long ago as 2002, before the adoption of the Local
Plan. Other examples are not supported by floorspace figures and comparisons
with the original buildings.
10. With that said, in regard to the alterations and additions to the dwelling and its
effect on its surroundings, the grounds of appeal also refer to a number of other
matters considered to support the application. In general terms I consider that
the surroundings of the appeal site offer some support for the appellant’s case.
Rocky Bank is part of a ribbon development extending northwards from Burgess
Hill, and whilst not ‘suburban’ as the appellant claims, I do consider that it has a
semi-rural rather than overtly rural character.
Appeal Decision APP/P1425/D/18/3207477
3
11. Furthermore, the original character of modestly sized bungalows, assuming as
seems likely that the original Rocky Bank was one of several dwellings of this
type, has changed to a wide range of dwellings of different sizes and styles on
this side of Valebridge Road. Bearing in mind this variety and the fact that the
dwellings are in large plots set well back from the road and in some cases with
a range of outbuildings, I consider that some flexibility of approach may be
justified. This would be supported by the Government’s Planning Practice
Guidance 2014 and National Planning Policy Framework 2018, particularly in
relation to design detail which in any event could be improved through the
Council engaging in negotiations. The Council uses the term ‘overdevelopment’
in the second refusal reason, but whilst this might be correct in relation to just
the original dwelling, I do not consider that by any yardstick it can reasonably
apply to the relationship of the proposed extended building with its extensive
plot.
12. Overall, I conclude that the appeal must fail because there is an insufficient
basis for its enlargement as regards the objective to maintain a range of
dwelling sizes in the countryside as required by Local Plan Policy RES14. On the
other issues raised in the grounds of appeal and the policies referred to, the
scheme would benefit from some amendments. I do not though consider that
the Council has demonstrated that there would inevitably be a harmful effect on
the site and its surroundings. However, this does not outweigh my finding that
the building would be cumulatively extended by an amount that would greatly
exceed the floorspace increase allowed and change its character and size
contrary to adopted policy. Unless and until the policy is changed or the
planning boundary moved there would need to be a clear exposition of an
additional and significant material consideration to weigh in the planning
balance.
13. For the above reasons and having had regard to all other matters raised the
appeal is dismissed.
Martin Andrews
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.