Demolish outbuildings and construct rear single storey extension, two storey side extension and double garage with studio over
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Rural Impact
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 15 August 2018
by Peter D Biggers BSc Hons MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 29 August 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/P1045/D/18/3206542
Knaveholm Cottage, Sides Lane, Snelston DE6 2EN.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Ratcliffe against the decision of Derbyshire Dales
District Council
The application Ref 18/00354/FUL, dated 29 March 2018, was refused by notice dated
29 May 2018.
The development proposed is demolish outbuildings and construct rear single storey
extension, two storey side extension and double garage with studio over.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the double garage and studio.
2. The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the rear single storey extension and
two storey side extension. Planning permission is granted for the rear single storey
extension and two storey side extension at Knaveholm Cottage, Sides Lane,
Snelston DE6 2EN in accordance with the terms of the application, Ref
18/00354/FUL, dated 29 March 2018 and the plans submitted with it, so far as
relevant to that part of the development hereby permitted and subject to the
following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: 1701/48/PL/01 and 1701/48/PL/02 insofar as
these relate to the rear extension and side extension.
3) No development shall commence until details of the materials to be used in
the construction of the external surfaces of the extensions hereby permitted
have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning
authority. Development shall be carried out in accordance with the approved
details.
4) Notwithstanding condition 2, no development shall take place until revised
details of the ground floor front living room window in the side extension,
matching the style of the other windows in the front elevation, have been
submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority.
Development shall be carried out in accordance with the approved details.
Procedural Matter
3. There is a discrepancy in the spelling of the cottage name but I have taken the
spelling of ‘Knaveholm’ shown on the ordnance survey based location plan to be
correct for the purposes of this decision letter.
Appeal Decision APP/P1045/D/18/3206542
2
4. The appellant, in submitting his appeal statement, has indicated that the height of
the garage could be reduced to 4 metres if necessary. However this would be a
material amendment to the application as originally submitted and there is no
evidence that it has been subject to formal consultation. As such, the interests of
third parties could be prejudiced. Accordingly, I have not taken this amendment
into account and have instead determined the appeal on the basis of the scheme
which was before the Council.
Main Issue
5. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and the surroundings of Sides Lane.
Reasons
6. Knaveholm Cottage is a small detached dwelling in an isolated location on Sides
Lane with the nearest neighbouring property being Knaveholm Farm to the south
of the lane. The cottage is built in a traditional style in stone and slate over two
storeys on the main part of the house with a single storey side offshoot. It is set
well back from and at an angle to Sides Lane.
7. The most dominant part of the proposed alterations would be the double detached
garage with upper floor space. The scale of the proposed garage would be almost
two thirds the length of the existing house and deeper than it. The height at about
5.8 metres would be close to the height of the main dwelling and as the garage is
proposed to be set above the level of the original house it is probable that the
garage ridge height would actually exceed the ridge height of the main house. It
would therefore not be proportionate to the existing house.
8. In sitting between the house and the road, the height, scale and mass of the
garage would be obtrusive. Although the Design and Access Statement states that
the garage would be set into the bank there is no evidence on plan that this would
be the case to any significant degree and, as above, in fact the slab level for the
garage is proposed to be about 1 metre above the main house. I acknowledge that
there is some tree planting along Sides Lane and a boundary hedge to the north
east but the trees are mainly deciduous fruit trees and in winter would not screen
the bulk of the garage to any significant extent.
9. I note that the appellant states that he needs the garage for the storage of cars,
cycles and gardening equipment but this could be achieved in a much smaller
building and is no justification for the scale, mass and height of building proposed.
10. By contrast although the floor area proposed in the side and rear extensions is also
large, both components of the extensions would be subordinate to the main house
being set down and set back from the main house in respect of the side extension
and set in and set below the eaves line of the main house in respect of the rear
extension. In addition the rear extension would be subordinate in height to the
side extension. The result would be an extended property where the original form
of the house could be clearly read. Although the proposal would be a significant
increase in floorspace, the total extension would still be less than the original
house and, because of the relationship of the various elements, the extensions can
still be considered to be proportionate.
11. Generally the design and fenestration proposed for the extensions would be
sensitive to the character of the property with one exception. The patio doors on
the main frontage would appear as an incongruous addition and are largely
unnecessary as the north-west facing windows to the ground floor living room are
Appeal Decision APP/P1045/D/18/3206542
3
large format and take up virtually all of the room length. These large format
windows on the north west elevation, by contrast to those on the frontage, would
not be viewed in the context of any original fenestration nor from the road and as
such would not be inappropriate. The design of the front fenestration could
however be satisfactorily controlled by condition requiring the submission of an
alternative design showing a matching window detail to the existing windows.
12. The extensions would be visible in the approaches, particularly from the west along
Sides Lane and from the surrounding countryside. However, the overall scale and
design of the alterations, amended in respect of the ground floor window, coupled
with the existing boundary hedging and trees is such that neither the character
and appearance of the cottage nor the countryside setting would be harmed.
13. The proposed single storey rear extension and two storey side extensions would be
clearly severable both physically and functionally from the proposed double garage
and studio and it would be open to me to issue a split decision.
14. Policy S4 of the Derbyshire Dales Local Plan (DDLP) allows extensions in the open
countryside subject to them meeting the requirements of policy HC10 and
providing development protects and where possible enhances the landscape’s
intrinsic character and distinctiveness. With a split decision issued, dismissing the
appeal as it relates to the detached garage, I am satisfied that the landscape
character and distinctiveness would not be harmed by the house extensions.
Similarly, the house extensions, excluding the garage, would respect the
character, identity and context of Derbyshire Dales landscapes in accordance with
DDLP policy PD1. A split decision, for the reasons set out above, would mean the
house extensions would also meet the criteria set out in DDLP policy HC10. The
plot size is large enough to accommodate the extensions without appearing
cramped. The height, scale, form and design would be in keeping with the scale
and character of the original dwelling. Finally sufficient space would remain for the
parking of cars on the property.
15. As such the proposed house extensions would accord with DDLP policies and would
not adversely impact on the character and appearance of the host property and
the surrounding countryside. Conversely, and particularly in respect of policy
HC10b), the proposed detached garage would not accord with the policies.
Conclusions and conditions
16. I have considered the matters before me and, for the reasons given above, I will,
therefore, issue a split decision dismissing the appeal in relation to the proposed
garage and studio but allowing the appeal and granting planning permission
insofar as it relates to the single storey rear and 2 storey side extensions.
17. I have considered the conditions suggested by the Council against the advice in
the Planning Practice Guidance and for their clarity. A condition requiring
development to be carried out in accordance with the submitted plans used to
determine the application is necessary as this provides certainty that the
development would be carried out in the form proposed. Control of the materials
to be used on the exterior of the extensions to the dwelling will also be important
to protect the character and appearance of the dwelling and surroundings.
However as the materials are not proposed to be matching, being render rather
than stone, the proposed form of condition is inappropriate and confusing. I have
therefore instead attached a condition requiring the submission of details of the
materials thus allowing the Council to retain control of the final choice of materials.
I have imposed an additional condition to those proposed by the Council that is
Appeal Decision APP/P1045/D/18/3206542
4
designed to achieve a more complementary form to the ground floor fenestration
in the front elevation in the interests of maintaining the character and appearance
of that elevation which is open to inward views from Sides Lane. I have not
consulted specifically on the additional condition as it seeks to address a concern
raised by the Council in the officer report and known to the appellant and is in
itself a minor amendment to the design.
P. D. Biggers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.