Ground floor extension and alterations to the dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 December 2018
by A J Mageean BA (Hons) BPl PhD MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 31st December 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/E2530/D/18/3205919
The Former Rectory, Back Lane, Ingoldsby, Grantham, Lincolnshire
NG33 4EW
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr T Arnold against the decision of South Kesteven District
Council.
The application Ref S17/1844, dated 5 September 2017, was refused by notice dated
3 May 2018.
The development proposed is ground floor extension and alterations to the dwelling.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. Whilst the decision notice refers to ‘The Rectory’ I understand that this was in
error and the correct name of the property is in the above banner heading.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance
of the area, and on the setting of nearby listed buildings.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. Ingoldsby village comprises a range of cottage type properties and farm
buildings alongside more contemporary and modest post war infilling. It has a
pleasantly rural setting. The host dwelling is a two storey detached property
set in a large plot and located some 25m back from the Main Street frontage.
It is constructed from buff brick with a steeply pitched roof and a modest
central front gable projection. Overall it is of substantial but unremarkable
appearance which assimilates reasonably well in its setting. The fact that it is
at a higher level than Main Street in a corner plot means that it appears more
noticeable on the street scene than other dwellings, particularly when travelling
west along Main Street.
5. The proposed front extension would be a single storey addition which would
step down from the front of the dwelling, following the falling site gradient
towards Main Street. It would fill much of the existing width of the dwelling,
with side wings with shallow mono-pitched roofs projecting forward by around
Appeal Decision APP/E2530/D/18/3205919
2
6.5m. The central portion would have a shallow gabled roof and an extensively
glazed frontage and would project forward by around a further 4.66m.
6. This large addition would not accord with or complement the character of the
host dwelling in terms of the considerable mass of its single storey form,
contrasting roof slopes and extent of glazing. Whilst complementary materials
would be used this would do little to secure effective integration.
7. More generally it would substantially alter the appearance of the host dwelling
in the local area, standing out as an intrusive addition and a jarring element in
the streetscene particularly when travelling along Main Street in a westerly
direction. The fact that it would step down with the slope would mean that its
overall mass would be clearly apparent and would appear as an unusual and
eye catching feature. Whilst local views are to some degree moderated by the
fact that nearby buildings are set further forward relative to the road, and the
extension would be set back over 14m from the roadside, in this relatively open
corner location it would remain a prominent addition.
8. I therefore find that the proposed extension would be harmful to the character
and appearance of the area. In this sense there would be conflict with the
South Kesteven Core Strategy 2010 (Core Strategy) Policy EN1 which seeks to
protect and enhance the character of the district. It requires that development
proposals are assessed in terms of local distinctiveness and sense of place, and
the quality and character of the built fabric and their settings. It would also
conflict with those aspects of the National Planning Policy Framework (the
Framework) which seek to promote a high standard of design which is
sympathetic to local character.
Setting of listed buildings
9. A short distance to the south east of the site is the Grade I listed Church of St
Bartholomew. This is a striking structure, dating back to the late Norman
Period with notable additions and alterations dating from the 14th, 15th and 19th
Centuries. It is set in an elevated position and located close to the roadside,
and therefore appears prominently in views along Main Street, particularly
when travelling west. Views from the west along Main Street are restricted by
the mature vegetation and buildings associated with the Old Manor House. The
modest character of nearby dwellings and rural setting support the prominence
of the Church in the local street scene.
10. The undeveloped nature of the long front garden area of the host dwelling
currently contributes to the open setting of the Church when travelling west
along Main Street, though as it is located a little further west, this contribution
is at most modest. The proposed extension would appear within this setting in
a limited range of views. As I have found that this would be an
uncharacteristic and eye-catching addition, it would create some visual
distraction away from this heritage asset in these views. As such it would
result in some harm to the setting of this highly significant building, though I
quantify this as less than substantial.
11. The Council also makes reference to harm to the setting of Old Manor House, a
Grade II listed building located to the south west of the appeal site. However,
this building is set back some distance from the road, and the surroundings in
which it is experienced relate more closely to its extensive grounds and the
rural area to the west. The appeal proposal would be located some distance to
Appeal Decision APP/E2530/D/18/3205919
3
the north, behind the northern outbuildings. As such it would not cause harm
to the setting of this heritage asset.
12. Concluding on this point, the less than substantial harm to the significance of
the Grade I listed building remains a matter to which I am required to give
considerable importance and weight. In such circumstances the lack of formal
objection to the proposal from Historic England is not an indication of its
acceptability. The Framework sets out at paragraph 196 that such harm should
be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. The purely private
benefits of the additional living accommodation created do not qualify as such.
13. The harm found to the setting of this listed building would be in conflict with
Core Strategy Policy EN1 which states that all development proposals will be
assessed in relation to statutory, national and local designations of landscape
features, including natural and historic assets.
Conclusion
14. The current scheme represents a revised proposal following an earlier refusal of
planning permission for a front extension set at the same floor level as the
existing dwelling. The appellant has sought to address concerns about the
effect of a large front extension on the local area. However, I have considered
the appeal scheme on its own merits and found that the proposal would appear
out of place in its local context, and that it would result in some harm to the
setting of a Grade I listed building. As such the proposal would not accord with
the development plan taken as a whole and there are no other material
considerations to outweigh this finding. So, for the reasons given above, the
appeal is dismissed.
AJ Mageean
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.