Reconfiguration of existing dwelling, including an extension to both sides and small extension to rear. New roof to height of existing and demolition of existing garage to create driveway
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 28th August 2018
by Alison Roland BSc DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 18 September 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/H4505/D/18/3204922
Glen View, Stannerford Road, Clara Vale, Ryton, NE40 3SN.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Wayne Stewart against the decision of Gateshead Metropolitan
Brough Council.
The application Ref: DC/17/00562/HHA, dated 16 May 1982, was refused by notice
dated 29 March 2018.
The development proposed is reconfiguration of existing dwelling, including an
extension to both sides and small extension to rear. New roof to height of existing and
demolition of existing garage to create driveway.
Procedural Matters
1. The date of the application cited in the header above is derived from the planning
application forms and is clearly an error. I note the appeal form gives the date of
the application as 5 September 2017 and the Decision Notice gives it as 22 May
2017. However, this matter is not of importance since the appeal is dismissed.
2. The works to which this appeal relates have been completed. I shall therefore
deal with this appeal as an application for retrospective planning permission.
Decision
3. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
4. The main issues in this appeal are (1) whether the proposal amounts to
inappropriate development in the Green Belt (GB) and if so, whether the harm by
reason of inappropriateness and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances necessary to
justify the development and (2) the implications of the proposal for the character
and appearance of the area.
Reasons
5. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) states at paragraph 145
that the extension or alteration of a building is not inappropriate development in
the GB provided that it does not result in disproportionate additions over and
above the size of the original building.
Appeal Decision APP/H4505/D/18/3204922
2
6. The Council say that the original dwelling was 85.3sqm and the proposals have
increased this to 449.2sqm. The appellant cites a volume of 468.8m3 for the
“existing dwelling” (presumably the dwelling prior to implementation of the
proposals) compared against 546.9 m3 for the “new dwelling” (presumably the
current dwelling). However, the former figure appears to include outbuildings and
the previous extension to the property carried out in the 1980’s. The volume
given for the original property alone is 191.2m3.
7. Annex 2 of the Framework defines ‘original building’ as a building as it existed on
1 July 1948 or, if constructed after 1 July 1948, as it was built originally. Clearly,
the 1980’s extension cannot be included in the definition of the original building.
Neither do I consider the term can reasonably extend to the garage and dog
shelter, as the evidence suggests these were detached outbuildings. By any
measure, whether one relies on the calculations of the Council or appellant, the
original property has been very substantially enlarged as a result of the proposals.
8. This is particularly evident when a comparison is made between its present size
and massing and its original condition as can be discerned in the aerial
photograph submitted with the appeal. The resultant increase in scale and
massing leave me in no doubt that the proposals would amount to a
disproportionate addition to the original dwelling. It follows that they would
amount to inappropriate development in the GB. Paragraph 143 of the Framework
states that inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the GB and
should not be approved except in very special circumstances.
9. Added to the harm by reason of inappropriateness would be a moderate loss of
openness to the GB as a result of the increased scale and massing of the dwelling.
The modest proportions of the original L-shaped bungalow have been
substantially increased in width and depth. This harm would be localized, but
paragraph 144 of the Framework states that the decision maker should ensure
that substantial weight is given to any harm to the GB.
10.In relation to the second main issue, the Council say that the original dwelling has
been engulfed in extensions and it is very hard to distinguish in the mass of built
form. Whilst that is certainly true, the appearance of the resultant dwelling
harmonises perfectly well with others along this stretch of road and it is of
unremarkable appearance. It appears the property has been completely
remodelled, but the result is a cohesive design which, whilst slightly more
contemporary than many others in the street, by no means draws the eye. Whilst
the white painted render finish is somewhat brighter than the brickwork of
surrounding properties, I note that the previous building had a white painted
finish. I thus find on the second main issue that the proposal would integrate
comfortably with the prevailing character and appearance of the area.
Other Considerations raised by the appellant
11.The appellant raises a number of considerations in favour of the appeal. It is
claimed that the work was undertaken following advice from a Planning Officer
about the extent of permitted development rights which could potentially be
exercised, which were depicted on a plan. It is further asserted that the appellant
implemented a scheme which did not utilise those rights to the full.
12.It is difficult to come to a view on what the plan purports to show as it is a very
basic floor plan and not three dimensional. I also understand a more recent
Appeal Decision APP/H4505/D/18/3204922
3
Planning Officer has questioned its accuracy. If indeed the appellant believes that
what has been implemented is lawful, it is open to him to have the matter
determined under Section 191 or 192 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
However, this is not a matter for me to determine in the context of an appeal
made under Section 78 of the Act and it has no bearing on the planning merits.
The appellant further argues that the exercise of permitted development rights
could have resulted in a larger building. However, no specific scheme in three
dimensional form has been put before me to demonstrate this.
13.The appellant says that alternative plans were submitted to the Council which had
previously been agreed with them in 2014 and these have been supplied with the
appeal. The position of the Council on these plans at that time is unclear from the
email correspondence supplied and the appellant implies that they have since
revised their position. The comment from the Planning Officer that the scheme is
“generally there” subject to the removal of permitted development rights is not
synonymous with an outright approval. Furthermore, the calculations in the
emails compare what was then the existing property, with the proposed scheme,
rather than comparing the resultant volume against the original building, which is
the correct approach as outlined in paragraph 7 above. On the available evidence,
I am not persuaded therefore, that they represent a legitimate fallback position.
14.The appellant highlights that the Inspector in a previous planning appeal at the
site (APP/H4505/D/14/2215596) acknowledged that some form of extension
would be acceptable. Paragraph 10 of that decision states that there was the
“potential for some extensions to be constructed” if that appeal were
unsuccessful. However, this appears to have been simply an acknowledgement of
the fact that alternative schemes could be devised using permitted development
rights at that time and was not intended to give a steer on the scale of extensions
likely to be acceptable. He also went on to say that such extensions would not be
as harmful as the scheme that was then before him. I do not consider therefore
that the Inspectors’ comments fetter my discretion in this appeal.
15.Information submitted in relation to the immediately adjoining properties
(Norbreck and Meadowvale) demonstrates that the appeal property is smaller in
volume and floor area than both. The fact the property is sited in a row of
dwellings, including some larger properties, does slightly mitigate the impact of
the proposal on the openness of the GB. However, whether a proposal amounts to
inappropriate development in the GB in the first instance is not contingent on the
scale of nearby properties. I therefore attribute some, albeit limited weight to this
point.
16.I understand the appellant is aggrieved with the way the Council dealt with the
application the subject of this appeal and earlier correspondence prior to that.
However, those are not matters I can take into account in assessing the planning
merits.
Overall Balance and Conclusion
17.I have found on the first main issue that the proposal would amount to a
disproportionate addition to the original property which would render it
inappropriate development in the GB. Added to that harm would be a moderate
loss of openness to the GB. This would bring it into conflict with Policy CS19 of the
Core Strategy and Urban Core Plan for Gateshead and Newcastle upon Tyne
Appeal Decision APP/H4505/D/18/3204922
4
2010-2030 (March 2015) (CS), which seeks to ensure that development in the GB
complies with national policy, including the Framework. I attach substantial
weight to these findings.
18.In relation to the second main issue, I have found that the proposal would
integrate comfortably with the prevailing character and appearance of the area. I
thus find no conflict with Policy CS15 of the CS, saved Policy ENV3 of the
Gateshead Council Unitary Development Plan (2007), or the guidance in the
Framework. These seek to secure high quality design that responds positively to
local character and identity. It would not comply with the guidance in the
Householder Alterations and Extensions Supplementary Planning Document
(2012), which requires that extensions are in keeping with and do not dominate
the original building. However, its appearance is not at all out of place in its
context. Nonetheless, this amounts to a neutral or absence of harm factor, rather
than a positive one in the overall GB balance.
19.For the appeal to succeed, the combined weight of the other considerations raised
by the appellant must be sufficient to clearly outweigh the totality of harm
identified. Overall, I conclude that the other considerations raised by the
appellant, would not clearly outweigh the identified harm. It follows that the very
special circumstances necessary to justify the development do not exist. The
appeal therefore fails.
ALISON ROLAND
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.