First floor side extension over existing garage and entrance lobby to create additional living space for growing family
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 18 September 2018
by Elaine Worthington BA (Hons) MTP MUED MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 26 September 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/C2741/D/18/3204776
96 Acorn Way, York, YO24 2RP
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Davenport against the decision of City of York
Council.
The application Ref 17/03042/FUL, dated 8 December 2017, was refused by notice
dated 3 May 2018.
The development proposed is a first floor side extension over existing garage and
entrance lobby to create additional living space for growing family.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The revised National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) was
published on 24 July 2018 and replaced the version published in 2012. None of
the revisions to the Framework materially affect the issues in this appeal.
However, for clarity, references made to the Framework in this decision are to
the 2018 version.
Main Issues
3. The main issues in this case are:
The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the host
property and the surrounding area; and
The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the occupiers of 2a
Ryecroft Avenue with particular reference to outlook.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal property is a semi-detached house in a residential area of similar
properties. It is located at the end of the row of semi-detached houses which
make up the east side of Acorn Way and occupiers a corner position where it is
adjacent to the properties in Ryecroft Avenue to the north.
5. The City of York Council’s House Extensions and Alterations Supplementary
Planning Document (SPD) advises at paragraph 7.1 that any extension should
normally be in keeping with the appearance, scale, design and character of
Appeal Decision APP/C2741/D/18/3204776
2
both the existing dwelling and the street scene generally. In particular care
should be taken to ensure that the proposal does not dominate the house or
clash with its appearance. Paragraph 12.3 states that side extensions should
be generally subservient to the main house, the ridge height of extensions
should be lower than that of the house and the front elevation should be set
behind the front building line. Paragraph 12.4 further advises that extensions
should not exceed around 50% of the width of the original house, unless its
width has been designed to successfully harmonise with architectural features
contained on the original property.
6. The proposed first floor extension would be constructed over the existing single
storey side extension which extends up to the side boundary. Thus, although it
would not exceed the width of the existing extension, it would nevertheless be
wider than the extent of the original dwelling (the Council estimates it would be
117% of its width and the appellants do not dispute this). Furthermore, the
extension would not be set behind the front building line of the appeal property
and would be built flush with its front elevation. Although it would be set down
by 0.5 metres from the ridge of the main roof, the extension’s eaves would be
the same height as those of the existing dwelling.
7. This being so, the proposal would be an excessively wide and bulky addition
that would be almost as tall as the host property. Even taking into account the
host property’s simple design and relatively narrow original width, it would be
appreciated as a considerable unbroken continuation of the property’s front
elevation and would appear out of scale with it. As such, it would overwhelm
the host property’s appearance, fail to be subservient to it, and introduce an
unduly dominant and incongruous feature.
8. The use of horizontal timber boarding across the front elevation and the wide
front porch, whilst contemporary additions, would add to the impression of
excessive width and exacerbate the proposal’s unsatisfactory visual impact.
Thus, the design would fail to harmonise successfully with the host property.
This would be so despite its incorporation of matching light brown bricks. Nor
am I persuaded that the new garage door would break up its appearance to
any significant extent. Additionally, in the context of adjoining No 94 which
has not been extended, the proposal would unbalance the appearance of the
pair of properties and undermine the existing symmetry between them.
9. The appeal property is at the end of the row and positioned side on to the front
of adjacent Nos 2 and 2a Ryecroft Avenue. I appreciate that this is an unusual
relationship and that the proposed extension would not project towards a side
elevation of a close neighbour. Nevertheless, the existing space above the
appeal property’s single storey extension creates a sense of openness and
separation between the properties in Acorn Way and those at right angles to
them in Ryecroft Avenue.
10. The proposal would project towards the front of those dwellings and close that
gap with built development. As a result it would reduce the spaciousness of
the plot and the area. Whilst this would not be immediately obvious on
approach from the south, it would be readily appreciated in the immediate
vicinity of the appeal site in Acorn Close and from Ryecroft Avenue. In eroding
the spacious character of the area, the proposal would fail to respect the
established spaces between dwellings and stand out as an unsympathetic
addition to the locality.
Appeal Decision APP/C2741/D/18/3204776
3
11. The SPD encourages two storey side extensions as a positive way to increase
internal living space, and the appellants consider them to be a common feature
in the street scene. That said, the examples cited nearby all appear to differ
from the appeal scheme in some way or another. They do not occupy
corner/end plots, relate to detached dwellings, are set in from their respective
front elevations and/or they are much narrower in relation to their host
properties. In any event, I am not aware of the full circumstances that led to
those developments and so cannot be sure that they are the same as in the
case before me. I confirm that I have considered the appeal proposal on its
own individual planning merits.
12. Overall, even having regard to the existing extension’s flat roof design, I
consider that the proposal would fail to respect the appearance, scale and
design of the host dwelling, the neighbouring property at No 94, or the wider
street scene. That the appeal property is not listed or within a Conservation
Area does not alter my view.
13. I therefore conclude on this main issue that the proposal would be harmful to
the character and appearance of the host property and the surrounding area.
This would be contrary to Policy GP1 of the City of York Draft Development
Control Local Plan 2005 (Local Plan) which expects development to; respect or
enhance the local environment (a); be of a density, layout, scale, mass and
design that is compatible with neighbouring buildings, spaces and the character
of the area, using appropriate building materials (b); and avoid the loss of
open spaces, important gaps within development, vegetation, water features
and other features that contribute to the quality of the local environment (c).
14. It would conflict with Local Plan Policy H7 which is permissive of residential
extensions where; the design and materials are sympathetic to the main
dwelling and the locality of the development (a); the design and scale are
appropriate in relation to the main building (b); and the proposal respects the
spaces between dwellings (e).
15. Whilst I accept that the guidance in the SPD is advice only to be applied flexibly
taking into account context and site specific circumstances, the proposal would
also be at odds with the SPD. Additionally, it would fail to support paragraph
130 of the Framework which indicates that permission should be refused for
development of poor design that fails to take the opportunities available for
improving the character and quality of an area and the way it functions, taking
into account any local design standards or style guides in plans or
supplementary planning documents.
16. Although the Council also refers to Policy D11 of the City of York Publication
Draft Local Plan 2018, since that document has not yet been examined,
remains subject to consultation, and is at a relatively early stage of
preparation, I afford this policy only very limited weight.
Living conditions
17. Adjacent No 2a is a bungalow which faces the appeal property. It has a lounge
window to its main front elevation along with windows serving its kitchen on
the west and south elevations of its front offshoot element. Whilst these do
not face out directly onto the side of the appeal property, its gable end is only
slightly off set and clearly visible from these principal habitable rooms.
Appeal Decision APP/C2741/D/18/3204776
4
18. Whilst the proposed extension would be to some extent framed by the bulk of
the main house behind, it would introduce two storey development to almost
the full height of the existing house very near to the boundary and in much
closer proximity to No 2a than is currently the case. The resultant tall blank
gable end would appear visually dominant and overbearing. Given No 2a’s
single storey nature and already somewhat tucked away and enclosed position,
the proposal would erode the existing sense of openness currently experienced
by the occupiers there and reduce the amount of sky that would be visible from
the rooms described as well as from the front garden area. Thus, the occupiers
of No 2a would experience an unsatisfactory loss of outlook and feel
unacceptably hemmed in.
19. I therefore conclude on this main issue that the proposal would be harmful to
the living conditions of the occupiers of 2a Ryecroft Avenue with particular
reference to outlook. This would be contrary to Local Plan Policy GP1 which
expects development to ensure that residents living nearby are not unduly
dominated by overbearing structures (i). It would conflict with Local Plan
Policy H7 which is permissive of residential extensions where there is no
adverse effect on the amenity which neighbouring residents could reasonably
expect to enjoy (d). It would also be at odds with Paragraph 5.2 of the SPD
which advises that when assessing the impact on outlook, regard will be had to
the established character of an area and the existing feeling of openness.
Additionally, the proposal would fail to support paragraph 127 (f) of the
Framework which advises that decisions should ensure that developments
provide a high standard of amenity for existing and future users.
Other matters
20. The existing flank bedroom window facing Nos 2 and 2a would be replaced by a
high level window such that privacy levels would be improved. Whilst this is a
benefit of the proposal, given the separation distances involved I am not aware
that the existing window causes any particular harm in terms of overlooking.
The appellants consider the house to be cramped and poorly configured
upstairs and the proposal would provide more balanced accommodation and a
much needed fourth bedroom. Nevertheless, even taken together, these
benefits of the proposal are insufficient to outweigh the harm I have identified
in relation to the main issues.
21. The appellants refer to the government’s changes to permitted development
rights. However, these do not add any weight in favour of the appeal proposal
(which concerns a first floor extension that requires planning permission). I
am aware of the support for the proposal from other local residents but that is
not a reason to allow development that would be harmful. Despite the
concerns of the occupiers there, the Council is satisfied that no loss of daylight
or sunlight would occur to No 2a. The absence of harm in this regard counts
neither for, nor against the proposal.
Conclusion
22. For the reasons set out above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Elaine Worthington
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.