Erection of a single storey side, rear and roof extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 31 July 2018
by K E Down MA(Oxon) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 6 August 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/N5090/D/18/3203904
72 Milton Avenue, Barnet, EN5 2EU
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs J McBarek against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Barnet.
The application Ref 18/1129/HSE, dated 20 February 2018, was refused by notice dated
19 April 2018.
The development proposed is erection of a single storey side, rear and roof extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. There are two main issues. Firstly, the effect of the proposed rear and roof
extension on the character and appearance of the host dwelling and the
surrounding area; and secondly, the effect of the rear and roof extension on the
living conditions of occupiers of 74 Milton Avenue with respect to outlook.
Reasons
3. The appeal site comprises a modest, traditional, detached bungalow with a
hipped, pyramid roof. It is set noticeably above street level in Milton Avenue, a
suburban road, characterised in the vicinity of the appeal site by bungalows of
similar age but of various designs. The street rises from south to north with 74
Milton Avenue being at a lower level than the appeal dwelling.
4. The proposed extensions include a single storey side extension that would
replace an existing extension. It would be set behind the existing garage and
would have a mono pitched roof. The Council raises no objection to this part of
the proposed development and I agree it would be acceptable. I shall therefore
restrict my further consideration to the proposed rear and roof extension.
5. The existing pyramid roof would be replaced by a gabled roof with a wide
crown, set behind the new ridge. The crown roof would extend back beyond the
existing main rear elevation of the bungalow by about 2.4m, over a proposed
rear extension. The bungalow would therefore appear from the rear as a two
storey dwelling with a flat roof. The sides of the roof would be hipped and on
Appeal Decision APP/N5090/D/18/3203904
2
the northern elevation the hip would flow into the mono pitched roof of the
single storey extension, forming a cat-slide roof. On the southern elevation it
would finish in high eaves, resulting in an extensive blank elevation facing No
74 and located up to the shared boundary.
6. The loss of the pyramid roof would alter the appearance of the bungalow but
the proposed gable ended structure would be no higher than the existing peak
and the proposed half hips would soften the blunt gable ends, helping to retain
some of the original roof character. Moreover, there are a number of hip to
gable roof conversions on similar bungalows nearby. As such the design would
not be alien in the street scene.
7. Nevertheless, the significant rearward extension of the roof, the incongruous
flat crown and the extensive blank side elevation, all of which would be
apparent from the street, would result in a bulky and unsympathetic addition
that would materially alter and detract from the character and appearance of
the existing bungalow and the street scene. From the rear the bungalow would
appear squat and boxy as a result of the roof extension rising up in a
continuous wall above the ground floor and finishing in a discordant flat roof,
materially adding to the harm.
8. It is concluded on the first main issue that, although the single storey side
extension would have no materially detrimental effect, the proposed rear and
roof extension would have a materially harmful effect on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and the surrounding area. This would be
contrary to the requirements of Policies CS1 and CS5 of the Barnet’s Local Plan
(Core Strategy) (CS) 2012, Policy DM01 of the Barnet’s Local Plan
(Development Management Policies) (DMP) 2012, the Council’s Supplementary
Planning Document: Residential Design Guidance (SPD), 2016, and the National
Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), July 2018. Taken together these emphasise
the importance of good design and expect new development to respect the local
context and distinctive local character through high quality design which
preserves or enhances local character and respects the scale, mass, height and
pattern of surrounding spaces and streets.
9. The appellants point out that there are many rear extensions and loft
conversions in Milton Avenue. However, whilst many of the dwellings have been
altered over time, they generally retain their original character. Moreover,
larger additions, including recent alterations at 57 Milton Avenue, have mostly
been carefully designed to reflect and respect the appearance of the original
dwellings, thus preserving their character and that of the street scene.
10. The appellants suggest that as the proposed rear extension is only 2.4m in
depth it would not be disproportionate. However, it is the alterations and
extensions to the roof, above ground floor level, that cause significant harm.
Moreover, whilst the appellants consider the proposed design to be
contemporary it would be poorly proportioned and would neither reflect nor
complement the design of the original bungalow.
11. Finally, the appellants argue that a hip to gable roof alteration and rear dormer
could be built under permitted development rights and that this provides a
fallback. That may be so. However, the proposed extensions are materially
Appeal Decision APP/N5090/D/18/3203904
3
larger and have a significantly greater effect on the character and appearance
of the host dwelling than the similar permitted development drawn to my
attention at 68 Milton Avenue. I do not therefore find that this fallback would
justify allowing the appeal proposals.
12. Turning to the effect of the proposed rear extension on the living conditions of
occupiers of 74 Milton Avenue, this dwelling lies about 2.5m from the shared
boundary and has several side windows facing the appeal dwelling. One of these
is a large window that appears to serve a habitable room. It is set towards the
rear of No 74 and currently faces the rear patio at No 72. Although outlook is
restricted by the high boundary fence, exacerbated by the change in ground
levels between the dwellings, the window has open views of sky above this. The
rear extension would be built opposite this window. That, together with its
proximity and the replacement of the existing roof slope with a blank side wall
that would extend to first floor level would result in a material loss of outlook
that would be overbearing to occupiers at No 74.
13. The Council’s delegated report also raises concerns regarding loss of privacy
due to overlooking from the proposed first floor rear windows. However, this
relationship is a common one in built up areas and would be similar to views
from a rear dormer, such as those seen on numerous properties nearby. I am
not therefore persuaded that any material loss of privacy would occur.
14. It is concluded on the second main issue that the proposed rear and roof
extension would have a materially harmful effect on the living conditions of
occupiers of 74 Milton Avenue with respect to outlook. This would be contrary to
Policy CS5 of the CS, Policy DM01 of the DMP, the Council’s SPD and the NPPF
which, taken together, expect development to achieve a high standard of
amenity for existing and future users which, amongst other things, allows for
adequate outlook.
15. For the reasons set out above and having regard to all other matters raised,
including the appellants’ wish to improve their living conditions, I conclude that
the appeal should be dismissed.
K E Down
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.