Conversion of loft space with a low profile mansard roof to the rear of the property
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 October 2018
by Andrew Walker MSc BSc(Hons) BA(Hons) BA PgDip MCIEH CEnvH
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 12th November 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/Q0505/D/18/3203794
18 Edward Street, Cambridge CB1 2LS
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs M Bruce-Doig against the decision of Cambridge City
Council.
The application Ref 18/0291/FUL, dated 19 February 2018, was refused by notice dated
25 April 2018.
The development proposed is conversion of loft space with a low profile mansard roof to
the rear of the property.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for conversion of loft
space with a low profile mansard roof to the rear of the property at 18 Edward
Street, Cambridge CB1 2LS in accordance with the terms of the application,
Ref 18/0291/FUL, dated 19 February 2018, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: Mansard roof design (6 February
2018); Attic conversion proposal (5 March 2018); Elevations as proposed
(5 March 2018).
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of
the development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
Main Issue
2. Whether the proposed development would preserve or enhance the character
or appearance of the Mill Road Area Conservation Area.
Procedural Matter
3. The Council adopted a new Local Plan on 18 October 2018. As my decision on
the appeal must be made against the policies of the Local Plan currently in
place, both parties were invited to make further comments on the new Local
Plan policies. I am grateful for all of the comments which I shall take into
account.
Appeal Decision APP/Q0505/D/18/3203794
2
Reasons
4. The Mill Road Area Conservation Area is Victorian suburb, with only a few
examples of modern infill. To the north of Mill Road, where the appeal property
is located, there are streets of terraced houses facing directly onto the
pavement, with gardens almost entirely hidden. Most of the houses are narrow
two storey terraced houses built from brick with slate roofs. They mainly date
to between 1880 and 1910 and are interspersed with public houses, industrial
buildings, and former stable blocks. Views tend to be fairly constrained by the
rows of houses and focus along their lengths1.
5. The appeal property is a ‘Positive Unlisted Building’ along with most of the
other buildings on Edward Street. The Council has not specified in detail why
this is the case although the Mill Road Area Conservation Area Appraisal says
“commonly they will be good examples of relatively unaltered buildings where
their style, detailing and building materials provides the streetscape with
interest and variety”. Based on the Appraisal, a matter to which I attach
significant weight therefore is whether the proposal will result in an appreciable
effect on the streetscene, and on the views along the lengths of rows of
houses. I also note Appendix E of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018 ‘Roof
Extensions Design Guide’ which advises a more flexible approach to extended
rear roof slopes that are not visible in the public realm.
6. The rear of the appeal property is largely screened from view. The proposed
roof extension would not be seen from Edward Street. The large industrial
building at no. 18 Upper Gwydir Street does not have windows overlooking the
site and it obscures views from the east and Gwydir Street. There is significant
tree and vegetation screening views from the south. There may be views
possible through this screening from the upper windows of the properties to the
south, along Norfolk Street, although these properties themselves block out
any view of the proposal from Norfolk Street.
7. The result of the above screening effects is that the proposal would not be seen
from any public space. The proposal might be seen from some nearby
properties, such as when standing in the rear gardens of no.s 16 and 18
Edward Street or possibly from the upper rear windows of properties in Norfolk
Street, but the development is away from public view.
8. Further, even when viewed from these limited private areas there would be
limited visual impact. The design of the mansard roof extension would not, in
my view, result in a large box structure. The proposed roof slope above the
dormer windows would be designed at an angle not visually discordant with the
existing roof form, and would not produce as harsh effect as would a horizontal
roof plane above dormer windows associated with a box structure.
9. While no.16 Edward Street may have been built as a pair with the appeal
property, there is not total symmetry. I consider that the proposed materials
would be in-keeping with the Victorian dwelling, including slate for the roof and
sash windows to match throughout. The design and materials would not harm
the appearance of no.18 Edward Street or imbalance the pair of dwellings.
10. As there is no view of the rear roof extension from the street, or from any
pubic area, I do not consider that this proposal has any significant bearing on
1 Mill Road Area Conservation Area Appraisal, June 2011, Cambridge City Council
Appeal Decision APP/Q0505/D/18/3203794
3
the property’s status as a ‘Positive Unlisted Building’ or that it has any
significant visual effect on the Conservation Area as a whole.
11. There are a number of other roof extensions nearby within the Conservation
Area, which have been built as the kind of box dormer to which the Council has
referred. For example, the box dormer at no. 2A Edward Street is highly
prominent and immediately visible when entering Edward Street from Matthews
Street. There are rear roof box dormers very close to the appeal property at
no.s 10 and 12 Edward Street, which can be seen from the rear gardens of no.s
16 and 18 as well as from further afield. Similarly, at no.s 5 and 7 there are
rear roof box dormers which can be seen from Vicarage Terrace which is a
public street. An end-of-terrace property within the Conservation Area nearby
at no. 27 Gwydir Street has a rear box dormer extension which is visible from
that street and its junction with Hooper Street.
12. These nearby box dormer extensions, several of which are obviously visible
from public spaces, form part of the character and appearance of the
Conservation Area. Therefore the proposal would not be out of keeping with the
existing visual context, and in fact it would be considerably less visible than
prominent roof extensions nearby. The proposal would accordingly preserve the
character and appearance of the Conservation Area.
13. In addition to the commencement condition, it is necessary to impose a
condition requiring external elevation material to match the existing dwelling to
safeguard the character and appearance of the host dwelling and area. In the
interests of proper planning and avoid doubt, it is necessary to stipulate that
the development shall be carried out in accordance with: Mansard roof design
(6 February 2018); Attic conversion proposal (5 March 2018); Elevations as
proposed (5 March 2018).
14. Therefore, I find that the proposal would not harm the character or appearance
of the Mill Road Area Conservation Area, and would not harm its significance as
a designated heritage asset. Thus the proposal would not conflict with policies
55, 58 and 61 of the Cambridge Local Plan 2018, which are concerned with
character and appearance of developments within Conservation Areas, or with
guidance in the Framework.
Conclusion
15. For the reasons given above I conclude that the appeal should be allowed.
Andrew Walker
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.