First floor extension to rear
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 21 August 2018
by Stephen Normington BSc DipTP MRICS MRTPI FIQ FIHE
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 3 September 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/V0728/D/18/3203622
54 Mayfield Road, Nunthorpe, Middlesbrough TS7 0EE
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Stevie Peat against the decision of Redcar & Cleveland
Borough Council.
The application Ref R/2017/0865/FF, dated 5 December 2017, was refused by notice
dated 1 March 2018.
The development proposed is a first floor extension to rear.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Application for costs
2. An application for costs was made by Mr Stevie Peat against Redcar &
Cleveland Borough Council. This application is the subject of a separate
Decision.
Procedural Matter
3. The Council has referred to the policies contained with the emerging Redcar &
Cleveland Local Plan (Local Plan). This plan was adopted in May 2018 and
replaces the policies contained within the Redcar & Cleveland Local
Development Framework Core Strategy DPD (2007). I have therefore
determined this appeal on the basis of the policies contained within the
adopted Local Plan.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are:
The effect of the proposed development on the character and appearance of
the surrounding area.
The effect of the proposed development on the living conditions of occupants
of No 52 Mayfield Road with particular regard to outlook and privacy.
Reasons
Character and appearance
5. The appeal property comprises a semi-detached two storey dwelling of brick
construction with a tiled hipped roof located on the southern side of Mayfield
Appeal Decision APP/V0728/D/18/3203622
2
Road. The immediate building group comprises of similar designed properties.
Both the appeal property and the adjoining dwelling at No 52 have single
storey rear extensions. However, the majority of dwellings within the
immediate building group do not have rear first floor extensions.
6. The proposed development would involve the construction of a rear first floor
extension that would occupy the full width of the property and would initially
project approximately 1.8m from the rear elevation. Thereafter, it would be
partly set back from the boundary with No 52 and would project approximately
a further 1.2m and extending beyond the rear elevation of the ground floor
extension. The proposed roof would be mono-pitched which would slope back
to the existing roof and at its highest point it would be higher than the existing
eaves level. Construction materials would comprise of rendered walls and
Etenit Cedral Board in a light grey finish. The rear elevation would incorporate
a Juliet Balcony with glazed doors and a frosted glass balustrade.
7. The Council’s approach to the consideration of proposals for the extension of
dwellings is set out in the ‘Residential Extensions and Alterations
Supplementary Planning Document 2013 (SPD). This indicates that extensions
should complement the design of the original building or, if the alterations are
of a contemporary design, be compatible.
8. The proposed design and materials of the extension would not reflect those of
the host property. Whilst it may be considered to be of a contemporary design,
in my view it would markedly contrast with the appearance of the host property
and that of its immediate building group. The combination of the roof form,
materials and extent of overhang above the ground floor extension would
cause the proposal to appear as an incongruous feature that would appear to
be unacceptably at odds with the design of the host property and those of the
surrounding area.
9. The proposal would not be visible from the street or other public viewpoints.
However, it would be visible from the rear gardens of nearby properties on the
south side of Mayfield Road. In such views, owing to its design, materials and
scale, the proposed extension would appear as an unacceptable prominent and
discordant addition to the property. I recognise that the SPD lends some
support to contemporary designs that are compatible with the design of the
host property. However, in this case I do not consider that the proposed
extension can be considered to represent a compatible addition to the property.
10. Taking the above factors into account the proposed development would
represent an incongruous addition to the property that would cause significant
harm to the character and appearance of the surrounding area. Consequently,
it would conflict with Policy SD4 of the Local Plan. This policy, amongst other
things, requires development to be designed to a high standard that respects
the character of the site and its surroundings in terms of its proportion, form,
scale, materials and detailed design features.
Living conditions
11. The SPD indicates that two-storey rear extensions, because of their height and
massing, are generally unacceptable in close proximity to party boundaries due
to the adverse impact on neighbour amenity. It suggests that two storey
extensions may be considered acceptable where they maintain adequate
daylight to neighbour properties and raise no issues in terms of overlooking.
Appeal Decision APP/V0728/D/18/3203622
3
12. Owing to the proposed set back of the extension adjacent to the property
boundary the submitted plans indicate that a line drawn at 45 degrees from the
centre of the nearest first floor window of No 52 is not encroached by the
proposed extension. Whilst there would undoubtedly be some loss of outlook
from this window, given that the 45 degree line is maintained I do not consider
that this would be of an extent that would warrant the dismissal of this appeal
on that ground alone.
13. The SPD also indicates that balconies will generally result in over-looking and
loss of privacy to neighbouring properties and as a result, are not normally
acceptable. It is inevitable in close knit urban environments that views of rear
gardens would be attainable between the intervening properties from first floor
windows. In most cases the reduction in privacy that this arrangement causes
is within an acceptable degree of tolerance.
14. However, in this case both the appeal property and No 52 have relatively
modest rear gardens. Consequently, the recreational use of the gardens
occurs within close proximity of the first floor windows of these properties from
where views of most of these rear gardens are attainable. The proposed first
floor Juliet Balcony would provide elevated direct views over a substantial part
of the rear garden of No 52.
15. Whilst the extent of overlooking may be no greater than that which would be
attainable from a traditional window, in my view the presence of the balcony
with glazed doors positioned in such close proximity to the rear garden of
No 52 would serve to emphasise the perception of overlooking. This would
cause an unacceptable sense of overlooking and a consequential loss of
privacy. Whilst the balcony would be provided with a frosted glass balustrade
which would offer some mitigation, due to the proximity of the balcony to the
rear garden this would not mitigate the loss of privacy to an acceptable extent.
16. The proposal would not cause a significant loss of outlook from the first floor
windows of No 52. However, as a consequence of the provision of the rear
balcony, it would lead to an unacceptable level of overlooking to the rear
garden of that property. This would result in a significant loss of privacy for
the occupants of No 52 thereby causing harm to their living conditions and
would therefore conflict with Policy SD4 of the Local Plan. This policy, amongst
other things, indicates that development should not have a significant adverse
impact on the amenities of occupiers of existing nearby land and buildings.
Other matters
17. I have taken into account the appellant’s view that a rear extension could be
constructed as permitted development. Whilst this may be the case, this would
be of a smaller scale than the proposal before me which I am obliged to
determine on its own individual merits.
Conclusion
18. For the above reasons, taking into account the development plan as a whole
based on the evidence before me and all other matters raised, I conclude that
the appeal should be dismissed.
Stephen Normington
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 21 August 2018
by Stephen Normington BSc DipTP MRICS MRTPI FIQ FIHE
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 3 September 2018
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/V0728/D/18/3203622
54 Mayfield Road, Nunthorpe Middlesbrough TS7 0EE
The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
The application is made by Mr Stevie Peat for a full award of costs against Redcar &
Cleveland Borough Council.
The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for a first floor extension to
rear.
Decision
1. The application for an award of full costs is refused
Reasons
2. Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) advises that costs may be awarded against a
party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying
for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process. The
PPG states that local planning authorities are at risk of an award of costs if they
fail to produce evidence to substantiate each reason for refusal or make vague,
generalised or inaccurate assertions about a proposal’s impact which are
unsupported by any objective analysis.
3. The basis of the appellant’s application for costs is on the grounds that the
Council acted unreasonably during the consideration of the planning application
which resulted in the decision to refuse planning permission. In particular, the
appellant alleges that that case officer was initially supportive of the proposed
development but the application was subsequently considered by other officers
who refused planning permission under delegated powers without recourse to
any further correspondence with the appellant.
4. It is not usual for planning applications that are subject to delegated decisions
to be considered by senior officers prior to a formal decision being issued.
Furthermore, it is not unusual for senior officers to disagree with initial
recommendations of case officers with a consequential change to the
recommendation of whether to grant or refuse planning permission. This is
part and parcel of a Council’s internal administration and decision making
procedures. The fact that the appeal proposal was considered as part of such
procedures does not constitute unreasonable behaviour.
5. I note the appellant’s concern that the signatories to the delegated decision
may not have visited the site. However, I have no evidence to indicate how
this may have affected the outcome of their decision. The submitted plans
Costs Decision APP/V0728/D/18/3203622
2
accurately show the design and extent of the proposal in relation to the host
property and the adjacent property at No 52. Furthermore, I have no evidence
to indicate whether the initial case officer had provided photographs or failed to
describe the site and its surroundings to the signatories of the delegated
decision to the extent that a failure to visit the site would have prejudiced the
decision to refuse planning permission. On the basis of the evidence available,
I do not consider that a failure of other officers to visit the site contributed to
any vague, generalised or inaccurate assertions about the proposal’s impact
that would demonstrably constitute unreasonable behaviour.
6. The reasons for the refusal of planning permission as set out in the decision
notice are specific and relevant to the application. It also clearly states the
policies of the Redcar & Cleveland Local Plan 2018 (Local Plan) that the
proposal would be in conflict with. This reason was adequately substantiated
by the Council in the Officer Report that demonstrates how the design and
materials of the proposal would harm the character and appearance of the
surrounding area and the living conditions of the occupants of the property at
No 52 Mayfield Road.
7. From the evidence before me it was clear that the Council considered the
planning merits of the proposed extension against the relevant policies
contained in the Local Plan. For the reasons set out in the appeal decision, I
too have concerns that the proposal would cause demonstrable harm to the
character and appearance of the surrounding area and the living conditions of
the occupants of No 52. I came to this decision on the basis of my
consideration of the details and merits of the proposal, having regard to all of
the evidence submitted.
8. Councils are encouraged to be pro-active in their approach to development
proposals and it is often the case that minor amendments may be made to a
proposal during the course of such considerations. I note that initial
amendments were made to the design of the proposed extension during the
initial discussions with the Council.
9. However, I have no evidence to indicate how further discussions following the
agreement to an extension of time in which to determine the application could
have resulted in a more favourable outcome on the application to the extent
that the appeal could have been avoided. Moreover, I do not have any
evidence to conclusively suggest that any lack of any negotiation following the
consideration of the initial case officer view by other officers was a contributory
factor in the Council’s decision to refuse the application.
10. I do not consider that the Council failed to properly evaluate the application,
consider the planning merits or adequately state the reasons for the refusal of
planning permission by reference to the appropriate policies contained in the
development plan that the proposal was in conflict with. I have found that the
Council had reasonable concerns about the harm to the character and
appearance of the area and the living conditions of the occupants of No 52
which justified its decision.
11. The extent to which the proposed development impacts on the character and
appearance of an area is a matter of subjective judgement guided by policies
contained within the development plan. The Council properly considered the
proposed development against the relevant policies contained within the Local
Plan. It is also clear that the design and materials of the proposed
Costs Decision APP/V0728/D/18/3203622
3
development would not reflect those of the host property. Whilst the proposal
may be considered to be of a contemporary design, the Residential Extensions
and Alterations Supplementary Planning Document 2013 (SPD) requires such
designs to be compatible with the host property. It is therefore a matter for
the decision maker to consider the extent to which the proposal was considered
to be compatible with the host property and whether harm would be caused to
the character and appearance of the area as a consequence of the proposed
development. This is a subjective judgement relevant to policies contained
within the development plan.
12. The views of the Council were adequately explained in the Decision Notice,
were relevant to policies in the development plan and were substantiated in the
evidence provided in the officer report. Taking all of these matters into
account, I find that the reasons for the refusal of the planning application were
complete, precise, specific and relevant to the application. I have found that
the Council had reasonable concerns about the impact of the proposed
development on the character and appearance of the area and the living
conditions of the occupants of No 52 which led to the decision to refuse the
application. Accordingly, I do not find that the Council failed to properly
consider the merits of the scheme and therefore the appeal could not have
been avoided.
13. For these reasons, I find that unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary
or wasted expense, as described in the PPG, has not been demonstrated and
having regard to all other matters raised, an award of costs is not justified.
Stephen Normington
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.