Roof extension comprising one rear dormer and one side dormer. On the rear dormer one opening will be made to accept one upvc casement window, and in the face of the side dormer, one opening will be created to allow for one upvc casement window (obscure glass). On the front roof slope openings will be created to accommodate two number velux windows
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 10 August 2018
by Gary Deane BSc (Hons) DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 August 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/Q5300/D/18/3203614
3 Chase Side, Enfield EN2 6NB
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Alex Renolds against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Enfield.
The application Ref 18/00231/HOU was refused by notice dated 15 March 2018.
The development proposed is a roof extension comprising one rear dormer and one side
dormer. On the rear dormer one opening will be made to accept one upvc casement
window, and in the face of the side dormer, one opening will be created to allow for one
upvc casement window (obscure glass). On the front roof slope openings will be created
to accommodate two number velux windows.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural matters
2. The name of the appellant given in the above heading reflects the details
provided on the planning application and appeal forms. I do, however, note
that the name of the appellant stated on the cover to the grounds of appeal
and in the personal statement dated 30 May 2018 is Mr Alex Reynolds.
3. I have assessed the proposed development in the light of the revised National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) that was issued on 24 July 2018.
Main issue
4. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the local area.
Reasons
5. The appeal property is an end-terrace mainly 2-storey dwelling within a row of
similar properties that address one side of Chase Side. The terrace to which
No 3 belongs is within the Enfield Town Conservation Area (CA), which is mixed
in character and includes large expanses of open space and a wide variety of
uses and buildings. In the vicinity of the site, the busy through route of Chase
Side separates a village green on one side, which is Chase Green, and a
residential area of which the site forms part on the other. According to the CA
Character Appraisal, No 3 and the wider terrace make a neutral contribution to
the significance of the designated area as a heritage asset.
Appeal Decision APP/Q5300/D/18/3203614
2
6. The proposal is to provide additional living space at second floor level served
by a new dormer extension on each of the side and rear roof slopes and 2 new
conservation style roof lights at the front. Each of the new dormers would be
set in from all 4 edges of the main roof and clad with tiles to match those of
the existing building. Like the host building, the side dormer would include a
hipped roof while the rear addition would have a flat roof. The new dormer
windows would satisfactorily relate to the fenestration in the building below.
7. Nevertheless, each new dormer would be a highly conspicuous feature of the
finished building given its scale and elevated position even taking into account
the partial screening from some vantage points provided by existing buildings
and some vegetation. Specifically, the new rear dormer would be evident in
the context of the wider terrace from the back gardens of neighbouring
properties. The proposed side dormer would also be visible from the road and
Chase Green with the host terrace beyond. From these locations, the new
dormers, individually and together, would be a dominant feature, unduly
disturbing the clean lines and uncluttered roof slopes of the host terrace, which
appears to be largely unaltered and is free of any significant built additions.
8. The new roof lights would be modest in size and fitted close to the plane of the
front roof slope. However, their high level position would cause them to be
prominent features when seen from the road and Chase Green despite the
partial screening provided from some locations by the adjacent chimneystack.
As the only example of such features in the front roof slope of the host terrace,
the new roof lights would be a visually intrusive and an uncharacteristic
addition to the local street scene.
9. Along the Chase Side and within the CA, I observed that dormers and roof
lights were not a strong or prevailing feature of most properties. While I did
see examples of alterations and extensions to properties at roof level further
afield, these generally served to demonstrate that even modest changes can
have a significant effect on the character and appearance of the host building
and the area to which it relates. None that I observed were directly
comparable in scale or type with the proposal before me nor had the same
relationship to the host building and the streetscape as in this case.
10. I share the appellant’s view that planning decisions should adopt a positive
strategy for the conservation and enjoyment of the historic environment.
However, heritage assets such as conservation areas are an irreplaceable
resource. The process of change within the CA should therefore be managed
that preserves or sustains and where appropriate enhances its significance. In
this case, the new dormers and roof lights would detract from the uniformity in
the appearance of the existing roofscape and be an unsympathetic addition to
the dwelling and the terrace. By materially reducing the contribution of the
host building to the CA from neutral to negative, the proposal would fail to
preserve the character and appearance of this heritage asset. Although the
harm to the significance of the CA would be less than substantial in this case, I
am not persuaded that the public benefits would outweigh this harm.
11. Along Chase Side I saw that some properties had been extended including 1
and 15 Chase Side although none had been changed in a manner that is similar
to that proposed. The appellant states that the plans for the appeal dwelling
could be amended to include a hip to gable extension to match No 15, which is
Appeal Decision APP/Q5300/D/18/3203614
3
at the opposite end of the same terrace as the site. However, my remit is to
determine the development for which planning permission is sought.
12. Reference is also made to 36 Old Park Ridings, Southgate in which a side
dormer extension was recently granted planning permission on appeal. As a
single roof level extension on a semi-detached property the approved scheme
would differ to the nature of the proposal and the type of host building. The
Inspector in that case also draws attention to the diversity of roof forms in the
local area; the asymmetric relationship between nearby pairs; the presence of
similar side dormer on a close by property; and the lack of clear views of the
gable other than from immediately in front of the site. None of these points
could reasonably be applied to the setting of No 3 or the wider terrace. Given
these differences, I am able to draw few meaningful conclusions in support of
this appeal. While dormers and roof lights within conservation areas that are
visible from the public realm can be acceptable, the proposal, which has been
assessed on its own merits, is objectionable for the reasons given.
13. On the main issue, I conclude that the proposed development would cause
significant harm the character and appearance of the local area. Accordingly, it
conflicts with Core Policies 30 and 31 of The Enfield Plan: Core Strategy
2010-2025 and Policies DMD 8, DMD 13, DMD 37 and DMD 44 of the Council’s
Development Management Document. It is also contrary to Policies 7.1, 7.4
and 7.8 of The London Plan. These policies seek to ensure that new
development achieves high quality design; has no adverse visual impact; is
appropriate in scale, massing and bulk; and conserves or enhances heritage
assets. There would also be a conflict with the Framework regarding the
protection of heritage assets and with the statutory duty. This duty requires
special attention to be paid to the desirability of preserving or enhancing the
character or appearance of conservation areas.
14. Once complete, the proposal would provide additional living accommodation
that in turn would enhance the living conditions of the appellant and his family.
The completed dwelling would be better suited to provide the appropriate care
and to meet the specialist needs of the appellant’s daughter than the existing
property. I am sympathetic to this intention and have carefully considered all
the points made in the appellant’s personal statement to his agent. An
interested party also supports the scheme. However, these considerations do
not outweigh the significant harm that I have identified.
Conclusion
15. For the reasons set out above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Gary Deane
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.