Appeal Against Conditions
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 20 November 2018
by Thomas Bristow BA MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 23rd November 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/Y1110/D/18/3203657
1 Tresillian Gardens, Topsham EX3 0BA
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 as
amended (‘1990 Act’) against a refusal to grant planning permission under section 73 of
the 1990 Act for the development of land without complying with conditions subject to
which a previous planning permission was granted.
The appeal is made by Ms Carole Trim against the decision of Exeter City Council.
The application Ref 17/1244/VOC, dated 1 August 2017, was refused by notice dated
2 February 2018.
The application sought planning permission for proposed alterations and extensions
comprising raising roof height by one metre, single storey rear extension, construction
of dual-pitched roof to garage, removal and reconstruction of dormers and other minor
alterations, without complying with a condition attached to planning permission Ref
16/1205/03, dated 9 January 2017.
The condition in dispute is No 2 which states that: ‘The development hereby permitted
shall not be carried out otherwise than in strict accordance with the submitted details
received by the Local Planning Authority on 05 January 2016 (dwg. no. 20-408-06 Rev.
E), 04 January 2017 (dwg. nos. 20-408-08 Rev. E, 20-408-07 Rev. E, 20-408-09 Rev. D
and 20-408-11 Rev. B) and 30 September 2016 (dwg. nos. 20-408-05 Rev. C) as
modified by other conditions of this consent’.
The reason given for the condition is: ‘in order to ensure compliance with the approved
drawings’.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for alterations and
extensions comprising raising roof height by one metre, single storey rear
extension, construction of dual-pitched roof to garage, removal and
reconstruction of dormers and other minor alterations without complying with
condition No 2 attached to planning permission Ref 16/1205/03, dated 9
January 2017. This new permission is subject to an amended version of that
condition and the others set out in the schedule below.
Preliminary matters
2. The dispute in respect of condition 2 is limited to a single plan. Approved plan
20-408-08 Rev. E states that the roof of No 1, as altered, would either be
finished in existing tiles or similar versions. Plan 20-408-08 Rev. F is proposed
in its place, which instead refers to a finish of ‘first quality approved natural
slate’. The Planning Practice Guidance (‘PPG’) sets out that an appeal under
Section 73 of the 1990 Act will consider only the disputed condition(s).1 I have
1 Reference ID: 2a-031-20180615.
Appeal Decision APP/Y1110/D/18/3203657
2
approached the appeal on that basis; there is nothing that I have read or seen
to indicate that the proposal is otherwise unacceptable.
Main issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposal in respect of character and
appearance, with particular regard to the Topsham Conservation Area (‘TCA’).
Reasons
4. No 1 is a somewhat dilapidated detached inter-war chalet bungalow. I
understand that it was originally built as one of four similar properties in a field
behind Grade II listed No 45 the Strand, reflecting a prototype show house
displayed at the Ideal Home Exhibition 1925. In form and understated aesthetic
the existing property does not reflect the prevailing intimate historic character
of the TCA, or the eclectic and intricate detailing of many properties within it.
Nor was it originally conceived of in that light.
5. On account of the narrow and enclosed character of Topsham, as No 1 is at the
periphery of the built form of the town, and given the presence of various
trees, boundary features and planting nearby, there are very few public
vantage points from which the existing property is readily visible. There is
therefore nothing to lead me to a different summary to that in the Topsham
Conservation Area Appraisal and Management Plan, namely that No 1 has a
‘neutral impact’ in respect of the TCA.
6. Any historic interest to the property, or consistency with its class of nearby Nos
2 to 4 Tresillian Gardens, is now not strong (other than in relation to overall
form, which would be broadly reflected in the proposal). I am told that No 1
was substantially extended and its dormers overlaid with dark cladding around
1982. Nos 3 and 4 also appear to have been significantly altered over time,
including by way of front and side extensions respectively, and there is now a
modest dwelling of contemporary design adjacent No 1 in what was formerly
part of its plot.
7. Having also been changed during the 1980s the current roof tiles at No 1 are
not original, nor it appeared are those at Nos 3 and 4. They are small standard
brown concrete tiles in contrast to the warmer and variable colouration of the
original clay finish still in evidence at No 2. Moreover Tresillian Gardens is now
characterised by a wide variety of differing building sizes, designs, detailing,
and roofing materials including also natural and artificial slate and ridged
concrete tiles.
8. I acknowledge that the existing tiles are more akin in size and colour to that
which would have originally been present compared to natural slate. However
they are not original and there is now considerable variety in the character of
nearby properties. Accordingly, and given my reasoning above regarding the
significance of No 1 in respect of the TCA, there is no robust justification for the
disputed condition (which essentially aims to ensure that the remodelling of the
property would integrate appropriately with its surroundings).
9. Whilst the dwelling, as altered, would be larger and taller than at present, that
would not be to such a degree that its prominence would be increased to any
Appeal Decision APP/Y1110/D/18/3203657
3
meaningful extent.2 I acknowledge that the proposal has been through a
protracted process of negotiations and amendments at application stage. Whilst
I have reviewed the history to the scheme, that procedural context has little
substantive bearing on the acceptability of the proposal in planning terms.
10. For the above reasons, I conclude that the proposal would have an appropriate
effect on the character and appearance of the area, including preserving that of
the TCA. Consequently no conflict arises with relevant provisions of the
development plan, including objective 9 and policy CP17 of the Core Strategy
and saved policies C1 and DG1 of the Local Plan First Review.3 Amongst other
things, and in summary, those policies require that development maintains or
enhances local character, including where there is historic integrity meriting
protection in accordance with statutory requirements.4 Disputed condition 2, in
its present form, is therefore not necessary.
Conclusion
11. For the above reasons, having considered the development plan as a whole,
the approach in the National Planning Policy Framework (‘NPPF’), and any other
relevant considerations, I conclude that the appeal should be allowed subject to
the conditions below.
Conditions
12. The PPG sets out that decision notices for the grant of permission under
Section 73 of the 1990 Act should also repeat the relevant conditions from the
original permission unless they have already been discharged.5 As the
development permitted via application Ref 16/1205/03 has not been
commenced, I have imposed a condition limiting the life of the permission in
line with the provisions of Section 73(5) of the 1990 Act.
13. In order to safeguard the character and appearance of the area and in the
interests of certainty, including pursuant to the policies cited in paragraph 10
above, conditions requiring compliance with the supporting plans, and with an
approved sample of the intended roofing material and details of any roof lights
are necessary. I have amended the wording of conditions to ensure they meet
the requirements of NPPF paragraph 55, without altering their aim.
Thomas Bristow
INSPECTOR
2 Plan 204-408-10 Rev. A illustrates the proposed roof overlaid with the existing form of No 1. The roof height
would be raised one metre higher than presently.
3 Adopted originally on 21 February 2012 and 31 March 2005 respectively. Principle 8 of the Council’s
Householder’s Guide to Extension Design of February 2008 appears to relate principally to development that would
alter an existing property less significantly than the remodelling proposed here, notwithstanding my reasoning that
the proposal is acceptable.
4 Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 as amended, reflected in
paragraph 193 of the National Planning Policy Framework.
5 Reference ID: 21a-031-20140306.
Appeal Decision APP/Y1110/D/18/3203657
4
SCHEDULE OF CONDITIONS
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years from
the date of the local planning authority’s decision in respect of planning
permission Ref 16/1205/03 (9 January 2017).
2) The development herby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the
following approved plans, as modified by condition 3 in this schedule:
received by the local planning authority on 5 January 2016 (dwg. no. 20-
408-06 Rev. E), 04 January 2017 (dwg. nos. 20-408-07 Rev. E, 20-408-09
Rev. D and 20-408-11 Rev. B) and 30 September 2016 (dwg. nos. 20-408-
05 Rev. C), and 20-408-08 Rev. F submitted in support of application Ref
17/1244/VOC, dated 1 August 2017.
3) Notwithstanding condition 2, prior to their installation in the development
hereby permitted, a sample of the proposed roof materials and details of any
roof lights shall have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local
planning authority. Development shall be undertaken in accordance with the
sample and details thus approved, and thereafter retained as such.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.