Glazed link and greenhouse/orangery to provide access to the garage and sports facilities from the adjacent main dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 3 August 2018
by Les Greenwood MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 17 August 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/J1915/D/18/3203393
The Coach House, Woodcock Lodge, Epping Green SG13 8ND
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mrs Helen Brown against the decision of East Hertfordshire
District Council.
The application Ref 3/18/0341/HH was refused by notice dated 13 April 2018.
The development proposed is a glazed link and greenhouse/orangery to provide access
to the garage and sports facilities from the adjacent main dwelling.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary matters
2. A revised version of the National Planning Policy Framework was published
before the date of this decision. Having considered the role and content of the
Framework in relation to this case, I see no need to re-consult the main parties
about this change in national policy.
Main issues
3. The main issues are:
i) whether the proposal constitutes inappropriate development in the Green
Belt;
ii) its effect on the openness of the Green Belt and on the character and
appearance of the local area; and
iii) if it is inappropriate development, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness and any other harm would be clearly outweighed by
other considerations, amounting to the very special circumstances required
to justify the proposal.
Reasons
Inappropriate development in the Green Belt?
4. The Coach House is an L-shaped house situated in the countryside and the
Metropolitan Green Belt, accessed via a long private drive which runs past a
grade II listed building, Woodcock Lodge. The proposal would add a glazed link
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/18/3203393
2
between the house and an existing, extended outbuilding, including a widened
section to serve as an orangery.
5. Paragraph 143 of the Framework advises that inappropriate development is by
definition harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances. Paragraph 145 explains that construction of new
buildings should be regarded as inappropriate in the Green Belt, except for
listed exceptions. These include extensions and alterations to buildings
provided that they do not result in disproportionate additions over and above
the size of the original building. Policies GBC1 and ENV5 of the East Herts
Local Plan Second Review April 2007 (LP) similarly allow for limited extensions
which would not, either by themselves or cumulatively with other extensions,
disproportionately alter the size of the original dwelling nor intrude into the
openness or rural qualities of the surrounding area.
6. There is some debate about what should be considered to be the ‘original
building’ here. The Framework defines this to be the building as it existed on
1 July 1948 or, if constructed after that date, as it was built originally.
Based on information supplied by the appellant, it appears that the main
building was part of a sale lot including a 3 bedroom flat, stables and
garaging in 1945 or 1946, and was then fully converted into a dwelling in
the early 1950s. I base this decision on the pre-conversion building, insofar
as that is possible given the evidence provided.
7. Neither the Framework nor the LP Policies provide guidance as to what scale of
increase would be considered disproportionate or limited. A pre-application
letter from the Council dated 2 October 2015 advises that as a general rule if
the original building has been extended over 50% (including outbuildings) then
it could not be classed as ‘limited’. I regard this to be a reasonably generous
guideline and agree that an increase of more than half would generally be
considered to be disproportionate. This rule of thumb, however, has no force
at all in policy terms and can only be used with caution in light of the
circumstances of each case. I note the appellant’s reference to 2 other recent
planning permissions for extensions in Epping Green, 1 of which apparently
results in a 63% increase. I do not, however, have any details of those cases
and have considered this case on its own merits.
8. If I accept the appellant’s submission in regard to the sizes of the original
building, existing extensions and the proposed extension, the overall increase
in floorspace since 1948 would be 47.9% and the proposal would add an
additional 7.1%, to make a cumulative increase of about 55%. With or without
the Council’s rule of thumb, I regard this to be a substantial cumulative
increase in size which would potentially be disproportionate.
9. There is an additional factor here which reinforces this tentative finding. The
appellant’s calculation includes outbuildings which no longer exist and for of
some of which there are no good plans. I accept that detached outbuildings
located close to the main building could be considered to be adjuncts, which
are effectively part of the building for the purposes of Green Belt policies. I
have no clear information, however, on the condition of these buildings in 1948
and do not know the circumstances of their removal. 1 is noted as being a
corrugated garage and may well not have been substantial. The Council says
that 2 of them were stated to be temporary in a 1952 planning application.
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/18/3203393
3
Even though those outbuildings appear to have been on site in the period 1939
to 1952, they may not have been structurally sound enough to be retained.
Subtracting any of these from the equation would significantly amplify the
overall percentage increase.
10. I note that a Certificate of Lawfulness has recently been granted for a 2 storey
extension to the house (Ref 3/17/2689/CLP). The appellant’s statement
advises that this has not been built. At my site visit I noted that works were
underway on what appeared to be an extension. I do not, however, have any
firm information about this and therefore rule it out of my assessment.
11. The appellant further seeks to remove from the equation any built form which
is or would be appropriate facilities for outdoor sport or outdoor recreation –
citing the provisions of LP Policy GBC1(b) and the Framework (in what is now
paragraph 145b). It seems to me, however, that all of the built form at this
site is part and parcel of the residential use of the property, and is not primarily
for any separate outdoor sport or recreational use. Any building or extension
at this residential property could be used for a range of normal domestic
purposes and these uses may change from time to time.
12. The appellant also argues that 3 large greenhouses which existed in 1948
should be included in the calculation. Those greenhouses were set at a
considerable distance from The Coach House and on plan their former site
appears to be outside of the house’s current curtilage. The courtyard garden at
The Coach House may have originally been part of the kitchen garden to
Woodcock Lodge, as the appellant states, but I am not at all satisfied that
these remotely sited greenhouses should be considered to be part of the
original building for the purposes of this assessment.
13. Finally, the appellant also asks for allowance of a margin for error in the
measurements due to the poor quality of some of the plans being relied on. I
consider that my analysis of the situation is reasonable in this regard, in that I
have adopted the appellant’s basic measurements and estimates, rather than
the Council’s.
14. Having taken all of these points into consideration, I find that the proposal
would, cumulatively with other extensions, represent a substantial and
disproportionate increase over and above the size of the original building. The
proposal therefore constitutes inappropriate development in the Green Belt,
conflicts with LP Policies GBC1 and ENV5 and the Framework and is by
definition harmful to the Green Belt. I give this harm substantial weight in
accordance with paragraphs 143 and 144 of the Framework.
Openness, character and appearance
15. The proposal would cause a slight decrease in the openness of the Green Belt
due to its significantly sized built form but limited by the lack of public views
and its positioning as a low level link between existing structures in a location
where there is already a short section of garden wall and a gate. Like the
Council, I find no objection to its impact on the character and appearance of
the building or the local area – or on the setting of the listed building,
Woodcock Lodge, which is some distance away.
16. The harm that would be caused to openness weighs against the proposal, but
only to a limited extent. The effect on local character and appearance is a
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/18/3203393
4
neutral factor that does not weigh for or against the proposal in the overall
balance.
Other considerations and very special circumstances
17. I have already dealt with most of the considerations put forward by the
appellant as potential very special circumstances (use for outdoor sport and
recreation, previously existing greenhouses, allowance for a margin of error in
the calculations and limited impact due to design and lack of visibility), as
these appear to more properly relate to the first main issue. This leaves
2 other key considerations.
18. The first point is about safety. The site is accessed via a long, narrow private
track which then goes around a sharp bend on its way to a couple of other
dwellings. Another section of the lane goes straight on. The site access is
close to the bend and visibility of vehicles coming from that direction is poor
because of the road layout and because of shrubs growing near to the
carriageway. Parked vehicles could partially obstruct vision in the other
direction as well. The appellant is concerned for the safety of her young
children. The link would help to block a direct route from the main garden area
to the lane to keep children from straying onto the lane.
19. I accept that, although the lane must be very lightly trafficked and traffic
speeds should be limited by the sharp bend and the single carriageway width,
there is a significant potential danger if young children stray onto the lane. I
am not convinced, however, that this proposal is necessary in order to make
the situation safer. There is already a wall and gate in place between the
garden and the drive. As suggested by the Council, it may well be possible to
construct a new enclosure if required to satisfactorily accomplish the objective.
Whilst I note the appellant’s concerns over whether this suggested solution
would be permitted development and its potential visual effect on The Coach
House and the setting of the listed building, these matters have not been
tested by any specific proposal.
20. Turning to the second point, the appellant argues that something similar to the
proposal, but not linked to the house, could be built as permitted development
under Class E of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted
Development) Order 2015 as an incidental outbuilding. If correct, this would
be capable of forming a fall-back position that would be a material
consideration. This has not, however, been established by the issue of a
Certificate of Lawfulness. The argument as put forward appears to depend
largely on an assessment that the house’s largely blank eastern elevation is the
building’s principal elevation, which seems doubtful. In the absence of
convincing evidence or a Certificate of Lawfulness to confirm the situation, I
place very limited weight on this alternative as a fall-back position.
21. I also note the lack of any local objection. I find, however, that these factors
taken together are not sufficient to clearly outweigh the harm due to
inappropriateness and the harm to the openness of the Green Belt. I conclude
that the very special circumstances necessary to justify inappropriate
development in the Green Belt do not exist in this case, so that the proposal
conflicts with the above-mentioned policies.
Appeal Decision APP/J1915/D/18/3203393
5
Conclusion
22. For the reasons set out above, and having regard to all other matters raised, I
conclude that the appeal should not succeed.
Les Greenwood
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.