Single storey extension to form garage to front including alterations to porch
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 24 August 2018
by S Harley BSc(Hons) MPhil MRTPI ARICS
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 31st August 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/B2002/D/18/3202775
35 Nicholson Road, Healing, near Grimsby, North East Lincolnshire,
England DN41 7NS
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Ben Chase against the decision of North East
Lincolnshire Council.
The application Ref DM/0126/18/FUL, dated 5 February 2018, was refused by notice
dated 4 May 2018.
The development proposed is single storey extension to form garage to front including
alterations to porch.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. The proposal was described slightly differently on the planning application form
compared to the decision notice. The description above accords with that set
out on the decision notice and appeal form, and is preferred as it more
accurately describes the proposal.
3. Since the planning application was refused the North East Lincolnshire Local
Plan 2018 (the revised LP) has been adopted. As a result the numbering and
wording of Policies has changed. The Council confirms that Policy 2, as referred
to on the decision notice, is Policy 5 in the finalised LP. The wording in relation
to size, scale and density; access and traffic; and impact upon neighbouring
land uses remains the same. There is therefore no prejudice in me considering
the appeal proposal against the revised LP Policy.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are: the effect of the proposed development on the character
and appearance of the area; and the effect on the living conditions of the
occupants of No 37 Nicholson Road taking particular account of privacy and
outlook.
Reasons
Character and appearance
5. The appeal site is in a residential area. The building at No 35 Nicholson Road is
similar in height and original form to the adjoining bungalows although dormer
windows have been installed in the roof. This allows for additional living
Appeal Decision APP/B2002/D/18/3202775
2
accommodation in the roof space and the garage has also been converted into
living space.
6. The properties on the appeal side of this part of Nicholson Road do not have a
uniform building line. They are set back from the carriageway behind a verge
and footpath and have modest front gardens. On this part of Nicholson Road
the building at No 35 is closer to the back edge of the footpath than the nearby
properties.
7. As No 35 is situated on the outside of a pronounced curve in the road and
almost opposite Pine Walk, the property is prominent in the street scene. The
proposed extension would be positioned in front of an original projecting part of
the building. Due to the height and width of the proposed garage, and as the
resulting position would be much closer to the front boundary, it would appear
overly prominent and intrusive in the street scene, detracting from the
spacious surroundings.
8. Due to its scale and position I conclude that the proposed extension would
have an unacceptable effect on the character and appearance of the area even
though the window design and materials would match the existing and the
ridgeline of the forward projection would remain lower than that of the main
roof. Accordingly I conclude that the proposal would be unsuitable in terms of
size, scale and visual intrusion. It would conflict with Policy 5 of the revised LP
and those principles of the National Planning Policy Framework that seek good
design that respects the character and appearance of local areas.
9. The proposal includes minor alterations to the design of a porch that already
has planning permission. These would not unduly affect the character and
appearance of the area. I have seen no indications that the porch alterations
would be progressed independently of the proposed garage and so I see no
reason to reach a separate decision in respect of the porch.
Living conditions
10. The buildings at Nos 35 and 37 Nicholson Road are some 5m apart. The
proposed extension would project forward of the bungalow at No 37. However,
the garage at No 37 is closest to the shared boundary and the nearest living
room window is therefore some distance away. I acknowledge the concerns
expressed by the neighbours about the change in outlook as viewed from their
property. However, due to the distance from the nearest living room window
from the proposed extension, and as the proposed extension would be single
storey, I consider that the outlook from the windows of No 37 would not be so
intruded upon as to justify refusal in planning policy terms.
11. However, there would be a significant change in outlook from the front garden
and drive of No 37 due to the height and position of the proposed garage. This
would replace an open spacious setting with a harmful feeling of oppression
and enclosure for the occupants of No 37. Accordingly I conclude that the
proposed development would be harmful to their living conditions in terms of
reduced outlook. It would be contrary to that part of Policy 5 of the revised LP
that seeks to ensure developments do not impact on neighbouring land uses by
way of visual intrusion, amongst other things, and those principles of the
Framework that seek a high standard of amenity for existing and future users.
Appeal Decision APP/B2002/D/18/3202775
3
12. The proposal includes the re-positioning of a window from the front elevation to
the side facing towards No 37. However, this would predominantly face the
driveway and front garden of No 37 which are already open to public view from
the road and boundary treatment could provide screening. Accordingly I
conclude the proposed development would not have such an unacceptable
effect on privacy for the occupants of No 37 as to justify refusal in planning
terms.
Other Matters
13. I acknowledge the personal circumstances of the appellants; the desire to
provide secure off street parking and their commitment to improving the
property. However, I have seen no evidence to suppose that vehicles parked in
the front garden of the property would be at particular risk. Planning is
concerned with land use in the wider public interest and in this case I do not
consider that the adverse impacts of the proposal I have identified are
outweighed by the personal circumstances of the appellants and family as
described in the evidence before me. Nor is whether or not others park on the
road a matter for me in relation to this appeal.
14. The proposal would neither increase nor decrease the amount of space
available for parking but would replace a space that is, sometimes at least,
used for parking by a space within a garage. Accordingly whether or not the
average numbers of cars per property is high locally; the introduction of
parking controls in the area; and guidance on parking standards do not lead
me to any different conclusions.
15. I have taken into account the examples of other developments which have
been drawn to my attention by the appellant. Each application and appeal falls
to be determined on its own merits and it is rare that circumstances are exactly
the same. From the available information it appears to me that none have quite
the same relationship with established existing properties and the public realm
and they do not lead me to conclude that this particular extension is acceptable
in the location proposed.
16. I note that officers gave encouraging advice at pre-application stage and that
the Planning Committee reached a different decision to that recommended by
officers. The appellant has expressed dissatisfaction with the way in which the
Healing Parish Council handled the planning application. However, such matters
do not go to the heart of the planning merits of the proposal and I have
reached my own conclusions solely on the basis of the material planning
considerations before me. Nor are concerns relating to any delay by the Council
in issuing the decision notice a matter for me in considering this appeal.
Conclusion
17. For the reasons set out above, and taking into account all other material
planning considerations raised, I conclude the appeal should be dismissed.
S Harley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.