Construction of a three-storey and basement side extension to replace the existing single-storey side extension to the property. New extension extends to the rear of the property and includes a dormer window to the rear at second floor and roof level. New external insulation to the existing property, to be clad to match existing. Replacement of existing rooflights with enlargement of these openings, and a new rooflight to the rear roof. New roof tiles to existing property
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 11 June 2018
by J L Cheesley BA(Hons) DIPTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 15th June 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/E5330/D/18/3201037
White Lodge, Westbrook Road, Kidbrooke SE3 0LL
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr Panos Yiasoumi against the decision of the Council of the
Royal London Borough of Greenwich.
The application Ref 18/0511/HD was refused by notice dated 10 April 2018.
The development proposed is construction of a three-storey and basement side
extension to replace the existing single-storey side extension to the property. New
extension extends to the rear of the property and includes a dormer window to the rear
at second floor and roof level. New external insulation to the existing property, to be
clad to match existing. Replacement of existing rooflights with enlargement of these
openings, and a new rooflight to the rear roof. New roof tiles to existing property.
Enlargement of an existing window opening to the rear elevation to create new door
opening onto the rear terrace.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed in so far as it relates to the construction of a three
storey and basement side extension to replace the existing single-storey side
extension to the property. New extension extends to the rear of the property
and includes a dormer window to the rear at second floor and roof level.
2. The appeal is allowed in so far as it relates to the new external insulation to the
existing property, to be clad to match existing. Replacement of existing
rooflights with enlargement of these openings, and a new rooflight to the rear
roof. New roof tiles to existing property. Enlargement of an existing window
opening to the rear elevation to create new door opening onto the rear terrace.
3. Planning permission is granted for new external insulation to the existing
property, to be clad to match existing. Replacement of existing rooflights with
enlargement of these openings, and a new rooflight to the rear roof. New roof
tiles to existing property. Enlargement of an existing window opening to the
rear elevation to create new door opening onto the rear terrace at White
Lodge, Westbrook Road, Kidbrooke SE3 0LL in accordance with the terms of
the application Ref 18/0511/HD dated 13 February 2018 subject to the
following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years
from the date of this decision.
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/18/3201037
2
2) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
3) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: 1109-0001 Rev P1, 1109-0002 Rev P1, 1109-
0010 Rev P1, 1109-0011 Rev P1, 1109-0012 Rev P1, 1109-0013 Rev P1,
1109-0020 Rev P1, 1109-0021 Rev P1, 1109-0022 Rev P1, 1109-0030 Rev
P1, 1109-0031 Rev P1, 1109-0032 Rev P1, 1109-0109 Rev P1, 1109-0110
Rev P1, 1109-0111 Rev P1, 1109-0112 Rev P1, 1109-0113 Rev P1, 1109-
0120 Rev P1, 1109-0121 Rev P1, 1109-0122 Rev P1, 1109-0123 Rev P1,
1109-0124 Rev P1, 1109-0130 Rev P1, 1109-0131 Rev P1, 1109-0132 Rev
P1, 1109-0133 Rev P1, 1109-0134 Rev P1, 1109-0200 Rev P1, 1109-0201
Rev P1, 1109-0202 Rev P1 in so far as relevant to that part of the
development hereby permitted.
4) The rooflights hereby permitted shall be 'conservation rooflights', to sit flush
with the roof slope and shall be maintained as such thereafter.
Main issues
4. I consider the main issues to be:
the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the host dwelling
and surrounding Blackheath Conservation Area; and
the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of occupiers of 34 and 36
Kidbrooke Park Road, with particular reference to privacy.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
5. The appeal site lies with the Blackheath Conservation Area, a designated
heritage asset. The Conservation Area is primarily residential and is
characterised by the predominance of spacious residential verdant streets.
6. The Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 imposes
duties requiring special regard to be had to the desirability: at Section 72(1), of
preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of a Conservation Area.
7. The National Planning Policy Framework advises that when considering the
impact of a proposed development on the significance of a designated heritage
asset, great weight should be given to the asset’s conservation.
8. Guidance in the Council’s Residential Extensions, Basements and Conversions
Guidance Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) (July 2016) seeks to
ensure that side extensions accurately reflect the style of the main house and
remain secondary in size and appearance.
9. The existing dwelling is of traditional design and has a side projection that
detracts from the architecture of the main part of the dwelling to some extent.
The proposal includes the replacement of this side projection with a three
storey side extension with basement. From my observations, due to the scale,
bulk and design of this extension, I consider that it would overwhelm the
existing character and proportions of the dwelling. It would appear as an
exceptionally wide and bulky addition which would dominate the original
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/18/3201037
3
dwelling to such a degree that it would unacceptably erode its original
character and proportions. As such, I consider the proposed side extension
would not be of a scale and design appropriate to the host dwelling. Therefore,
I consider that the proposed side extension would have an adverse effect on
the character and appearance of the host dwelling. In such a prominent
position in the streetscene, this would not preserve the appearance of the
Conservation Area, but this would be less than substantial harm as set out in
the Framework.
10. The proposed side extension would provide additional living accommodation.
This would have only limited wider public benefit. I have attributed
considerable importance and weight to the duty and the presumptive
desirability of preserving the character and appearance of the Conservation
Area, which I do not consider, for the reasons stated above, are outweighed by
any benefits of the proposal. In particular, having regard to the Framework, I
find that the harm to the appearance of the Conservation Area is not
outweighed by any public benefit.
11. The appellant has proposed to increase the front set back to the extension to a
dimension of 300mm. I have not been provided with details of this proposal
and thus have not taken it into consideration.
Living Conditions
12. The proposal includes a rear roof terrace. A terrace balustrade is proposed to
be set back from the edge of the roof terrace by some 900mm. From my
observations and having viewed from the neighbouring garden at 34 Kidbrooke
Park Road, I consider that the height and position of the proposed roof terrace
would create an unacceptable loss of privacy for occupiers of both 34 and 36
Kidbrooke Park Road, when in their rear gardens.
13. I note that the appellant has suggested the inclusion of a screen to a height of
1600mm to the boundary of the roof terrace. Whilst it would go some way to
preventing direct overlooking, due to the proximity of the proposed roof terrace
to the neighbouring gardens, I consider that the neighbours would still perceive
an unacceptable loss of privacy, making their gardens less pleasant places to
use.
14. I appreciate that there is neighbour support for the proposal. However, I
consider it appropriate to take into consideration the living conditions of all
existing and possible future occupiers of neighbouring properties.
Conclusion
15. In reaching my conclusion, I have had regard to all matters raised including
representations by interested parties. I have found that the proposed side
extension would have an adverse effect on the character and appearance of the
existing dwelling, would not preserve the appearance of the Conservation Area
and would have an adverse effect on the living conditions of neighbours.
16. For the above reasons, the proposed side extension would be contrary to
guidance in the Council’s SPD; and contrary to Policies 7.4, 7.6 and 7.8 in The
London Plan (2016) and Policies DH1, DH(a), DH(b), DH(h) and DH3 in the
Royal Greenwich Local Plan: Core Strategy with Detailed Policies (2014), where
they seek to ensure high quality design that positively contributes to the
Appeal Decision APP/E5330/D/18/3201037
4
improvement of the built environment; preserves or enhances heritage assets;
and seek to protect residential amenity.
Split Decision
17. The proposal includes various alterations to the existing dwelling including new
external insulation to the existing property, to be clad to match existing.
Replacement of existing rooflights with enlargement of these openings, and a
new rooflight to the rear roof. New roof tiles to existing property.
Enlargement of an existing window opening to the rear elevation to create new
door opening. The Council has not raised concern regarding these matters and
I consider that these minor alterations would be in keeping with the character
and appearance of the existing dwelling and preserve the character and
appearance of the Conservation Area. Thus, these parts of the proposal would
be in accordance with the guidance and policies referred to above. As these
can be undertaken independently from the proposed side extension and
basement, I consider it appropriate to issue a split decision in this respect.
18. As the proposed basement would be an integral part of the proposed side
extension, it is not appropriate to allow the basement in isolation and I note
concerns regarding underground streams and clay soil.
19. The Council has suggested the imposition of standard time, matching materials
and plans conditions. I consider it reasonable and necessary to impose such
conditions.
20. The Council has suggested additional conditions, most of which are related to
the proposed side extension. Thus, it is not necessary to impose these
suggested conditions. The Council has suggested a condition requiring the
rooflights to be conservation rooflights to sit flush with the roof slope. In the
interest of visual amenity, I consider such a condition to be reasonable and
necessary.
J L Cheesley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.