Two storey side and rear extensions
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 20 June 2018
by David Murray BA (Hons) DMS MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 5th July 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/A1910/D/18/3200562
The Hollow, Toms Hill Road, Aldbury, Tring, HP23 5SA.
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Stuart and J Rouse against the decision of Dacorum
Borough Council.
The application Ref. 4/02422/17/FHA, dated 11 September 2017, was refused by notice
dated 24 January 2018.
The development proposed is two storey side and rear extensions.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the extensions proposed on the character and
appearance of the host property and its setting within the Aldbury Conservation
Area and the Chilterns Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty.
Reasons
Background
3. The appeal site comprises the garden of a detached house with rendered
elevations and a tiled roof, which is located on rising land on the edge of the
village of Aldbury. The proposal is to add side and rear extensions and remodel
the building and its fenestration. The proposal has been revised from the initial
plans which proposed a single gable on the front elevation and a double gable
to the rear one, and it is now proposed to make fewer changes to the roof as
shown on drawing 7129-02 Rev C. I have only had regard to these revised
plans.
Effect on the host building and wider area
4. The host building has modest proportions with a half-hip at both ends of the
roof and small dormer and other window openings, with a central main
chimney in the roof and lower chimney stacks at either end. The side of the
property shows a single gable width but with a single storey cat-slide front and
back as well as a single storey flat roof extension at the front. Overall, the
existing property makes a positive contribution to the character of the
conservation area and the wider landscape of the AONB.
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/18/3200562
2
5. Although the property occupies a prominent position on the inside of a bend in
Toms Hill Road, the roadside shrubs and trees partly screen the property from
the public realm, although the retention of these natural features cannot be
relied on in the long term.
6. In assessing the effect of the proposals I have had regard to the design
principles set out in the Chiltern Building Design Guide (2010). In terms of the
overall form and design of the extensions proposed, I am concerned about the
loss of the half hip at the southern end of the roof and its replacement with a
full hip. Further, this hip would lead to a secondary ridge at right angles to the
main ridge to form the gable. The scale of the partial ‘crown roof’ roof would be
accentuated by the addition of two part-dormer windows on this side elevation.
There would be a similar building bulk shown on the south facing elevation
particularly at first floor level.
7. The bulk and form of the extensions and remodelling would materially change
the design and appearance of the building. Whilst it is not of great antiquity, I
agree with the Council that the present cottage form of the property would be
lost and it would be replaced by a dwelling with an imposing and awkward
form. In particular there would a loss of a simple vernacular form when seen in
the street scene around the site frontage and when approaching down Toms
Hill Road from the north. I appreciate that this individual view is limited to a
short part of the street at the moment but in my judgement the appearance
and design of this dwelling plays an important part in establishing the character
of the area at an entrance to the village and its wider setting in the AONB.
8. I acknowledge that the original scheme has been amended in order to try and
overcome the Council’s stated objections; nevertheless I have made my
assessment on the revised plans. I have also considered the scheme for an
extension as previously approved in 2011 and while this introduced a single
rear gable, the overall design, width and form of the property was retained and
I consider that this permitted scheme was materially different in form. I have
also had regard to the photographs submitted by the appellants’ agent of other
extensions or new properties in the locally. None of these examples suggest to
me that the conclusions I have reached above are wrong in design terms.
9. Overall, I find that the design and form of the extensions and remodelling put
forward would materially harm the character and appearance of the host
property and it would also harm and not preserve or enhance both the
character and the appearance of the Aldbury Conservation Area. Therefore the
statutory test is not met and the proposal would conflict with the requirements
of Core Strategy Policies CS11, CS24 and CS27 and in terms of conserving the
distinctive character of the historic environment and the special qualities of the
AONB.
10. In terms of the guidance set out in Section 12 of the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework) I find that the harm to the heritage asset would
amount to ‘less than substantial harm’ as referred to in paragraph 134.
Planning balance
11. On the main issue I have found that the proposed extension would neither
preserve or enhance the character or the appearance of the host property but
would harm its setting in the conservation area and its contribution to the
AONB. This adverse effect has to be balanced with other considerations.
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/18/3200562
3
12. I acknowledge that the scheme would rationalise and improve the internal
accommodation within the property and would benefit the occupiers. However,
I find that this factor does not constitute a public benefit in the context of the
paragraph 134 of the Framework. The benefits do not outweigh the adverse
effects that I have concluded will arise with the proposed scheme and the
conflict with the development plan. This indicates that planning permission
should not be granted.
Conclusion
13. For the reasons given above I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
David Murray
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.