Two storey side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Open Space
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 19 June 2018
by Jillian Rann BA (Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 09 July 2018
Appeal Ref: APP/P4225/D/18/3200424
959 Oldham Road, Rochdale OL16 4SE
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Miss Emma Cooper against the decision of Rochdale Metropolitan
Borough Council.
The application Ref 18/00154/HOUS, dated 8 February 2018, was refused by notice
dated 6 April 2018.
The development proposed is a two storey side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
the effect of the proposed development on the character and appearance
of the appeal site and its surroundings; and
the effect of the proposed development on the living conditions of
neighbouring occupants at 961 Oldham Road, with regard to outlook and
light.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. The appeal property is one of a small group of semi-detached houses set back
from Oldham Road behind long front gardens. The neighbouring terrace of
houses at 961-967 Oldham Road sits much closer to the street frontage, and
forward of the front elevation of the appeal property.
4. The proposed extension would project for some distance to the side of the host
property, and both its front elevation and its ridge height would be level with
those of the original building. As a result of its height, scale and width in
relation to the host property, and in the absence of any visual distinction
between its roofline and front elevation and those of the original building, the
proposed extension would not appear subservient, or maintain the visual
prominence of the host property. It would instead appear as a dominant and
disproportionate addition which would give the building an unduly elongated
appearance, and serve to significantly unbalance the symmetry of this pair of
semi-detached houses.
Appeal Decision APP/P4225/D/18/3200424
2
5. Whilst the property is set back from Oldham Road behind the neighbouring
terrace, and has a high front boundary hedge, views of the building are
nonetheless possible through the vehicular access gates of the site and its
neighbour at No 957, and above the existing front boundary hedges, and the
proposed extension would be clearly evident in views from Oldham Road.
6. I note that the proposed extension would replace a flat-roofed garage, and is
proposed in matching materials, with a bay window to match that on the
original property. I further note that it would partially screen the existing
cement block wall to the side of No 961 and that it would not create a visual
‘terracing’ effect between the appeal building and this neighbouring property.
Nevertheless, for the reasons described above, as a result of its scale and its
lack of subservience in relation to the host property, the proposed development
would have a significant adverse effect on the character and appearance of the
appeal site and its surroundings.
7. The proposal would therefore conflict with Policies DM1 and P3 of the Rochdale
Adopted Core Strategy, October 2016 (the Core Strategy), and with the aims of
the Council’s Guidelines & Standards for Residential Development
Supplementary Planning Document, adopted June 2016 (the SPD). Amongst
other things these require that all development proposals are of high quality
design, that buildings contribute positively to the townscape, and are well
proportioned, and that house extensions are designed to be in keeping with the
host property and generally should be subservient to it.
8. The proposal would also conflict with policies and core planning principles of
the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework), which require high
quality design, and that developments are visually attractive.
Living conditions
9. The proposed extension would project alongside the full depth of No 961’s rear
garden and beyond. Although it would be set in slightly from the boundary with
No 961, it would nonetheless sit in very close proximity to this neighbouring
garden, and to the rear window in No 961’s rear extension. Whilst its hipped
roof would rise away from the boundary with No 961, the first floor of the
proposed extension would nonetheless be clearly evident from this
neighbouring property above the existing boundary fence. The proposed
extension would therefore appear as a highly prominent and oppressive feature
when viewed from the ground floor rear window and main private garden area
of No 961, and would further constrain the already limited outlook from these
parts of the neighbouring property to an unacceptable degree.
10. The Council has cited SPD guidelines relating to the rear projection of
two-storey rear extensions, the aim of which appears principally to prevent
such extensions from having an overbearing and oppressive effect where they
project to the rear of neighbouring properties close to a party boundary.
Although the proposal before me relates to a two-storey side extension, the
particular layout of the appeal property in relation to No 961 is such that it
would nonetheless project some distance to the rear of this neighbouring
property and, for the reasons described above, I consider that its effect on the
outlook from the ground floor rear window and garden of No 961 would be
unacceptable.
Appeal Decision APP/P4225/D/18/3200424
3
11. Although the proposed extension would also be evident from the first floor
windows in the side and rear of No 961, these windows are situated further
away, and beyond the front of the appeal building, and would therefore
maintain some wider outlook across the front of the appeal property. I
therefore do not consider that the proposal would have a significant adverse
effect on the outlook from these first floor windows.
12. Although the side elevation of No 961 runs for some distance to the front of the
appeal building, it is situated alongside the appeal property’s drive and parking
area rather than immediately adjacent to its main windows or garden areas. I
therefore do not consider that this existing situation is directly comparable to
that which would arise as a result of the proposed extension, which would be
much closer to the nearest ground floor rear window of No 961, and adjacent
to the main private garden area of this neighbouring property.
13. I note the presence of existing two-storey projections to the rear of other
houses in the same terrace as No 961. However, as the proposed extension
would project significantly further to the rear of No 961 compared to these
existing structures, it would have a significantly greater effect on the outlook
from the ground floor rear window and garden area of No 961.
14. As the proposed extension would be situated roughly to the north of the house
and garden at No 961, I do not consider that it would result in a significant
additional degree of overshadowing of this neighbouring property or its garden
area. This appears to be supported by the shadow diagrams which have been
provided by the appellant. I therefore do not consider that the proposal would
significantly affect the living conditions of neighbouring occupants at No 961
with regard to light.
15. However, for the reasons above, the proposed development would have a
significant adverse effect on the living conditions of neighbouring occupants at
No 961 with regard to outlook. The proposal would therefore conflict with Policy
DM1 of the Core Strategy, and with the aims of the SPD which, amongst other
things, require that development proposals do not adversely affect the amenity
of residents through visual intrusion or overbearing impact.
16. The proposal would also conflict with a core planning principle of the
Framework, which requires a good standard of amenity for all existing and
future occupants of land and buildings.
Other matters
17. The proposal would allow the existing boundary wall between the site and
No 961 to be maintained and enhanced, and would allow improved access for
the movement of bins to and from the rear of the property. It would also
provide some enclosure to this part of the site following the intended removal
of trees between the site’s rear garden and Thornham Court, and would create
additional accommodation and enhanced internal space for the use of the
appellant, in a property closer to her parents. However, such benefits of the
scheme are essentially private in their nature, and I do not consider that they
would offset the significant wider harm arising from the proposal.
18. I note that the removal of the existing conservatory would allow for the
provision of a larger rear garden area and the maintenance of a drain within
the site, and that the Council has raised no objection to its removal. I also note
Appeal Decision APP/P4225/D/18/3200424
4
that the extension would have no windows overlooking No 961, whereas at
present the appeal building has a landing window facing that property.
However, I nonetheless find the proposal to be unacceptable for other reasons.
19. The appellant has suggested that the design of the proposed extension could
be changed, to step it back from the front of the existing building, or add
detailing to the brickwork on its side elevation. However, no such proposal is
before me, and I consider the appeal on its planning merits and on the basis of
the plans which formed the subject of the Council’s decision, and which were
the subject of associated publicity as part of the application process.
20. I have been referred to a previous appeal decision for a two-storey side
extension to the appeal property. On the basis of the information before me,
this appears to have related to a proposal for a larger extension and, in
refusing the previous proposal, the Council does not appear to have cited the
effects of that proposal on the occupants of No 961 with regard to outlook.
Having had due regard to the previous appeal decision, I am therefore satisfied
that the nature and circumstances of the current proposal are materially
different.
21. My attention has been drawn to another two-storey side extension nearby.
From the limited details before me, I note that there appear to be some
outward similarities in its design, but also that development plan policy appears
to have changed since it received permission. Notwithstanding comparisons
drawn, I have considered this appeal on the basis of the specific circumstances
and planning merits of the site and proposal before me, and having regard to
current development plan policy and supplementary guidance.
Conclusion
22. For the reasons given above, and having regard to all other matters raised, the
appeal is dismissed.
Jillian Rann
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.