Ground floor rear extension, a two storey side extension and conversion of roofspace
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decisions
Site visit made on 24 July 2018
by Michael J Muston BA(Hons) MPhil MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 25th September 2018
Appeal A Ref: APP/L5810/D/18/3200126
84 Myrtle Road, Hampton Hill TW12 1QB
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr T Mascarenhas against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Richmond upon Thames.
The application Ref 18/0258/HOT, dated 25 January 2018, was refused by notice dated
21 March 2018.
The development proposed is a ground floor rear extension, a two storey side extension
and conversion of roofspace.
Appeal B Ref: APP/L5810/D/18/3200127
84 Myrtle Road, Hampton Hill TW12 1QB
The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
The appeal is made by Mr T Mascarenhas against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Richmond upon Thames.
The application Ref 18/0264/HOT, dated 25 January 2018, was refused by notice dated
22 March 2018.
The development proposed is a rear extension and infill, with two storey side extension,
including loft conversion.
Decisions
Appeal A
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal B
2. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
3. I consider the main issues in each of these two cases to be the effect of the
proposal on
1) the character and appearance of the area, and
2) the setting and ecological value of the adjacent Metropolitan Open Land.
Appeal Decisions APP/L5810/D/18/3200126, APP/L5810/D/18/3200127
2
Reasons
Character and appearance - background
4. Myrtle Road is a residential street, comprising predominantly terraced houses.
No 84 is at the end of two long terraces of houses, dating from the late 19th or
early 20th century. Apart from No 84, these terraces display a uniformity in
height, width, window location and proportions, and positioning of bay windows
and chimney stacks. They also all include some form of vertical division,
mostly marked with brick detailing, between each dwelling. All of this
contributes significantly to the character of the road.
5. No 84 has already been altered. It has different shaped and proportioned
windows and no chimney stack. As a result, it already appears noticeably
different from the other houses in the two terraces, when seen from Myrtle
Road.
Character and appearance – Appeal A
6. The proposal in Appeal A would approximately double the width of the house
above ground floor level and would not include any demarcation between the
existing house and the extension. Two additional windows are proposed at first
floor level, unevenly spaced across the extended frontage, and a garage door
would be included on the main front elevation. All of these new elements
would increase the sense of No 84 being different from its neighbours. In
particular, I consider that the increased width and unevenly spaced windows,
combined with the lack of any vertical division across the new front elevation at
first floor level, would result in the appeal property unbalancing the southern
end of the terrace, appearing out of keeping with its neighbours and causing
harm to the character and appearance of Myrtle Road.
7. The Council has not raised any objections to the other parts of the Appeal A
scheme, including the single storey extension to the rear of the dwelling and
the provision of rooflights in the front roof slope, resulting from the conversion
of the roofspace. I see no reason to disagree with the Council as to the
acceptability of these elements of the proposal. However, this does not alter or
outweigh my conclusion that the two storey side extension in Appeal A would
unacceptably harm the character and appearance of the area, contrary to
Policy CP7 of the Core Strategy (2009) and Policy DM DC 1 of the Development
Management Plan (2011), as well as to advice contained within the Council’s
Supplementary Planning Document: House extensions and external alterations
(2015).
Character and appearance – Appeal B
8. The Appeal B proposal includes the setting back of the two storey side
extension by some 1.5 metres from the front elevation and setting it down
from the ridge of the roof by 0.2 metre. The width of this extension is the
same as that the subject of Appeal A. I consider this part of the proposal to be
an improvement on the earlier scheme, as it would introduce in the side
extension an element of subservience to the main house and to the terrace as
a whole. It would also introduce a clear demarcation at first floor level
between the original dwelling and the extension. However, the extension
would still be approximately the same width as the existing dwelling.
Appeal Decisions APP/L5810/D/18/3200126, APP/L5810/D/18/3200127
3
9. As a result of this width, the uneven spacing of the first floor windows and the
relatively small reduction in height from the main roof height, I consider that
this element of the proposal would still unbalance the southern end of the
terrace and harm the appearance of the terrace as a whole. Because of the
setback proposed in this scheme, this impact would not be perceived from as
far down Myrtle Road as the Appeal A proposal. However, it would in my
opinion still harm the character and appearance of Myrtle Road, when seen
from the southern end of the road.
10. The Council also objects to the proposed rear dormer extensions included in
the Appeal B scheme. These would occupy the whole of the main rear roof
slopes of both the existing house and the proposed two storey extension. I
agree with the Council that these are an unsympathetic addition to the house
and would overwhelm the rear roof slope. On my site visit, I walked
extensively around the area and was unable to find any public viewpoints from
which the rear roof of the appeal property could readily be seen. Glimpses
may be possible from Uxbridge Road in the winter, when the intervening trees
are not in leaf. The fact that the rear roofspace could not easily be seen from
any public viewpoint reduces the weight I attach to the harm caused by the
proposed dormer windows. However, I accept the Council’s point that the
dormer extensions would be visible from rear gardens, from where they would
appear unduly prominent and incongruous. To that extent, they would harm
the character and appearance of the area.
11. In my view, the remaining elements of the Appeal B proposal, including the
single storey rear extension, the rooflights and the door to the cycle store,
which would be set back from the road and would replace an existing garage
door, are acceptable. However, this does not alter or outweigh my conclusion
that the Appeal B proposal as a whole would unacceptably harm the character
and appearance of the area, contrary to Policy CP7 of the Core Strategy (2009)
and Policy DM DC 1 of the Development Management Plan (2011), as well as to
advice contained within the Council’s Supplementary Planning Document:
House extensions and external alterations (2015).
Metropolitan Open Land – both Appeals
12. The appeal site immediately adjoins an area of Metropolitan Open Land (MOL),
also designated as an Other Site of Nature Importance (OSoNI). The Council is
concerned that both appeal proposals may have a harmful impact on the MOL
and in particular on a tree on the boundary of the appeal site. The appellant’s
agent in the Grounds of Appeal tells me that the tree in question sits on
adjoining land owned by the Royal Parks, is dangerous and will have been
removed by the time of my site visit. However, the tree was still in situ when I
visited the site.
13. The tree’s branches overhang the appeal site and these, as well as potentially
the tree’s roots, may well be negatively affected by the proposed building
works. The tree itself is large and can be seen from some distance, including
from the top of Myrtle Road, from the Pantile Bridge over the Longford River
and from Uxbridge Road. It contributes to the value of the MOL as open space
in this area. I have not been provided with any evidence that the tree is
dangerous, is about to be removed, or that the proposed building works can
take place in such a way as to avoid unacceptable harm to its branches and/or
roots. In the absence of such evidence, I conclude that the proposal may well
Appeal Decisions APP/L5810/D/18/3200126, APP/L5810/D/18/3200127
4
be detrimental to the setting and ecological value of the adjacent MOL and
OSoNI, contrary to Policy DM DC 4, DM OS 2 and DM OS 5 of the adopted
Development Management Plan (2011).
Conclusions – both Appeals
14. I have concluded that the proposals in both Appeal A and Appeal B would cause
harm to the character and appearance of the area and that they may well be
detrimental to the setting and ecological value of the adjacent MOL and OSoNI.
In the absence of any benefits of allowing the proposal to proceed that would
outweigh the harm I have identified, I have therefore dismissed both appeals.
Michael J Muston
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.