First floor extension over garage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 6 July 2022
by Ryan Cowley MPlan (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 24th August 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/G2713/D/22/3299593
83 High Street, Great Broughton, Middlesbrough, North Yorkshire TS9 7EF
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr G Falloon against the decision of Hambleton District Council.
• The application Ref 21/02804/FUL, dated 25 November 2021, was refused by notice
dated 23 March 2022.
• The development proposed is a first floor extension over garage.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are:
• Whether the proposal would preserve or enhance the character or
appearance of the Great Broughton Conservation Area (CA); and
• The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the occupiers of
85 High Street, with particular regard to privacy.
Reasons
Character and Appearance
3. The appeal site is located within the southern portion of the CA, with its
boundary running along the rear of the property. Irrespective of whether the
CA is subject to an Article 4 Direction or there is an approved conservation area
appraisal, it is a designated heritage asset as defined in Annex 2 of the
National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF). Policy E5 of the Hambleton Local
Plan adopted February 2022 (Local Plan) and paragraph 202 of the NPPF are
therefore both relevant.
4. In the vicinity of the appeal site, the CA is characterised by a mix of house
types and sizes. Most are two storey, albeit typically modest in size. Stone
facings and red pantile roofs are prevalent, though render, brick and slate roofs
can be seen. Dormer windows are not characteristic of the area, however
notably a public house nearby features a pair of catslide dormers at second
floor, set back from the eaves. There are also notable variations in the roof
height of buildings which, along with the variation in materials, adds interest to
the street scene. The significance of the CA however, in so far as it relates to
this appeal, is derived from the traditional appearance of the buildings, their
composition and typically modest frontages.
Appeal Decision APP/G2713/D/22/3299593
2
5. Along the west side of High Street, within the vicinity of the appeal site,
dwellings sit close to the footpath. On the east side of the road however, they
are typically set further back with generous, often landscaped front gardens.
The terrace adjacent to the appeal property is largely screened from view by
hedgerows and other planting along the roadside. The appeal property however
sits at a partial break in the landscaped frontage, and so the host dwelling,
aided by the contrasting render, stands prominently in the street scene.
6. While the appeal dwelling has been extended, its various offshoots are mainly
at ground floor level and/or to the rear. The modest proportions of the main
two storey part of the dwelling can therefore still be appreciated from the front.
The dwelling does not feature some of the more traditional details found on
older buildings in the area. However, the use of stone, white render and red
pantiles, in combination with its relatively modest front elevation, is
sympathetic to the characteristics of the area.
7. It is noted the proposed extension would feature matching finishing materials.
Furthermore, the use of dormer windows is not alien to the area and would
assist in reducing the mass of the extension. However, the proposal would
significantly expand the frontage of the dwelling at first floor level. This would
encroach on the setting of No 85 and sit prominently in the street scene. The
proposed extension would not appear subservient to the existing dwelling, and
when viewed from the front the dwelling’s overall width and mass as extended
would be out of keeping with those in the immediate area. The proposal would
therefore detract from the prevailing character and appearance of the CA.
8. In relation to this main issue, I find that the proposal would harm the character
and appearance of the area, including the CA, the preservation and
enhancement of which I apportion great weight to. It would therefore not
accord with the clear expectations of statute in this respect1.
9. The proposal therefore also does not comply with policies E1 and E5 of the
Local Plan. These policies seek to ensure that, amongst other things, those
elements that make a positive contribution to a conservation area and its
setting are preserved, and proposals for residential extensions respect the
scale and massing of the original dwelling.
10. With respect to policy E5 of the Local Plan and paragraph 202 of the NPPF, less
than substantial harm would be caused to the significance of the CA, which is a
designated heritage asset. The proposal would appear from the evidence
provided to be advantageous to the appellant, however there would be
insufficient public benefits to outweigh the identified harm.
Living Conditions
11. No 85 High Street is a detached dwelling separated from the appeal property
by a single width driveway providing access to its rear. The driveway is
bounded by a high wall and fence along the shared boundary with the appeal
property. The immediate rear garden area of No 85 is separated from the
driveway down the side by low railings. A large garage building sits at the
bottom of the immediate rear garden area, beyond which there is a larger
expanse of private garden with significant tree and shrub planting.
1 Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990.
Appeal Decision APP/G2713/D/22/3299593
3
12. I observed on site that, while there is a large tree within the immediate rear
garden area of No 85, this area has a generally more open character when
compared to the rest of the garden, with limited screening from vegetation.
This part of the neighbour’s garden is immediately outside their rear door,
features a patio and seating area, and appears well utilised and maintained.
13. The existing narrow driveway between the two properties provides a minimal
sense of separation. The proposed first floor rear bathroom window and rear
balcony would not be immediately on the boundary however would be close to
it. While the roof of the appeal property’s swimming pool provides a limited
amount of screening, the rear roof slope of its garage can still be clearly seen
from No 85’s immediate rear garden area. Views from the proposed first-floor
extension and rear balcony to this part of the neighbour’s garden would
therefore be largely unobscured and at close distance.
14. It is noted that no objections were received from neighbours. However, I find
that the proposal would result in an unacceptable level of overlooking to the
detriment of the privacy of the occupiers of No 85. This would have a harmful
effect on the enjoyment of the immediate rear garden space, and ultimately on
the living conditions of the occupiers of No 85. Views from the proposed first
floor rear bathroom window could be mitigated using obscure glazing, which
could be secured by planning condition, however this would not overcome the
overlooking, and perception of overlooking, from the proposed balcony.
15. In relation to this main issue, the proposal would harm the living conditions of
the occupiers of 85 High Street, and therefore would be contrary to policy E2 of
the Local Plan. This policy, amongst other things, seeks to ensure proposals do
not result in overlooking causing loss of privacy.
Conclusion
16. The proposed development conflicts with the development plan when
considered as a whole, and there are no material considerations, either
individually or in combination, that outweigh the identified harm and associated
development plan conflict. Therefore, for the reasons given above, I conclude
that the appeal should be dismissed.
Ryan Cowley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.