Demolition of existing porch and conservatory, and construction of a single storey extension and entrance link to existing house
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Fallback Position
Heritage & Conservation
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 13 June 2022
by Mr C J A Parker BA(Hons) PGCert MA MRTPI MCMI IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 15 June 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/Y3940/D/22/3296711
44, Haygrove Farm, Junction with Iford Hill East C217 to Westwood Road,
Lower Westwood, BA15 2AR
(address on decision notice: 44 Westwood Road, Lower Westwood, BA15 2AR)
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Mike Hopkins against the decision of Wiltshire Council.
• The application Ref PL/2021/05676, dated 27 May 2021, was refused by notice
dated 6 December 2021.
• The development proposed is described as ‘demolition of existing porch and
conservatory, and construction of a single storey extension and entrance link to
existing house’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matters
2. The address on the application form, appeal form and the decision notice all
differ to varying degrees. It is clear from the submitted evidence, including the
site plan and other drawings, as to the location of proposal regardless of the
exact postal identifier used. I have proceeded on the basis that the appeal site
is the area outlined in red on the submitted location plan.
Main Issues
3. The main parties agree that the appeal site is located within the Green Belt.
As such, the main issues are:
• Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green
Belt, including any impact on openness, having regard to the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) and any relevant development
plan policies;
• Would the harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm, be
clearly outweighed by other considerations so as to amount to the very
special circumstances required to justify the proposal.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
4. The Framework sets out national policy on Green Belts and is an important
material consideration. It is also used by Wiltshire Council to determine
Appeal Decision APP/Y3940/D/22/3296711
2
planning applications within the Green Belt. Paragraph 147 of the Framework
indicates that inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the Green
Belt and should not be approved except in very special circumstances.
Paragraphs 149 and 150 of the Framework indicate limited exceptions to
inappropriate development. Those listed in Paragraph 150 are of limited
relevance in this case and it is not suggested by the parties that the proposal
would fall into any of those exceptions: I concur.
5. Paragraph 149 sets out exceptions to inappropriate development which
includes part c); ‘the extension or alteration of a building provided that it does
not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original
building’. The pivotal dispute between the parties revolves around this point.
Neither the Framework, nor local planning policy, define what is considered by
the term ‘disproportionate additions’. It is therefore, for the decision-maker to
determine, as a matter of planning judgement, whether the evidence before
them would represent that or not. I have proceeded on this basis.
6. The first stage is identifying the extent of the ‘original building’ which the
Framework helpfully defines in its glossary as ‘A building as it existed on
1 July 1948 or, if constructed after 1 July 1948, as it was built originally.’
There is some dispute between the parties as to what constituted the ‘original
building’ as it existed in July 1948. The Appellant suggests the volume of built
development of the main house (that is the element attached to No 45
Westwood Road) was 342m3 pre-19481. The local planning authority considers
that this figure2 should be approximately 333m3. These are the relative
positions of the main parties – there is also the question of a detached double
garage I return to shortly.
7. The next stage is to consider whether the extension or alteration would be
‘disproportionate additions’ over and above the original building. The Appellant
confirms that the proposed link and rear extension, taking into account the
removal of a porch and conservatory, would result in a proposed volume of
roughly 459.1m3. In mathematical terms, the proposal would represent a
percentage increase in the ‘original building’ of around 34% on the Appellant’s
figure or roughly 37% on the Council’s figure3. In both calculations, the
proposed extensions would increase the size of the original building by over a
third.
8. With regard to the detached double garage, I understand that this was erected
following planning permission in 2003, and later planning permission was
approved for use of part of the existing double garage as ‘ancillary
accommodation’ under planning permission 14/07360/FUL4. This is borne out
on the submitted drawings Proposed Ground Floor Plan 1336_P_110 Revision A
and Existing Ground Floor Plan 1336_P_010 Revision A, which indicates part of
the garage floor area being used as an annex.
9. The Appellant disputes that the garage should be included in any calculations
for the building as it is part of the site than the building. Nevertheless, it is
clear from the submitted drawings that the garage – which the Council
considers is about 229 m3 in size - is a normal domestic adjunct with a space
1 Appellant’s Statement of Case, Appendix F – Volume calculations and photos
2 See Case Officer’s Report
3 459.1-342/342*100 = 34 and 459.1-333/333*100 = 37
4 See submitted Design and Access Statement, page 7, Section 2.4 Site history
Appeal Decision APP/Y3940/D/22/3296711
3
for parking a vehicle and an annex to the main house that could be used as
accommodation. Whilst I note that the garage is not attached, the mere fact it
is physically separated from the main house does not prevent it from being
part of the dwelling. In this respect it should technically be considered within
the calculations of the original dwelling against the proposed.
10. However, neither party has provided me with specific details as to whether the
previous garage was part of the ‘original building’ volume area, and if so
whether the replacement garage which is now present was larger, the same, or
smaller than the previous garage structure. The Appellant has indicated that
the ‘original garage was further northwest of replacement but comparable in
volume’5. With little evidence to the contrary I see no reason to disagree. As
such, I do not find that the size of the previous and replacement garage
structures, the latter of which could reasonably be considered as a domestic
adjunct, alters my findings in respect of the percentage changes in volume
proposed.
11. In setting out that extensions in Green Belt should not result in
disproportionate additions, Paragraph 149(c) does not set out a methodology
for assessing this. Whilst the main parties have focused on the volumetric
method it is also important to consider the dimensions of the proposed
development in relation to the original building. In this respect, the proposal
would result in a rear extension spanning across most of the rear elevation by
around 9.8 metres with a depth of roughly 5 metres, with the link extension
having a width of approximately 4.4 metres between the garage and house as
shown on drawing 1336_P_110 Revision A. It is clear, in dimensional terms
from this drawing, that the footprint of the proposed extension would represent
a significant addition to the original building.
12. The Framework makes clear at Paragraph 137, that the essential
characteristics of the Green Belts are their openness and permanence, so any
reduction in these characteristics would also be harmful. In terms of openness
of the Green Belt, the proposal seeks a small, but disproportionate, increase in
the size of the existing building in terms of footprint and floorspace. When all
of these various factors are compared against the original building, it is clear
that the extensions and alterations proposed would further erode the openness
of the Green Belt. The proposal would therefore have an adverse impact on
the openness of the Green Belt.
13. My attention has been drawn to some of the text accompanying Core Policy 51
of the Wiltshire Core Strategy which sets out the purposes of the Wiltshire
Green Belt; including maintaining the open character of undeveloped land
adjacent to Bath, Trowbridge and Bradford-on-Avon. However, it also indicates
that applications within the Green Belt will be determined in accordance with
national planning policy. I have done that here.
14. When taking into account the percentage increase in volume and the relative
dimensions of the extensions in comparison with the original building, I find
that the proposal would result in disproportionate additions over and above the
size of the original building. Accordingly, the proposal would represent
inappropriate development in the Green Belt as it does not fall within one of
the exceptions set out in Paragraph 149 and 150 of the Framework.
5 Appellant’s Statement of Case, Appendix F – Volume calculations and photos, Figure 5
Appeal Decision APP/Y3940/D/22/3296711
4
Other considerations
15. Whilst the Appellant considers that the proposal is not inappropriate
development within the Green Belt, I have found otherwise. In this respect the
Appellant considers that the following very special circumstances provide
justification for it to be permitted in Green Belt terms.
16. In terms of what might be possible through permitted development rights, I
acknowledge the Appellant’s point about being able to build a smaller rear
extension. However, this would be considerably smaller than that proposed,
with a depth of 3 metres rather than 5 metres. Furthermore, whilst it could be
possible to erect outbuildings under permitted development rights which could
impact views through the site, I have not been provided with specific details as
to where such buildings would be erected. Given the doubt of what in practical
terms could be achieved through permitted development rights (as little detail
has been provided) I afford what might be built through the exercise of
permitted development rights limited weight in this case.
17. With regard to the removal of the existing conservatory I note the Appellant’s
view that this is not a sympathetic design to the main dwelling. Its
replacement with a potentially more sympathetic designed structure is
accorded modest weight.
18. The fact that the proposal has not been identified as causing harm to the
character or appearance of the Conservation Area by failing to preserve or
enhance it, as required by s72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and
Conservation Areas) Act 1990, as amended, is afforded modest weight in
favour of the proposal.
Overall Conclusions
19. Paragraph 148 of the Framework requires decision-makers to ensure that
substantial weight is given to any harm to the Green Belt. In this case the
proposal is inappropriate development and would reduce openness of the
Green Belt.
20. Other considerations weighing in favour of the development must clearly
outweigh this harm. Principal among these are permitted development rights,
removal of unsympathetic additions and no specifically identified harm to the
Conservation Area. Whilst I acknowledge these, and all other considerations
put forward by the appellant, Paragraph 144 makes clear that all development
in the Green Belt is subject to stringent national planning policy tests, which I
have applied.
21. In light of this, I conclude that those considerations put forward which weigh in
favour of the proposal fail to clearly outweigh the substantial harm by reason of
inappropriateness. The very special circumstances needed to justify the
proposal do not therefore arise. The proposal conflicts the Policies of the
Framework, the aims of which I have aforesaid, and the adopted development
plan.
22. Accordingly, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Cullum J A Parker
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.