Single and two storey extension to the front and side of existing property
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 June 2022
by G Powys Jones MSc FRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 30th June 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/L3815/D/22/3296796
21 Worcester Road, Chichester, PO19 5DW
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against a
refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Darren Frost against the decision of Chichester District Council.
• The application Ref EWB/21/02193/DOM, dated 14 July 2021, was refused by notice dated
21 January 2022.
• The development proposed is a single and two storey extension to the front and side of
existing property.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural matter
2. Shortly before my site visit the appellant submitted a document entitled
Appendix A, which contained photographs and further submissions in addition
to those contained within the original grounds of appeal. The email
accompanying it says:
‘It is been noted that the attached was not include (sic) as part of the original
submission, however is included in the appendix list in the appeal statement of
case.’
3. An Appendix A was submitted with the original grounds of appeal, is referred to
in the text, and comprises a summary of a legal case. However, at the foot of
the final page of the grounds of appeal reference is made to appendix A as
‘photographs of the surrounding area showing recent extensions.’ Clearly there
has been some confusion in compiling the appeal documentation.
4. The Regulations1 provide that the notice of appeal and the documents
accompanying it shall comprise the appellant’s representations in relation to
the appeal. Clearly, the submission of the new Appendix A on 1 June 2022 is
outside the time limits set out in the Regulations.
5. However, with regard to the photographs, I am satisfied that it was clearly the
intention to submit them, as indicated in the grounds of appeal, and no party’s
interests would be prejudiced if I were to accept them. However, no
justification has been provided as to why I should accept the further late
1 The Town and Country Planning (Appeals) (Written Representations Procedure) (England) Regulations 2009
Appeal Decision APP/L3815/D/22/3296796
2
written representations set out in the new Appendix A. I shall not therefore
take them into account in my determination.
Main issue
6. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the host property and its surroundings.
Reasons
7. The appeal property is a detached brick and tile hung dwelling standing at the
junction of Worcester Road and Durham Gardens in what the Council describes
as a spacious 1970s open plan estate. The dwelling is of a design and
appearance which resembles that era, and similar dwellings stand alongside it
to the south.
8. Worcester Road forms a loop and is the main distributor in this part of the
wider estate. Several culs-de-sac lead off the road. The layout was designed
in a manner such that the entrances to most of the culs-de-sac are generously
wide and landscaped, so as to convey the distinct impression of spaciousness.
Like most dwellings fronting Worcester Road, the appeal property is well set
back from the road, which adds to the perception of pleasant spaciousness
experienced in this part of the estate.
9. The main element of the proposals is a two storey side extension, which would
be built on land currently occupied by a garage and a car space. The intention
is that the hedge which currently separates the car space from a footway
leading into the cul-de-sac would remain. A single storey projection is also
proposed at the front.
10. The Council comments that the garage and car space occupy land ‘outside the
original residential curtilage of the dwellinghouse and forms open plan
vegetated amenity land for the estate’.
11. The appellant however has established that the garage and car space have
existed for a considerable time, and I’ve not been made aware of any
enforcement action taken by the Council to seek their removal. On the
evidence of what I saw, it seems to me that the garage and car space have
served the dwelling for a reasonable purpose for some time, and on that basis,
it would be wrong for me to treat the land on which they stand as ‘amenity’
land in the sense used by the Council.
12. Nevertheless, since the garage is of a modest size and single storey and the
car space is open, they do not materially impinge upon or detract from the
sense of spaciousness currently perceived at the junction. The two storey
extension could not be regarded in the same light.
13. The dwelling would be considerably lengthened, with the extension’s projected
ridge at the same height as the original dwelling. Whilst openings and pattern
of fenestration would match those of the existing dwelling, the finished building
would appear disproportionately long and visually unbalanced, and the
outcome would be a significant visual incursion of a bulky extension materially
impinging upon the sense of spaciousness currently experienced at the
junction.
Appeal Decision APP/L3815/D/22/3296796
3
14. The side extension would also stand noticeably proud of the front building line
of those dwellings behind it in Durham Gardens. From within the cul-de-sac,
the side extension would be seen as projecting intrusively, narrowing and
impinging upon the sense of space currently perceived at the mouth of the cul-
de-sac.
15. I therefore conclude that the proposed extensions would harm the character
and appearance of the host property and its surroundings. A clear conflict
arises with those provisions of policy 33 of the Chichester Local Plan, which I
regard as the most relevant development plan policy in the context of this
appeal. This stresses the importance attached to design in new residential
development, and that proposals should respect the character of the
surrounding area and its setting.
Other matters
16. I have taken account of all other matters raised in the representations,
including the photographs submitted late. These are meant to show that
similar developments to that proposed have taken place in Worcester Road and
the wider estate. They are of limited value in my assessment since generally
they do not show the developments in their wider context, and no addresses
are provided. Where I was able to decipher one or two of the locations from
street signs appearing in the photographs, one development took place in
Norwich Road some distance away from the appeal site, and the other at the
end rather than at the mouth of a junction in Bristol Gardens. Whilst I have
taken account of the photographs, I have determined the appeal on its specific
merits, particularly having regard to the visual evidence of my site inspection.
17. I have taken into account of the various references to national policy.
However, the government attaches considerable importance to design, and the
Framework2 provides that:
Good design is a key aspect of sustainable development, creates better places
in which to live and work and helps make development acceptable to
communities.
18. The Framework also provides that ‘development that is not well designed
should be refused’. I intend to follow that advice here.
19. I note the comments made by a local resident and the local residents
association. Both make the point that the development may be used in future
as a separate dwelling or a HMO. I have given these points no weight since
even if the appeal had succeeded, separate planning permissions would be
required for those types of proposals.
20. All other matters raised have been taken into account but none outweighs
those considerations which led me to my conclusions.
G Powys Jones
INSPECTOR
2 National Planning Policy Framework at paragraph 126
Appeal Decision APP/L3815/D/22/3296796
4
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.