For the demolition of existing rear and side single storey additions and erection of side return and side infill ground floor extensions. Erection of a first floor extension. Alteration of the existing garage roof. Addition of new side and rear openings at first and loft level. erection of two storey side extension and single storey rear extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 21 June 2022
by Elizabeth Lawrence BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 6TH July 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/Z5630/D/22/3296552
14 Balaclava Road, Surbiton, KT6 5PN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Ms Joanna Kheir against the decision of the Royal Borough of
Kingston Upon Thames.
• The application Ref 21/03760/HOU, dated 24 November 2021, was refused by notice
dated 20 January 2022.
• The development proposed is for the demolition of existing rear and side single storey
additions and erection of side return and side infill ground floor extensions. Erection of
a first floor extension. Alteration of the existing garage roof. Addition of new side and
rear openings at first and loft level. erection of two storey side extension and single
storey rear extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of the
occupiers of 12 Balaclava Road (No.12), with regard to visual impact, daylight
and sunlight.
Reasons
3. The appeal site is located within the Victoria Avenue Conservation Area (VACA).
The VACA is a small residential conservation area which is characterised by
uniformly sited two and a half storey detached and semi-detached Victorian
and early Edwardian villas constructed from limited designs and palettes of
materials. The villas are set back from the tree lined streets behind small front
gardens and have deep rear gardens. The soft planting within the gardens and
the streets add to the traditional suburban and spacious character and
appearance of the VACA. These features all contribute to the significance of
the VACA.
4. The appeal dwelling is located on the northwest edge of the VACA, at the end
of a row of semi-detached two and a half storey Victorian villas. On the other
side of the appeal dwelling is pair of more recent two storey semi-detached
houses.
5. The appeal building is constructed from red brick under a plain tiled hipped
roof, with catslide features. There are triangular dormer windows and bay
windows on the front elevation and to the side of the appeal dwelling is a white
Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/22/3296552
2
painted flat roofed garage. To the rear the appeal dwelling has a two storey
wing with a gable roof and a single storey extension which wraps around the
rear and part of the flank elevation of the projecting wing. This single storey
extension has a shallow pitched roof, which is visible from the street scene,
above the flat roof of the garage.
6. With the proposal a catslide roof would be formed over the existing side
extension and the gap between this extension and the garage would be filled.
A false pitched roof would run along the side of the dwelling and the front of
the garage, where it would join the roof canopy over the porch. The flat roof
behind the false pitch would comprise a green roof within a modular tray
system. A small part of the proposed catslide roof would also be visible from
the street scene, where it would follow the line of the hipped roof of the front
dormer.
7. On the opposite side of the existing rear projection would be a modest sized
single storey extension with a steeply pitched mono-pitched roof to reflect the
pitch of the proposed catslide roof. To the front of the resultant rear projection
would be a single storey extension with a flat green roof.
Living conditions
8. Amongst other things policy D3 of The London Plan and policy DM10 of the
Royal Borough of Kingston Upon Thames Local Development Framework Core
Strategy 2012 (LDF), seek to ensure that regard is given to the occupiers of
neighbouring properties and that appropriate outlook, sunlight and daylight is
achieved.
9. The plain gable wall of the existing singe storey rear/side extension forms a
continuous built line with the existing boundary wall between the appeal
dwelling and No.12. The flank wall of this extension is approximately four
metres in depth and projects beyond a solid entrance door in the side elevation
of No.12. It is taller than the proposed single storey side extension, whose
shallow mono-pitched roof would be hipped away from No.12.
10. Towards the front of the appeal dwelling is an attached flat roofed garage
which projects onto the existing boundary wall and whose guttering overhangs
the boundary with No.12. The flank wall of the existing garage sits opposite a
modest sized secondary bedroom window at No.12. The main window that
serves the bedroom is unobstructed and faces towards Balaclava Road. With
the proposal the depth and height of the garage building would be increased.
It would have a sedum flat roof enclosed by a false pitched roof, which would
be hipped away from the boundary with No.12.
11. The gap between the existing garage and rear/side extension comprises an
enclosed yard area, which is over six metres deep and some two metres wide.
The majority of the existing boundary wall along this stretch of the boundary
with No.15 is approximately one metre high. The study window and an
entrance door at No.15 face towards this yard area.
12. The proposed single storey side extension includes the extended garage, whose
roof would be hipped away from the boundary with No.12. Attached to the
rear would be a slightly lower single storey extension, with a mono-pitched
roof, which would project up to the rear building line of the existing single
storey rear extension. All parts of the resultant extension would sit on the line
Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/22/3296552
3
of the existing boundary wall, although the eaves and guttering are designed to
prevent any part of the extension from overhanging the boundary with No.12.
13. The appellant has submitted a daylight and sunlight report, which has been
prepared in accordance with British Standard BS 8206: Part 2: Light for
Buildings – Code of Practice for Daylighting. The report sets out the results of
the daylight and sunlight assessments for the two ground and two first floor
windows in the adjacent flank elevation of the flats at No.12. It concludes that
in relation to all four windows the proposal is compliant with the BRE
recommendations for daylight and sunlight. Also, that the with the proposal,
the sunlight within the rear garden at No.12 would be unchanged.
14. Having regard to the juxtaposition between the two dwellings, their orientation
and the size, form and proximity of the existing and proposed extensions, I
have no reason to disagree with these findings. In addition, one of the existing
ground floor entrance doors serves the entrance to the first floor flat and the
other, which serves the ground floor flat, has minimal glazing and is located
within a porch. For these reasons I find that the proposal would not result in a
material and unacceptable loss of daylight or sunlight for the occupiers of the
adjacent flats at No12.
15. Regarding visual impact, the ground floor study window is located opposite the
existing enclosed yard on the appeal site. Although this yard area is only a
couple of metres wide and the outlook from the study window is towards the
main flank wall of the appeal dwelling, the courtyard provides some relief from
the sense of enclosure created by the various flank walls of both properties.
16. With the proposal the flank wall of the resultant extension would sit on the line
of the existing boundary wall and a small stretch of it would be close to the
study window. As a result, the direct outlook from this one window would be
oppressive and overbearing. It would have a material enclosing impact within
the room it serves, which would unacceptably harm the living conditions of the
occupier(s) of the adjacent ground floor flat at No.12. This harm could not be
satisfactorily dealt with by condition and would outweigh the benefits for the
appellant and their family that would result from the proposed additional floor
area.
17. Conversely, one of the entrance doors serves the entrance to the first floor flat
and the other has limited glazing and is located within a porch. The side
bedroom window already faces directly towards the adjacent flank wall of the
existing garage and that room benefits from an open outlook over the front
garden from its main larger window. For these reasons the proposal would not
have a materially harmful impact on the outlook from the ground floor
bedroom or the entrance doors.
18. Finally, the outlook from the existing first floor windows in the flank wall of
No.12 would be very little changed with the proposal.
19. I conclude on the main issue that due to the proximity of the study window to a
short stretch of the resultant flank wall of the single storey extension, the
proposal would be visually overbearing and would unacceptably harm the living
conditions of the occupiers of the adjacent ground floor flat at No.12.
Accordingly, the proposal would conflict with policy D3 of the London Plan and
LDF Policy DM10.
Appeal Decision APP/Z5630/D/22/3296552
4
Other matters
20. Section 72 of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990
requires that when assessing proposals for new development within a
conservation area, special attention shall be paid to the desirability of
preserving or enhancing its character or appearance. Section 16 of the
National Planning Policy Framework 2021(framework), states that when
considering the impact of a development on the significance of a designated
heritage asset great weight should be given to its conservation. Any harm
requires clear and convincing justification. Where a proposal would lead to less
than substantial harm to a designated heritage asset, this harm should be
weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. In addition, any harm to a
non-designated heritage asset should be taken into account, and a balanced
judgement is required having regard to the scale of any harm and the
significance of the heritage asset.
21. Policies HC1 of The London Plan and policies CS8 & DM12 of the Royal Borough
of Kingston Upon Thames Local Development Framework Core Strategy 2012
(LDF), are consistent with this. Amongst other things Policy D3 of the London
Plan and LDF Policy DM10 require high standards of design which reflect and
respect their surroundings.
22. Due to its mass, form, design detailing, fenestration and materials I find that,
visually, the proposal has been sensitively and imaginatively designed. It
would respect and reinforce the character and appearance of the host dwelling,
the street scene, the rear garden environment and would not have a terracing
effect. The proposal would also preserve the character and appearance of the
VACA and would not detract from its significance. In these respects, the
proposal would comply with LDF Policies CS8, DM10 & DM12, policy D3 of The
London Plan and sections 12 & 16 of the Framework.
23. Finally, I note that due to the narrow width of the access path at No.72 it could
be difficult moving large objects into and out of the flats accessed from it. The
proposed flank wall along the boundary would add to the level of enclosure
above the height of the existing boundary wall, in the vicinity of one of the
entrance doors. It is not unusual for tall boundary walls/fence to run along
side boundaries where there are entrance doors and in this instance the impact
of the proposal would be partially offset by the removal of the overhanging
guttering within the front section of the path. Accordingly, this is not a matter
which would weigh against the appeal proposal.
Conclusion
24. Whilst I have found in favour of the appellant on most issues, the conclusion on
the main issue represents a compelling reason for dismissing this appeal.
Elizabeth Lawrence
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.