Extension at rear and side of property at ground and first floors
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 June 2022 by G Sibley MPLAN MRTPI
Decision by Hollie Nicholls FdA MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 9th August 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/C4615/D/22/3296009
19 Corfe Road, Coseley WV14 9HP
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr R Fisher against the decision of Dudley Metropolitan Borough
Council.
• The application Ref P21/2119, dated 19 November 2021, was refused by notice dated
14 February 2022.
• The development proposed is extension at rear and side of property at ground and first
floors.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure
2. The site visit was undertaken by an Appeal Planning Officer whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Preliminary Matter
3. The single storey side extension has been built whilst the single storey
extension to the rear is under construction. Planning permission
(Ref:P20/1740) has already been granted for these elements and the main
difference between the scheme that has been built and that proposed would be
the proposed two-storey extension as well as a roof over the ground floor bay
window. Accordingly, given that this has already been implemented it is a
material consideration which I will have regard to in this decision, although the
scheme will be determined on its own merits.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are:
• the effect of the proposal upon the character and appearance of the host
dwelling and the street scene;
• the effect of the proposal upon the living conditions of the occupiers of
17 Corfe Road with regard to light and outlook; and
• the effect of the proposal upon the living conditions of the occupiers of
21 Corfe Road with regard to light and outlook.
Appeal Decision APP/C4615/D/22/3296009
2
Reasons for the Recommendation
Character and appearance
5. No 19 is a semi-detached dwelling with a hipped roof and a single storey side
extension that has a pitched side gabled roof. The proposed two-storey
extension would be located above the rear single storey extension that extends
beyond the flank wall of the house and would be visible above the single storey
side extension. The two-storey side extension would have a hipped roof that
would be set below the ridge of the host dwelling. Given the limited width and
height of the single storey and two-storey side extensions they would be of an
appropriate scale to the host dwelling.
6. The proposed extension forward of the front elevation would be limited in
height and depth and would use similar materials to the host dwelling. This has
effectively already been built, although the roof of the as built porch extends
over the ground floor bay window. Accordingly, this element of the proposal
would appear subordinate to the host dwelling.
7. The as built single storey side extension has a steep pitched roof over it and
only a small proportion of the front elevation of the proposed two-storey
extension would be visible above it. Consequently, the lack of fenestration
detail on this front elevation would not appear prominent within the street
scene, especially given the significant setback of the proposed two-storey
extension. Moreover, the single storey side extension includes fenestration
detail and as a result, the side extension when viewed as a whole would not
present a blank elevation. This, combined with the limited width of the
proposal, would ensure that the form and mass of the extension would appear
concordant with the host dwelling. Moreover, the proposed use of similar
materials in the construction of the extension would ensure that the proposal
would appear congruous with the dwelling.
8. The extension proposed to the rear of the dwelling would be well screened from
the roadside by the dwelling itself as well as the neighbouring properties. The
roof would be set below the ridge of the host dwelling and the limited scale of
this extension, as well as the materials proposed would ensure that the form,
siting, scale and mass of the proposals to the rear would be appropriate with
the host dwelling.
9. The surrounding dwellings are similar in appearance to No 19 and similar
extensions have been built within the street scene. The limited scale of the
two-storey extension would ensure that the symmetry across the two attached
properties would not be unbalanced. Furthermore, given the layout of the
houses in this area, the two-storey extension would be well screened from the
street scene. Given the subservient scale and appearance of the proposal, it
would not introduce an alien feature to the street scene and would be
responsive to the character of the surrounding area.
10. Therefore, the proposed development would not harm the character and
appearance of host dwelling or the street scene. Consequently, the proposal
would comply with Policy ENV2 of the Black Country Core Strategy (CS)
(adopted 2011) and Policies L1 and S6 of the Dudley Borough Development
Strategy (DS) (adopted 2017). These policies state that extensions will be
permitted where the design of the development is of an appropriate form,
siting, scale and mass, with the use of appropriate materials which respect and
Appeal Decision APP/C4615/D/22/3296009
3
are responsive to the context and character of the surrounding area. Moreover,
the proposal would accord with the Planning Guidance Note No. 17 House
Extension Design Guide (PGN17) insofar as it seeks to ensure that extensions
and alterations relate to the character of the original house in terms of scale,
materials and design details. Finally, the proposal would accord with the
general design policies of the National Planning Policy Framework (Framework)
Living conditions of the occupiers of No 17
11. The flank wall of the proposed two-storey rear extension would be built in line
with the boundary between No 19 and the attached dwelling (No 17). The
closest window on the first floor of No 17 serves a bedroom which is a
habitable room. Planning Guidance Note No 12 The 45 Degree Code (PGN12)
states that for an extension to comply with the 45-degree code they should be
designed so as not to cross the appropriate 45-degree line from an adjoining
neighbours nearest window which lights a habitable room. The purpose of this
is to ensure that an extension would not seriously affect a neighbour’s outlook,
daylight or privacy. It is accepted by the appellant that the two-storey rear
extension would cross this 45-degree line from the bedroom window at No 17.
12. No 19 is located to the north of No 17 and as such, the extension would not
block the path of the sun as it passes the bedroom window during most of the
day. Accordingly, the proposal would not lead to a harmful loss of sunlight.
However, the siting and depth of the extension relative to this window would
give rise to a minor impact on the amount of daylight enjoyed within the room.
13. In terms of outlook, the window in the bedroom currently has a clear and
unobstructed outlook over the fields to the rear. Due to the depth and siting of
the proposed extension relative to the window, the view would be much more
restricted to the domineering flank wall of the extension. Consequently, and
despite that some views would be maintained to the countryside to the rear
and in a westwards direction, the extension would be an overbearing feature
that would harm the outlook from the bedroom of No 17.
14. Whilst the proposal would bring the rear elevation of the first floor of the house
closer to the garden at No 17, the proposal would not extend further along the
shared boundary than the existing single storey extension. When the
neighbouring occupiers are standing within the patio closest to the proposed
extension it would only extend a very short distance into this patio area.
Accordingly, given the limited distance it would extend into the rear patio area,
the outlook from this patio would not be harmfully enclosed by the proposal.
Additionally, the open outlook from this patio, as well as the siting of the
proposed extension, would ensure it would not appear overbearing from this
patio area or the garden to the rear of it.
15. The proposed two-storey extension would be set back a significant distance
from the larger patio area on the opposite side of the single storey extension at
No 17. Given this distance and the limited height of the proposal compared to
the host dwelling, it would not harmfully enclose this area or appear
overbearing from it. Moreover, the orientation of the two houses would ensure
that these patio areas would not be significantly overshadowed by this
proposal.
16. Therefore, whilst the proposal would not harm the living conditions of the
occupiers when viewed from the garden and rear patio, the proposed
Appeal Decision APP/C4615/D/22/3296009
4
development would seriously harmfully affect the outlook and daylight from the
first-floor bedroom. Though the Planning Guidance Note Nos. 12 and 17 are
guidance, I regard the impacts as being harmful and, as a result, the proposal
would harm the living conditions of the occupiers of No 17 with regard to both
outlook and daylight. Consequently, the proposal would conflict with Policy L1
of the DS which states that the development should be appropriate in its
locality and would not cause unacceptable harm to the amenities of the
occupiers of neighbouring dwellings.
Living conditions of the occupiers of No 21
17. The two windows on the flank wall of No 21 that face towards the proposed
flank wall of the extension are both obscure glazed windows. One window
serves the upstairs landing and the other serves the bathroom. Given that
neither of these windows serve habitable rooms, the proposal would not
unacceptably harm the light or outlook of a habitable room and thus would not
harm the living conditions of the occupiers of No 21.
18. Therefore, the proposal would not harm the living conditions of the occupiers of
No 21. Consequently, the proposal would comply with DS Policy L1 insofar as
the proposal, in this instance, would not cause unacceptable harm to the
amenities of the occupiers of the neighbouring dwelling. Moreover, it would
accord with PGN17 for the same reason.
Other Matters
19. The proposal would provide a larger and improved living accommodation for
the appellant, but this would be a private benefit for the appellant and would
not justify the identified harm.
Conclusion and Recommendation
20. The proposal would harm the living conditions of the occupiers of No 17. Whilst
the proposal would not harm the character or appearance of the dwelling or the
street scene or harm the living conditions of the occupiers of No 21, this would
not overcome the identified harm. The proposal would conflict the local policies
in respect of living conditions. I therefore find that it would conflict with the
development plan taken as a whole and there are no material considerations
that outweigh this conflict.
21. For the reasons given above and having had regard to all other matters raised,
I recommend that the appeal should be dismissed.
G Sibley
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Inspector’s Decision
22. I have considered all the submitted evidence and the Appeal Planning Officer’s
report and, on that basis, I agree with the recommendation and shall dismiss
the appeal.
H Nicholls
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.