Erection of a single storey building to form a self- contained granny annexe ancillary to The Annexe to Embercombe Cottage
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Trees & Landscape
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 August 2022
by Martin Andrews MA(Planning) BSc(Econ) DipTP & DipTP(Dist) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 2nd September 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/P1133/D/22/3294252
Embercombe Cottage, Higher Ashton, Exeter EX6 7QT
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 against
a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs Short against the decision of Teignbridge District
Council.
• The application, Ref. 21/01897/HOU, dated 17 August 2021, was refused by notice
dated 24 February 2022.
• The development proposed is the erection of a single storey building to form a self-
contained granny annexe ancillary to The Annexe to Embercombe Cottage.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the erection of a
single storey building to form a self-contained granny annexe ancillary to The
Annexe to Embercombe Cottage, Higher Ashton, Exeter in accordance with the
terms of the application, Ref. 21/01897/HOU, dated 17 August 2021, subject to
the conditions in the attached Schedule.
Clarification and Main Issue
2. As a matter of clarification and notwithstanding the information on the
application and appeal forms, the host dwelling is more accurately identified as
The Annexe to Embercombe Cottage. The dwelling is in separate ownership and
occupation from Embercombe Cottage itself which is the listed building. The
owners of the Annexe to Embercombe Cottage now seek permission for a
‘Granny Annexe’ at its rear and I have amended the application description
accordingly.
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the setting of a
designated heritage asset, the Grade II listed Embercombe Cottage.
Reasons
4. The Statement accompanying the planning application has in my view made a
sufficiently sound case for the provision of ‘granny annexe’ ancillary
accommodation at the appeal site. In reaching this view, I have taken account
of representations to the contrary from the occupiers of the listed building. With
that point made, the main issue can be refined as whether the appeal scheme
would be acceptable as regards the effect of the proposed building’s siting and
scale on the heritage asset.
Appeal Decision APP/P1133/D/22/3294252
2
5. In this context, the Council’s reason for refusal refers to the annexe’s proposed
impact within the curtilage of the heritage asset citing fragmentation of that
curtilage and ‘dominance’ of the asset itself. I have noted the views of the
conservation officer in terms of fragmentation and curtilage. However, I accept
the appellant’s argument, supported by the fact of now separate lawful
ownership and occupation, Case Law and my own observations of the current
on-site circumstances, that the host dwelling and land within the red line of the
application are not within the curtilage of the listed building.
6. The Householder procedure for this appeal precludes any further counter
argument by the Council on this aspect, but in any event my assessment of the
effect on the setting of the listed building and whether harm would be caused
relies essentially on the spatial relationship between it and the proposed
annexe.
7. In this regard I consider that neither the size of the proposed annexe nor its
offset tangential position to the north east of the listed building supports any
reasonable use of the word ‘dominance’. This is all the more so because the
intervening mature landscaping would provide an effective screen, thereby
reducing intervisibility.
8. Conversely, because of the elevated position of the site I can see why this
argument of dominance might be used with some justification in regard to the
directly rearward relationship of the proposed annexe with the host dwelling.
This widens the scope of considerations in the issue as defined by the Refusal
Notice, but as the host dwelling itself is a significant part of the setting of the
heritage asset I consider that it carries weight. As the conservation officer
points out, the site chosen does not relate well to the existing distribution of
buildings on the appeal site, and in my view ostensibly appears somewhat
random in its location other than in respect of a necessary proximity to the
house.
9. However, in favour of the siting is that there are no obvious alternatives, as a
position frontward of the host dwelling would be clearly unacceptable in terms
of its visual impact. Also, a location elsewhere in the garden would not have the
requisite proximity to the dwelling to fulfil and retain the building’s stated
purpose in terms of both the principle of an annexe and its day to day use.
10. As I have concluded that the principle of a granny annexe is acceptable, I
consider it both reasonable and necessary to impose a condition to require the
area of land between the front of the proposed building and the rear elevation
of the host dwelling to be re-modelled or laid out in such a way that visually
integrates the two buildings. The scheme should also afford the ease of access
that a granny annexe would reasonably be expected to have (the submitted
plans currently show an inadequate and narrow winding path between the
existing and proposed buildings). A satisfactory scheme of stepped terracing or
some other arrangement in place of the steep grass bank with hard and soft
landscaping as appropriate would facilitate the visual and functional connection
necessary to justify the annexe in this position.
Other Matters
11. I have carefully considered the objections to the appeal proposal, including by
the occupiers of Embercombe Cottage, the listed building. These include the
Appeal Decision APP/P1133/D/22/3294252
3
view that there would be a loss of outlook and privacy as a result of the
building, and that its occupation would cause noise and disturbance.
12. However, none of these issues were embraced by the Council as reasons for the
development to be refused and I share the their view that any effect would not
be such as to materially disadvantage the residents of the listed building. There
are neither issues of too great a proximity nor on-site characteristics that
support an assessment of an unacceptable effect.
Conclusion and Conditions
13. In summary, I conclude that the principle of the granny annexe on the site is
acceptable and that a condition can be imposed that addresses the main
drawback of the scheme. On this basis and having had regard to all other
matters raised, I consider that no harm would be caused to the setting of the
listed building, the significance of which would thereby be retained. Accordingly,
there would be no conflict with Policy EN5 of the Teignbridge Local Plan 2013-
2033 adopted in 2014 and Section 16: ‘Conserving and Enhancing the Historic
Environment’ of the National Planning Policy Framework 2021. I shall therefore
allow the appeal.
14. A condition requiring the development to be carried out in accordance with the
approved plans is needed for the avoidance of doubt and is in the interests of
proper planning. A condition limiting the use of the building to ancillary use will
preclude the subsequent establishment of a separate dwelling in conflict with
national and local policy for the countryside.
15. A condition requiring the Council’s prior approval of external materials will
ensure a satisfactory appearance of the ancillary building. A condition regulating
external lighting will safeguard foraging paths for bats. Finally, the
aforementioned condition in respect of landscaping can include slab levels and
will ensure that the building (i) has a satisfactory relationship with the host
dwelling in terms of the implication for the protection of the setting of the listed
building; (ii) would be fit for its intended purpose, and (iii) would retain the
visual amenity of the application site as a whole.
Martin Andrews
INSPECTOR
Appeal Decision APP/P1133/D/22/3294252
4
Schedule of Conditions
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three years
from the date of this Decision;
2) Other than required to fulfil condition no. 5) below, the development shall be
carried out in accordance with the following approved plans: Block Plan;
Drawing No. Series CC/2021-01/: Plan Nos. 01; 02; 03;
3) The building hereby permitted shall not be occupied at any time other than
for purposes ancillary to the residential use of the dwelling known as The
Annexe, Embercombe Cottage, Higher Ashton, Exeter EX6 7QT;
4) The approved building shall be constructed using only external materials
with details and samples first submitted to and approved in writing by the
Local Planning Authority prior to any development above slab level;
5) Prior to the commencement of development, drawings showing the proposed
slab level and a scheme of alterations to the existing land form incorporating
hard and soft landscaping and a pedestrian access between the existing
Annexe to Embercombe Cottage (the host dwelling) and the proposed
granny annexe shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local
Planning Authority. The development shall be carried out in full accordance
with the approved details;
6) Prior to the installation of any external lighting on the outside of the
building, full details including design, siting and illumination type shall be
submitted in writing to the Local Planning Authority for approval. No lighting
other than that has been approved in writing shall be installed;
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.