Proposed single storey front extension including two roof lights, a two storey extension to the western side elevation following demolition of the existing garage, change to main roof form, six roof lights to main front roof slope, two rear dormers and fenestration alterations (this application is a resubmission of 19/0701 to allow for alterations to the height of the building and the front gables, alterations to the dormers and fenestration, and the installation of fixed plant for heating and cooling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 22 March 2022
by Kim Langford Tejrar LLB (Hons) BSc (Hons) PGDIP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 5TH April 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/D3640/D/22/3293507
1 Middle Close, Camberley GU15 1NZ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Bob Mugdal against the decision of Surrey Heath Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 20/0514/FFU, dated 17 June 2020, was refused by notice dated 01
February 2022.
• The development proposed is ‘Proposed single storey front extension including two roof
lights, a two storey extension to the western side elevation following demolition of the
existing garage, change to main roof form, six roof lights to main front roof slope, two
rear dormers and fenestration alterations (this application is a resubmission of 19/0701
to allow for alterations to the height of the building and the front gables, alterations to
the dormers and fenestration, and the installation of fixed plant for heating and cooling
units)- retrospective’
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The description of development was amended following submission of the
application; I have utilised the amended description.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
• The effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the host
building and surrounding area; and,
• The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of occupiers of
neighbouring property.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal site is a detached two storey dwelling situated within Middle Close,
a residential cul-de-sac. Despite the predominance of large, detached
dwellings, the area surrounding the appeal site has an open and verdant
character by virtue of generous plot sizes, set backs from the street and
mature landscaping both within the public realm and private gardens. Middle
Close is particularly open and verdant in character due to the orientation of
buildings around the cul-de-sac and the lack of any buildings fronting the side
Appeal Decision APP/D3640/D/22/3293507
2
of the road opposite the appeal site. The topography of Middle Close drops
away significantly towards the dead-end and the appeal site, situated at a
midpoint of the road, is therefore more naturally prominent than other
dwellings within the close which are set back and set down the slope.
5. The appeal proposal seeks to retrospectively regularise changes made to the
dwelling from a previously approved scheme (Council ref. 19/0701) which was
not constructed in accordance with the approved plans. This previously
approved scheme represents a precedent and a ‘fallback position’1 to which I
give significant weight.
6. The key changes made by the appeal scheme are that the overall ridge height
has been marginally reduced and the scale and height of the front dormers has
been increased, as has the extent of fenestration within one of those dormers.
The appeal scheme also includes several air conditioning units and pipes on the
flank elevation.
7. Whilst the appeal scheme has marginally reduced the overall ridge height of
the previously approved scheme, the difference is barely perceptible from
within the streetscene. As such, the reduction in height of the roof does not
have an adverse impact on the character and appearance of the area.
8. The increase in scale and height of the front gables and the much larger area of
fenestration within one of the dormers, which continues to the top of the gable,
is more prominent than that of the approved scheme. Whilst these gables
comply with some of the advice within the Residential Design Guide (RDG) in
respect of set-ins, they are not subservient in appearance to the host dwelling.
Indeed, combined with the limited setback from the road and surrounding
topography, the gables appear to loom over the boundary hedge and road in
an overbearing manner, exacerbating the existing prominence of the dwelling.
Whilst large glazing elements and varied fenestration are visible within the
area, the siting, design and materials utilised appear incongruous within the
immediate built context. The reduction of ridge height does not reduce the
prominent appearance and mass of the gables. The gables dominate the host
dwelling and streetscene as a result and undermine the open character of the
surroundings.
9. Although only two air conditioning units and pipes are visible from the street,
the flank elevation nonetheless appears cluttered by these accretions, resulting
in poor designed.
10. Therefore, the proposal is contrary to policy DM9 of the Core Strategy and
Development Management Policies (DMP), adopted in 2012, and the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework). These policies seek, amongst
other things, development of a high standard of design which provides a good
standard of amenity, which integrates well with its surroundings and maintains
the character of the area.
Living conditions
11. The flank wall upon which the proposed air conditioning units and related
external pipe work are situated is most visible within the private rear garden
space of no.3 Middle Close. Three of those units and a network of at least
1 As a best case scenario, depending on whether the previous approval may be regarded as implemented and
remains extant.
Appeal Decision APP/D3640/D/22/3293507
3
seven pipes are prominent, visually intrusive features of the flank wall. The
prominence of these features is not reduced by the minimal one metre set-in of
the flank wall from the boundary. The flank elevation appears poorly designed
and cluttered as a result of these accretions, resulting in an unacceptable
adverse outlook from the neighbouring property.
12. The ‘fallback position’ of a single air conditioning unit benefitting from
permitted development rights is not directly comparable to the addition of
several units and pipework, which has an exponentially greater adverse impact
on the outlook from neighbouring properties than a single permitted
development unit would.
13. For this reason, the proposal is contrary to policy DM9 of the DMP.
Conclusions
14. For the reasons stated above, I find that the appeal proposal is contrary to the
relevant policies of the Development Plan. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.
Kim Langford Tejrar
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.