Replacement conservatory to rear elevation, first floor side/rear extension and re-roofing to existing roof to dwelling
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 March 2022
by Paul Singleton BSc MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 28 March 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/R0660/D/22/3291456
81 ROBIN LANE, LYME GREEN, MACCLESFIELD, SK11 0LF
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr & Mrs T Rhodes against the decision of Cheshire East Council.
• The application Ref 21/3411M, dated 22 June 2021, was refused by notice dated 12
November 2021.
• The development proposed is replacement conservatory to rear elevation, first floor
side/rear extension and re-roofing to existing roof to dwelling.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. I requested that the parties provide additional information about the floorspace
comprised in the original dwelling, existing extensions and additions, and the
first floor extension proposed in the appeal scheme in order to assist my
assessment of whether or not the proposal complies with national and local
planning policy concerning development within the Green Belt. I also invited
them to set out their comments about the degree to which one of the saved
policies in the Macclesfield Borough Local Plan (MBLP) is consistent with the
Green Belt policies in the National Planning Policy Framework (Framework) and
the weight to be given to that policy. I have had regard to the additional
submissions received in my determination of the appeal.
3. The proposed conservatory would be a replacement for an existing one that is
of much the same footprint and height. This element of the proposal has not
been objected to by the Council.
Main Issues
4. The main issues are:
a) Whether the proposal would amount to inappropriate development in the
Green Belt;
b) The effect on the character and appearance of the dwelling and the
street scene; and
c) The effect on the living conditions of the occupiers of Number 79 Robin
Lane with regard to overshadowing and the outlook from that dwelling.
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/22/3291456
2
Reasons
Green Belt
5. Paragraph 149 of the Framework states that local planning authorities should
regard the construction of new buildings as inappropriate in the Green Belt
other than in a limited set of circumstances. One of those exceptions (at sub-
paragraph c)) is “the extension or alteration of a building provided that it does
not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original
building”. The glossary to the Framework advises that the term “original
building” means the building as it existed on 1 July 1948 or, if constructed after
that date, as it was built originally.” The Cheshire East Local Plan Strategy
(CELPS) incorporates much of paragraph 149 and other parts of section 14 of
the Framework into the wording of Policy PG3 which relates to the control of
development in the Green Belt.
6. Saved policy GC12 of the Macclesfield Borough Local Plan (MBLP) applies to
proposals for the extension or alteration of existing houses both in the Green
Belt and in the open countryside beyond the Green Belt. This states that
permission may be granted for extensions of up to 30% of the original
floorspace provided that the scale and appearance of the house is not
significantly altered. In the officer report, the Council states that, as the
appeal property is within a well-established ribbon of development and the
proposed first floor extension would not be prominent, the proposal meets one
of the possible exceptions to the floor space limit as set out under Policy GC12.
The Council accordingly concluded that the proposed extension does not
constitute inappropriate development in the Green Belt.
7. The reasoned justification for Policy GC12 explains that it is based on national
policy in Planning Policy Guidance Note (PPG) 2, published in 1995. That
guidance was superseded by the Framework in 2012 and the Framework itself
has been revised since its initial publication. Paragraph 149 c) of the
Framework refers to all buildings in the Green Belt, not just to dwellings, and
does not include any requirement to consider the effect on the scale or
appearance of the building when determining whether or not a proposal would
amount to inappropriate development. Nor does it provide for further
exceptions to the presumption against inappropriate development, in cases
where the proposal would result in disproportionate additions to the size of the
original building, on the basis of whether or not the building is part of a group,
is ribbon development, or whether the proposed addition would be prominent.
8. I note the Council’s comments that the further exceptions identified within
Policy GC12 were also not included in the previous government policy as set
out in PPG2. However, I consider that, insofar as it applies to proposals within
the Green Belt, Policy GC12 is not fully consistent with the Green Belt policies
in the Framework and that limited weight should be given to that policy. For
these reasons, greater weight should be given to CELPS Policy PG3 and the
Framework than to saved MBLP Policy GC12.
9. The relevant test in both part iii) of Policy PG3 and paragraph 149 c) is
whether, taking account of any previous extensions since 1948, the proposal
would result in disproportionate additions to the size of the original building.
There is some discrepancy in the information provided by the parties as to the
floorspace of the original dwelling, existing extensions (including the
conservatory that is to be replaced) and the first floor extension proposed as
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/22/3291456
3
part of the scheme. Even using the appellant’s more conservative estimate,
the floorspace of the original dwelling has been increased by 56.7% as a result
of the existing extensions and additions. The floorspace comprised in the first
floor extension now proposed would provide an extra 12 square metres of
floorspace and lead to a cumulative increase of 72.9% over and above that
comprised in the original building.
10. I agree that the Framework does not set any maximum percentage increase in
relation to extensions and additions to buildings in the Green Belt and that the
30% figure used in Policy GC12 is only a guide. However, in my assessment, a
cumulative increase of 72.9% does represent a very significant addition to the
floorspace of the original building. I also saw on my site visit that the existing
and proposed extensions in combination would also lead to a substantial
increase in the volume of the dwelling. In my view, the proposal would result
in disproportionate additions to the size of the original building and constitute
inappropriate development in the Green Belt. My observation of the
neighbouring properties suggests that these have not been extended by so
substantial a degree.
11. Paragraph 147 of the Framework advises that inappropriate development is by
definition harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances. Although the additional space provided would be of
benefit to the appellant this does not amount to very special circumstances to
justify a grant of planning permission. The proposal, therefore, conflicts with
CELPS Policy PG13 and with the policies in section 13 of the Framework.
Character and appearance
12. Although extending up to eaves level, the first floor extension would appear as
subservient to the existing house and would be finished in materials to match
the existing external elevations. However, and notwithstanding that it would
be set back from the main front wall of the dwelling, the first floor addition
would be seen from the road and pavement. In that view the plain brick
façade of the proposed extension would appear as a stark element in the front
elevation of the dwelling. The disjointed roof pitch of the completed
development would have an awkward appearance. I agree that these elements
of the scheme would cause detriment to the character and appearance of the
host building and detract from the street scene in this section of Robin Lane.
13. Accordingly, the proposal gives rise to a conflict with MBLP Policy DC2 which
requires that proposed extensions should respect the existing architectural
features of the building. It also conflicts with CELPS Policy SE1, which states
that development proposals should make a positive contribution to their
surroundings, and Policy SD2, which states that all development will be
expected to contribute positively to an area’s character and identity.
Living conditions
14. As the adjacent dwelling, No. 79 Robin Lane, is set forward of No. 81 by some
distance, the side elevation of the ground floor extension to the appeal
property already creates a sense of enclosure to the area immediately outside
the back door of the neighbouring house. The first floor addition would not
extend up to the line of the rear wall to No. 79 and its eaves would be lower
than those of the existing house. However, this upwards extension of
brickwork on the shared boundary would further increase that sense of
Appeal Decision APP/R0660/D/22/3291456
4
enclosure and have an overbearing effect on the outlook from the rear door
and kitchen windows.
15. As noted in the Council’s assessment, the proposal would breach the 45 degree
rule with regard to its relationship with the adjacent dwelling and result in
some overshadowing of the rear window to the kitchen at No. 79, thereby
reducing the amount of light received in the kitchen. It would also adversely
affect the outlook from that room. The proposed extension would, therefore,
have a unacceptable impact on the living conditions of the future occupiers1 of
that property.
16. As a result of this impact the proposal conflicts with MBLP Policy DC3 which
states that development should not significantly injure the amenities of
adjoining residential property, including by means of having an overbearing
effect or reducing daylight and sunlight.
Other Matters
17. As noted above, I acknowledge that the proposal would benefit the appellant
by increasing the area of living accommodation within the dwelling. However,
this private benefit is not sufficient to outweigh the harm that I have identified
or the resultant conflict with the development plan.
18. I have considered the option of a split decision which grants planning
permission for the replacement conservatory which has not attracted any
objection from the Council or any other party. However, it seems to me that
the proposal to replace this in a different built form is closely linked to the
proposal to erect a first floor addition above the existing ground floor extension
to the rear of the house. A split decision would not, therefore, be appropriate
in this case.
Conclusion
19. For the reasons given above I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Paul Singleton
INSPECTOR
1 At the time of my visit the property was empty and had a ‘For Sale’ sign outside.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.