Existing butterfly roof to be demolished to allow for replacement with new flat roof terrace
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 7 June 2022 by R Dickson BSc (hons) MSc
Decision by L McKay MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 13th July 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/N5660/D/22/3291217
9 St. Stephen’s Terrace, London SW8 1DJ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Jonathon Pearson against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Lambeth.
• The application Ref 21/03996/FUL, dated 15 October 2021, was refused by notice dated
21 December 2021.
• The development proposed is described as “Existing butterfly roof to be demolished to
allow for replacement with new flat roof terrace.”
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Appeal Procedure
2. The site visit was undertaken by an Appeal Planning Officer whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Preliminary Matter
3. The description of development used is taken from the planning application
form. The decision notice issued used a more detailed description of
development. As I have not had written confirmation that a revised description
of development has been agreed, I have used the one given on the original
application. Nevertheless, in addition to the roof terrace proposed, the
submitted plans also show replacement of the front wall with railings, to which
the appellant’s evidence refers. I have therefore considered the appeal based
on the plans before me.
Main Issue
4. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on:
• the character and appearance of the host property and the wider Albert
Square Conservation Area (CA)
• the living conditions of 77 Tradescant Road and 7 and 11 St Stephen’s
Terrace, with particular regard to privacy and noise disturbance.
Appeal Decision APP/N5660/D/22/3291217
2
Reasons for the Recommendation
Character and Appearance
5. The CA derives considerable significance from the formality of the buildings and
their arrangement, with formal terraces with unified architectural detailing. The
Albert Square Conservation Area Statement (2009) (CAS) sets out that front
and informal rear gardens within the CA contribute to the spatial quality of the
area and setting of the buildings. Roofs are described as typical of the period
and normally unified within terraces or building groups. Simple and uncluttered
roof slopes which reinforce the uniformity of the terraced development are a
defining element of the CA.
6. The properties on St Stephens Terrace are characterised by a unified façade,
with dual pitched ’London roofs’ behind. The roof forms of some properties in
the terrace are visible from Tradescant Road to the side and differ from the
roofs of the properties behind. The London roof is characteristic of the area
and contributes to the significance of the CA. No 9 shares these common
features and, although the original roof covering has been replaced in the past,
it nevertheless makes a positive contribution to the character and appearance
of the CA both individually and as part of the terrace.
7. The proposal would result in the loss of an important feature of the CA, the
London roof, and consequently, would disrupt the largely unaltered roof form of
the terrace of which it forms part. From the front, the alterations would be
concealed behind the existing parapets. From the rear however, the distinctive
V-shape of the roof would only be visible in the retained profile of the rear wall.
The new parapet wall would sit directly behind this and while the pale colour
proposed means it would, at times, be visually lost against the light sky above,
the valley behind would be lost. Consequently, the retention of the profile in
the wall and the new parapet wall would not be sufficient to disguise or
compensate for the loss of this distinctive roof form.
8. Although the rear of No 9 St Stephens Terrace can only be glimpsed from
public vantage points, it is visible from private properties on Tradescant Road
and from the rear garden of the dwelling itself. The significant change in roof
form would be apparent from these private vantage points and would introduce
a discordant feature that would harm the traditional character and appearance
of the host property and the terrace and diminish their contribution to the CA.
Consequently, the proposed roof alteration would harm the character and
appearance of the CA.
9. Furthermore, the appellant’s diagram demonstrates that people standing on
the roof terrace could be visible from other properties, which would make the
change in roof form even more evident.
10. The appellant has identified several other properties close to the appeal site
which have roof terraces. Other than 3 St Stephen’s Terrace, none of these
were on the main roof of the dwellings, with those visible from the garden of St
Stephens Terrace sited on the roofs of rear projections to the properties.
Furthermore, many were on properties which do not have London roofs, and
some are not within the CA. Consequently, these examples are not comparable
to the appeal proposal and do not weigh in favour of it.
Appeal Decision APP/N5660/D/22/3291217
3
11. No 3 has a roof terrace similar to that proposed and is within the CA. However,
there is no evidence before me of how this came to be built, and it also
disrupts the otherwise unified roof form of the terrace. It is not therefore an
example of a type of development that should be encouraged and does not
justify the harm I have identified.
12. Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990 requires me to pay special attention to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing the character or appearance of the conservation area. Given my
findings above, the proposed roof terrace would neither preserve nor enhance
the character or appearance of the Conservation Area. Given its modest scale
in relation to the wider CA, it would result in less than substantial harm to the
significance of the CA as a whole. Nevertheless, this is a matter to which I give
considerable importance and weight. The National Planning Policy Framework
requires that this harm should be weighed against any public benefits of the
proposal.
13. The appellant proposes to reinstate the railings to the front of the property.
Railings would have been the traditional front boundary treatment in this area,
and many have been lost, particularly on this side of the road. The CAS
identifies that the iron railings are a special feature of the CA and are important
to the unity and architecture of the street scene. The Building Alterations and
Extensions Supplementary Planning Document (SPD) sets out that boundaries
are especially important to the character and appearance of heritage assets
and that every effort should be made to authentically reinstate missing
boundaries.
14. The proposal to reinstate iron railings would therefore enhance the character
and appearance of the host property and the CA and its significance. This is a
public benefit that I afford significant weight. However, this enhancement
would not be sufficient to offset the harm caused by the loss of the London roof
through the creation of the roof terrace. The planting areas proposed would
provide a small ‘green roof’ however given the limited size I give this
biodiversity benefit very little weight. While the proposed development would
increase the amount of amenity space for the occupiers of the property, this is
an entirely private benefit. Consequently, the public benefits associated with
the proposal would not outweigh the identified harm.
15. For the reasons above, the proposed roof terrace would harm the character and
appearance of the host property and the wider Albert Square Conservation
Area. It would therefore be contrary to Policies Q5, Q11 and Q22 of the
Lambeth Local Plan 2020-2035 (2021) (Local Plan), which collectively require
development to sustain and reinforce local distinctiveness, reinforce positive
characteristics, positively respond to the original architecture and roof form and
seek to resist roof terraces on locally distinct building types where they are not
characteristic of the host building or group.
Living Conditions
16. Properties from St Stephen’s Terrace and Tradescant Road back onto one
another and, from the diagram provided, it is clear that the proposal would
result in overlooking if users of the terrace could stand next to the front and
rear parapet walls. The presence of other roof terraces in the area mean that
that the presence of people in an elevated position is already common,
resulting in some perceived or direct overlooking however. The planting
Appeal Decision APP/N5660/D/22/3291217
4
proposed would also ensure that users could not stand next to the parapets
and could be secured by condition. Therefore, it would mitigate any potential
material increase in overlooking of neighbouring properties, safeguarding their
living conditions in respect of privacy.
17. The introduction of people at main roof level could however result in noise
disturbance given the size of the terrace, which would be larger than most
others in the area. There would be no limit to the number of people who could
use the roof terrace or the hours of use, and no parties have put forward a
suitable mechanism to control either of these issues. As the terrace is proposed
as an area of private outside amenity space, I do not consider it would be
reasonable to restrict the occupiers’ use of it as might be appropriate for a
terrace on a commercial property.
18. Consequently, while the proposal would not harm the living conditions of the
occupiers of 77 Tradescant Road and 7 and 11 St Stephen’s terrace in respect
of privacy, it would have an adverse effect in respect of noise disturbance that
could not reasonably be reduced to an acceptable level. Accordingly, the
proposed development would conflict with Policy Q2 (point v) of the Local Plan.
Other Matters
19. The appellant suggests that current policy is more permissive towards roof
terraces, however I have considered the proposal on its own merits and found
that it conflicts with current Local Plan policies for the reasons set out above.
Conclusion and Recommendation
20. For the reasons given above the proposal would conflict with the Local Plan
and the Framework and there are no other material considerations that justify
granting permission. Therefore, and having had regard to all other matters
raised, I recommend that the appeal is dismissed.
R Dickson
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Inspector’s Decision
21. I have considered all the submitted evidence and the Appeal Planning Officer’s
report and agree with the recommendation. On that basis the appeal is
dismissed.
L McKay
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.