Side extension at upper ground floor level, a rear extension at lower ground floor, excavation of a new basement, installation of replacement dormers and new skylights
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Trees & Landscape
Inspector’s Reasoning
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 1
Appeal Decision
Site visit undertaken on 7 September 2022
by J Somers BSocSci (Planning) MA (HEC) MRTPI IHBC
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision Date: 22nd November 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
18 Springfield Road, London NW8 0QN
• The appeal is made under Section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Victoria O’Shea against the decision of the City of Westminster.
• The application, ref. 21/03823/FULL, dated 8 June 2021, was refused by notice dated
29 October 2021.
• The development proposed is described as the erection of a side extension at upper
ground floor level, a rear extension at lower ground floor, excavation of a new
basement, installation of replacement dormers and new skylights.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the loss of the Golden False
Acacia Tree; the excavation of a basement; the side extension to the upper
ground floor; the side and rear dormer windows; the installation of Solar
Photovoltaic (PV) tiles; and the front and rear lightwells and rooflights to the
basement extension.
2. The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the single storey rear extension
at lower ground floor (excluding basement); the front rooflights to the plane
of the main roof; and the plant enclosure to the rear garden; and planning
permission is granted for a single storey rear extension at lower ground floor
(excluding basement); a rooflight to the front and side of the main roof; and
a plant enclosure to the garden at 18 Springfield Road, London NW8 0QN in
accordance with the terms of the application, Ref 21/03823/FULL, dated 8
June 2021, in so far as relevant to that part of the development hereby
permitted and subject to the conditions as stated in the annex to this letter.
Preliminary Matters
3. Whilst I have taken the description of the proposed development from the
Council’s Decision Notice, it does not list all the items that require consent
and to be assessed under this letter. In order to clarify the matters that will
be discussed in this letter, the Council has listed some nine Reasons for
Refusal which relate to: 1) Lower Ground Level Extension; 2) Upper Ground
Floor Side Extension; 3) Plant enclosure to rear garden; 4) Dormer windows
to side and rear roof plane; 5) PV tile installation to main roof; 6) Skylights
and front and rear lightwells; 7) insulation and venting of Mechanical
Ventilation and Heat Recovery (MHVR) unit, insulation, and solar panel; 8)
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 2
loss of Golden False Acacia tree; and 9) Harm to a Tree Preservation Order
(TPO) Tree. I have therefore concentrated on these matters only. As all of
the matters given reflect the same issue towards the character and
appearance of the conservation area (CA), I have dealt with them together
under a single matter.
4. The Council have submitted further details within the appeal documents
regarding the appellant’s submission of an updated Heritage Statement1 and
an Arboricultural Appeal Statement2 which according to the Council are
different to those which were assessed by the Council and did not form part
of the original consultation. I acknowledge that the Council has not had a
chance to completely digest the additional information contained in the
appeal documents, however the Council have made some comments
regarding both reports which I will take into account. Given that both reports
do not change the scheme but are to give further explanation to the matters
of the appeal, in accordance with the ‘Wheatcroft Principles,3’ the acceptance
of these updated documents I am willing to accept these documents as they
would not deprive those who should have been consulted on the changed
development of the opportunity of such consultation. As such, I will base my
decision on the originally received documents, the updated documents and
the Council’s additional letter within this determination.
5. The appellant has also submitted an additional plan referred to in the
appendix as Document 54 which is an elevation and site plan showing the
location and appearance of the proposed air source heat pump and
associated enclosure. Whilst there were not specific drawings given in the
planning application, and this particular plan was not part of the
consultation, the design and dimensions of the enclosure were given within
the Noise Survey5 and the location given in the Site Plan. The purpose of the
additional plan is to aid clarity, I have considered this additional plan under
the Wheatcroft Principles, and I am willing to accept these documents as the
acceptance of such would not deprive those who should have been consulted
on the changed development of the opportunity of such consultation. As
such, I shall base my decision upon it.
Main issue
6. Taking the above into account, the main issue is the effect of the proposed
development upon the character and appearance of the host building and the
greater locality, with special regard given to the character and appearance of
the St. John’s Wood CA.
Reasons
Legislation and Development Plan Policy
7. Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990 (PLBCA), in respect of development affecting conservation areas,
1 Heritage Statement, By Jon Lowe Heritage, Ref 00182, Dated January 2022
2 Arboricultural Appeal Statement by Tim Moya Associates, Ref 211226-AD-01 Dated January 2022
3 Bernard Wheatcroft Ltd v SSE [JPL 1982 P37]
4 Planning General Arrangement Plant Enclosure, Dwg No.SR018-P300, Dated January 2022
5 By Emtec, Ref: QF10464/PF6970/RP1, Dated 2nd June 2021
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 3
states that special attention shall be paid to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing the character and/or appearance of the area.
8. In undertaking development, the Westminster City Plan 2019-2040 (CP)
Policy 38 sets a number of design principles for achieving good design, such
as responding to the context, people-centred design, sustainable design and
achieving excellence in contemporary design, amongst others. CP Policy 39
relates to the considerations around heritage assets, such as seeking that
development preserves and enhances CA’s, amongst others. CS Policy 34
seeks the protection and enhancement of green infrastructure, particularly
trees of amenity, ecological and historic value, amongst others.
Site Description
9. The appeal site is located along Springfield Road which is located within the
St. John’s Wood CA. The CA’s significance is highlighted in the St John’s
Wood CA Audit 2008, where relevant components of the significance in
relation to the appeal site relate to the development of formally laid out
speculative housing development of higher status ‘gentlemen’s villas’ and
mansion blocks constructed in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. The
majority of dwellings within the CA including the appeal site are buildings of
townscape merit and consist of semi-detached and detached buildings,
where there is a hierarchy in built form and plot sizes with streets such as
Avenue Road and Marlborough Place having very large villas, whilst roads
such as Springfield Road and Clifton Road East, have high status buildings,
but on a smaller scale.
10. There is a variance in dwelling types throughout the estate, however along
Springfield Road there is a concentration of large semi-detached dwellings.
The dwellings themselves have many similar design elements, with a
number of the pairs of semi-detached dwellings being four bays wide with a
half exposed basement area with steps leading to the front entrance, large
central coaxial chimney stacks with a shallow hipped roof, small lead clad
roof dormers, and large stone window and door surrounds. The use of
traditional materials such as timber, brick and slate along with the similar
designs reinforce a uniformity and authenticity which creates a formal
picturesque townscape along with vegetated front gardens and street trees
which give a spacious, leafy and distinctive character. To the rear the leafy
character continues with well vegetated rear gardens, the tops of vegetation
which can be experienced through gaps and spaces in and around dwellings.
Along the street are street lighting which provides low levels of illumination
to the street, however not to a high level with a low traffic flow and a
tranquil experience.
11. The appeal site displays a number of positive qualities of significance to the
CA, being a high quality semi-detached building which is noted in the CA as
a building of Townscape Merit and a positive element which contributes to
the significance of the CA. The dwelling appears to date from the early to
mid-nineteenth century, is of brick construction with a slate hipped roof, two
storeys with a half-exposed basement. The building also has small dormer
windows to the side and rear roof plane and a single storey garage to the
side of the dwelling along with a rear conservatory which both appear to
date from the late twentieth century.
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 4
Single Storey Rear Extension
12. The proposed single storey rear extension would be constructed after the
demolition of the existing conservatory which appears to date from the late
twentieth century. The proposed rear extension would be constructed in a
contemporary style with a flat roof and large glazed sections which would be
relatively lightweight in appearance. I acknowledge the Council’s concerns
that the proposal would contrast with the existing appearance of the
building, however the proposal is ‘honest’ in its approach which is
experienced as an add-on to the building, rather than having a pastiche
approach or appearance. The proposal would be relatively low scale with a
modest footprint that would be subservient to the existing building, and I
find this type of construction appropriate and is of high quality which would
allow an appreciation of the evolution of the building over time.
13. I do however agree with the Council that the proposed render does not
assist in integrating the appearance of the extension with the dwelling, and
additionally would stain within a relatively short time frame, giving a poor
appearance. I note that the appellant has also sought that consideration be
given to changing the facing material to yellow London stock brick to match
the existing building by condition, and this would also seem much more
appropriate to me also. Taking the above into account, with the aid of a
condition to have the face of the extension in yellow London stock brickwork,
the proposal would cause neutral harm to the character and appearance of
the existing building and towards the CA. Consequently, the proposal is
consistent with CP Policies 38 and 39, as described previously.
Side extension to the upper ground floor
14. Under this proposal the existing garage would be converted into part of the
living accommodation with an additional storey of yellow London stock brick
added at upper floor level with a parapet roof. The extension attempts to
mimic the upper ground floor extension to No.16 (the remaining half of the
semi-detached dwelling) in terms of design, albeit would have a door
inserted to the front façade, as well as having a shorter setback of 30
centimetres, compared with No.16 which has a larger setback from the front
facade. It would appear that the existing side extension to No.16 was
undertaken some time in the mid-late 20th Century with interested parties of
the view that the extension dates from the 1970s and was extended to the
rear in the early twenty-first century.
15. I agree with the Council that these types of side extensions are unusual and
uncharacteristic within this particular context, and that the extension would
further erode the important visual gaps in and around the dwellings which
are significant. Whilst there is an existing side extension to No.16, this was
undertaken at a time under a different policy position and is not a positive
element given that it increases the bulk and massing of the dwelling and
erodes the important visual gap in between the properties. I acknowledge
comments in the appellant’s Heritage Statement that the installation would
attempt to install symmetry, however this would not be the case given that
the extension does not retain a similar setback from the front façade, and
the considerations around the erosion of the visual gap between the
properties.
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 5
16. The setback and visual gap is important in this situation and whilst No.16
has a similar extension, this does not represent justification for an extension
that would similarly cause detriment to the existing building and the
significance of the CA. The proposal would therefore lack architectural
authenticity or integrity, erode the visual gap and cause detriment to the
significance of the CA. As such this proposal would be contrary to CP Policies
38 and 39, as described previously, and cause less than substantial harm to
the significance of the CA.
Plant enclosure
17. The proposed plant enclosure would be situated to the rear corner of the
garden and mounted above a plinth with the enclosure itself reaching a
height of 2.529 metres (Excluding Plinth). The building has the appearance
of an outbuilding and is relatively small and subservient. There remain
concerns from the Council with regards to the appearance which in their
opinion is not appropriate and is unclear as to what is actually being
proposed. To me, the principle of the plant enclosure is appropriate to
provide cover for the air source heat pump, and would not on its own cause
more than a neutral harm upon the character and appearance of the host
building and the significance of the CA. I note that the Council and appellant
agree on a condition where the final appearance could be satisfied by
condition and I am satisfied with this approach.
18. Taking the above into account, subject to an appropriately worded condition,
the plant enclosure would be appropriate in principle and would satisfy the
CP Policies 38 and 39 as discussed previously.
Side and rear dormer windows
19. Many of the buildings within the locality have dormer windows to the roof
planes, they are typically inset and low level and subordinate in proportion to
the roof. The proposal to slightly increase the size and height of the dormers
would appear to be appropriate and proportionate to the form of the roof.
The Heritage Statement includes a photograph of the property in 1962
where the roof plane had a fully glazed dormer window and seeks to emulate
this type of dormer window, rather than proposing a lead clad dormer.
20. I do not entirely agree with the Heritage Statement that such an alteration
from 1962 is ‘historic’ in this particular case and that just because something
has been previously installed would mean that it is appropriate or
architecturally authentic to a dwelling such as this. A glazed dormer would
be uncharacteristic to the existing dwelling and would have an unusual
appearance when experienced within the street scene. As the dwelling is
experienced in a tranquil environment, of an evening when the street lights
provide a low level of illumination, the light generated from the room in the
roof of the dwelling would disrupt the tranquil and low light levels
experienced within this particular locality, causing additional harm to the
significance of the CA. Taking the above into account, whilst the increased
size in dormers would appear to be appropriate, when taken as a whole, the
proposed glazing of the dormers would be architecturally inauthentic to this
particular dwelling and the greater locality and would be contrary to the CP
Policies 38 and 39 as described previously. Whilst significant, the harm
caused to the significance of the CA would be less than substantial.
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 6
PV tiles
21. Whilst PV tiles are proposed for the entire roof of the main building, it is
unclear which type of PV tiles are proposed. Section 3.06 of the Design and
Access Statement which has also been transferred into the appellant’s
Statement of Case (SoC) shows imagery of ‘GB Sol’ and ‘Solecco’ PV tiles.
One of the photographs has the PV tiles attached by hook, whereas the other
example appears to feature a product attached by a nail where there is no
visual appearance of their attachment to the roof. There is also no detail as
to the colour, size, reflectiveness and overall appearance of the PV tiles.
22. I acknowledge the submission in the appellant’s SoC that another location
where the Barnes Methodist Church in the Richmond upon Thames borough
has had PV tiles approved, which is noted as also being situated in a CA and
a Building of Townscape Merit. However, this building is situated within a
different CA with different types of significance and it is not evident that both
situations between this decision and the appeal site are closely related.
Additionally, there is the consideration of how the proposal would sit against
the remaining half of the semi-detached dwelling at No.16, whereas the
example given is confined to a detached church building.
23. With the increase in technology in building materials becoming more
sophisticated, such PV tiles that seek to emulate slate, installations may
become more common and therefore the principle might be appropriate to
the CA should sufficient justification be demonstrated. This is particularly the
case compared with installations such as solar panels which would have a
much greater detriment to the character and appearance of the building and
of the CA. However, on the basis of the current detail, there is a clear lack of
information to establish the principle, appropriate size, colour, appearance
and attachment of the PV tiles would be appropriate to the character and
appearance of the building and the CA.
24. I acknowledge that the appellant seeks a pre-commencement condition and
I am aware of Paragraph 54 of the National Planning Policy Framework (The
Framework) which states that ‘Local planning authorities should consider
whether otherwise unacceptable development could be made acceptable
through the use of conditions.’ Whilst I have considered the use of conditions
to make the scheme acceptable, in this case there is not enough information
to give confidence in the principle of such a scheme. It is for this reason,
that the lack of sufficient information has meant that the proposal is likely to
be detrimental to the host building and the character and appearance of the
CA, contrary to the CP Policies 38 and 39. Consequently as a result of lack of
information, the scheme would cause less than substantial harm to the CA.
Extension of Basement which includes front and rear lightwells, and rooflights to
the basement to the front and rear
25. Whilst many of the dwellings in this locality have a half basement at lower
ground floor level, an additional basement level is neither authentic to the
dwellings or characteristic of this particular location. I can appreciate
comments within the appellant’s SoC and heritage statement that visually
elements such as the lightwell to the front may not be readily appreciable
from the public realm as it would be quite deep with the railings at lower
level. However, the assessment of significance and harm towards a CA goes
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 7
beyond what is tangible or from what can be only visually experienced in the
public realm. The front and rear lightwells would be uncharacteristic in this
particular locality, and would not reflect the architectural authenticity or
integrity of this building or the greater locality.
26. The proposed rooflights at the rear (ground level) and front (lower ground
level) would introduce large sections of glazing that would clutter the
surrounds of the building and appear awkward and inauthentic in this
context. Additionally, similar considerations are also present with the
rooflights and associated illumination from these rooms, particularly at night
time.
27. Given the concerns regarding associated elements such as lighting and
lightwells for the basement, the extension of the basement by providing an
additional level may need to be reconsidered/ re-evaluated. As such, in its
current form the extension of the basement is not considered appropriate.
28. Taken as a whole, the additional clutter caused by the rooflights to the front
and rear, together with the front and rear lightwells would result in
unnecessary clutter, with these proposals and the basement extension being
architecturally inauthentic and have a detrimental impact upon the existing
building and the significance of the CA. The proposal would therefore be
contrary to CP Policies 38 and 39 and cause less than substantial harm to
the CA.
MVHR, insulation, and solar panel above proposed upper floor side extension
29. The installation of insulation and MVHR was noted within the application
documents, however these are not detailed on the plans and are not
mentioned within the application description on the application form. The
Council’s Reason for Refusal have refused the application on the basis of lack
of information, however the appellant has mentioned in their SoC that these
elements are unknown and therefore not part of the appeal. As these
elements have not been included on the plans or are present within the
application form, I am satisfied that consent is not sought for their
installation.
30. This matter also includes the installation of a solar panel behind the parapet
of the proposed upper floor side extension. Whilst such an installation might
be acceptable in principle, the proposed side extension does not have
consent and therefore the proposal is not able to proceed. As such, without
prejudice, I am not going to consider these matters.
Removal and effect towards trees
31. The Reasons for Refusal relate to two trees, referred to on the submitted
plans as T1, a Golden False Acacia (Robinia) tree located in the rear garden;
and T4, a Lime tree located in the front garden and which is subject to a
TPO.
32. Starting with the Robinia tree, the main reason for the removal of this tree
appears to be that it is in the way of the development of the site for a
basement. However, the submitted amended Arboricultural report and
appeal statement expand this reasoning further with commentary regarding
the tree’s health, longevity and contribution to the landscape. When grading
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 8
trees, the British Standard BS5837 – Tree Surveys categorises trees that are
worthy of retention in three Categories from A (high quality); B (moderate
quality) and C (low quality). The standard then categorises the trees in
Arboricultural qualities, landscape qualities and cultural values, including
conservation.
33. The appellant’s arboriculturist rates the tree as ‘Category C’ which in
accordance with the British Standard, would rate a Level C tree as
"Unremarkable trees of very limited merit or such impaired condition that
they do not qualify in higher categories." The Council’s arboriculturist rates
the tree as Grade B which would place the tree as ‘moderate.’
34. Whilst I appreciate that the assessment from an arboricultural report is
related to landscape value and the requirements of CP Policy 34 around
green infrastructure, the reason for refusal is also based upon a
consideration of the historic environment and associated heritage assets
which also brings in the duty under S72 of the PLBCA, and CP Policies 38 and
39.
35. When walking along Springfield Road, the experience of the road is one that
is leafy and picturesque with the trees to the rear and the front contributing
strongly towards the significance of the CA as explained in the CA Appraisal.
In the visual gap between Nos. 18 and 20, the Robinia has a dominant
presence within the street scene. I note comments in the Arboricultural
Appeal Statement6 that states that ‘trees in the rear garden cannot have the
same level of contribution in landscape terms as those within the street and
front garden.’ However I am unclear if this is from an official publication, or
the opinion of the consultant. Either way, the consideration before me goes
beyond one of landscape and is that of the significance of the CA and S72 of
the PLBCA which does not differentiate weight according to whether an
assessment relates to the private or public realm. I note that there does not
appear to be any assessment of the trees within the Heritage Statement,
other than to comment upon how significant the trees are, there is no
distinction made between the trees in the rear or front garden.
36. Having experienced the Robinia tree from both the street scene and from the
rear garden, the tree is a dominant and positive feature that contributes
strongly to the amenity of this particular location. The tree clearly has
material conservation or cultural value from a historic environment
perspective, which would place this tree within the Category B of BS5837,
and not Category C, which would have ‘no material conservation or cultural
value.’ Given the size and appearance of the tree, I disagree that if the tree
was removed, that the remaining trees in the rear garden would somehow
make up for this loss of tree and still enable the appreciation of the well
treed environment to contribute to the significance of the CA. Whilst some of
the remaining trees would be appreciable, and perhaps more so with the
removal of the tree, the removal of the Robinia in this location would be
noticeable and would have a detrimental effect towards the character and
appearance of the CA if it were removed.
6 Paragraph 2.4
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 9
37. The second reasoning for a Category C grade is given by the appellant is
because in the opinion of the appellant’s arboriculturist is that the tree is
unlikely to live beyond 20 years. In order to support this assertion, a graph
is submitted which shows that out of a survey of 30 trees, 23% lived
between 6-10 years, 40% lived between 11-24 years and 37% lived
between 25-49 years. Unfortunately, the data is not very convincing given
the very limited sample size; the chart does not give any detail as to where
the tree was, where it was located, and why it died (eg a natural event
causing the destruction of a number of similar trees). Additionally, it could
be said that the majority of trees as part of the survey lived beyond 20 years
if taking the 37% 25-49 years together with some of the 40% of trees that
lived 11-24 years.
38. According to the additional information supplied by the Council in rebuttal to
the amended Arboricultural Appeal Statement, the tree displaying signs of
the fungus Diaporthe Oncostoma which causes lesions and crown dieback is
quite typical for a tree of this type and that the cause of the fungus is not
known. Additionally, previous actions of controlling the crown were a result
of proactive management, rather than because of the need to arrest fungal
decay. Whilst the appellant’s arboriculturist has referred to the many
diseases and signs of problems of this specie of tree, none of which are
present in this specimen, with the Council’s arboriculturist categorising the
crown of the tree as ‘very vigorous.’ Having viewed the tree and assessed
the information before me, I disagree that the tree is in poor health and that
there is sufficient reasoning or justification to demonstrate that the tree
would not survive less than 20 years. I agree with the Council’s
arboriculturist that the tree is of a moderate quality which should be
retained, rather than felled because it is in the way of the development.
39. Turning to considerations around the impact to the lime tree in the front
garden which is subject of a TPO, the corner of the proposed basement
extension would likely impact upon the root protection area of this tree. The
tree is to be retained with a number of protection measures to ensure the
development does not cause material detriment to this tree. I acknowledge
comments from the Council’s Arboriculturist who recommends that the
basement be set back, and that further detail would be required regarding
protection measures. Both parties appear to be of a view that any issues
could be mitigated by an appropriately worded condition. As such, Reason
for Refusal No.9 which is regarding the harm towards the Lime Tree could be
overcome by the inclusion of an appropriately worded condition. As such the
development with regard to the lime tree would not be contrary to CP
Policies 34, 38 or 39, as discussed previously.
40. Taking the above into account, whilst it would be possible to resolve the
matter involving the Lime Tree, the proposed removal of the Robinia Tree
would not be appropriate and would cause harm to amenity, character and
appearance of the area and would be contrary to CP Policies 34, 38 and 39
as described previously. The proposed removal of the Robinia tree would
also cause less than substantial harm towards the significance of the CA.
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 10
Effect on the Conservation Area
41. Through this letter, it was found that the proposed dormer windows, PV tiles,
first floor side extension, front and rear lightwells and the loss of the Golden
Acacia Tree would cause ‘less than substantial’ harm to the CA within the
meaning of the term in paragraph 202 of the Framework. Paragraph 200 of
the Framework states that any harm to, or loss of, the significance of a
designated heritage asset requires clear and convincing justification.
Paragraph 202 of the Framework requires that, where a proposal would lead
to less than substantial harm, the harm should be weighed against the public
benefits of the proposal.
42. The applicant has not outlined any public benefits of the scheme. However,
the benefits of the scheme would deliver larger residential accommodation
for the existing dwelling, as well as result in short term employment
opportunities in the construction of the extension both of which are
important planning policy objectives. However, these benefits may also be
present in a more appropriately designed scheme. That said, these benefits
would not justify the harm I have identified.
43. I therefore find that the public benefits would not outweigh the harm caused
to the significance of the CA. The scheme therefore conflicts with the
Framework, which directs, at paragraph 199, ‘that great weight should be
given to the asset’s conservation … irrespective of whether any potential
harm amounts to substantial harm, total loss or less than substantial harm
to their significance’.
44. In conclusion on this matter, I consider the proposed development would
cause less than substantial harm to the significance of the CA. It has not
been shown that public benefits would outweigh this harm and so the
proposal would conflict with the development plan.
Other Matters
45. I note comments from interested parties that have concerns with regards to
party walls being able to hold the proposed extension; incorrect plans
showing the single storey side extension and the resultant impacts to living
conditions in terms of loss of light; issues with groundwater and the
installation of a basement. Given the failure of the application on a number
of issues, it has not been necessary to delve into these additional matters.
Additionally, in relation to the party wall issues, this is not a planning
consideration and has not formed a consideration as part of this letter.
Conclusion and Conditions
46. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should succeed in
relation to the single storey rear extension, plant enclosure, and rooflights to
main roof. However, in relation to the remaining elements, the appeal should
be dismissed.
47. The Council in their additional letter to the Inspectorate detailed that should
the appeal be allowed, that 23 conditions should be considered to be placed
on any decision notice. I have considered the conditions as specified in the
beginning of this letter in accordance with the Planning Practice Guidance
(PPG). Whilst the Council have suggested a condition to approve plans, this
Appeal Decision: APP/X5990/D/22/3291062
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 11
has been altered to include references to the plans in question in the
interests of proper planning and the avoidance of doubt. The Council have
not detailed a standard condition relating to the expiration of the permission
after 3 years if the approval is not commenced which is necessary to include.
Given the piling works and excavation regarding a basement are not part of
this permission and that the only demolition would be the conservatory, it is
not considered reasonable to impose a condition regarding timings of works,
as such suggested condition 2 and 19 are not required. Condition 3 is a
matching materials condition. Given that the only elements that have been
approved require approval of details via condition, this condition would not
be required as it would repeat these pre-commencement conditions once
approved. Suggested conditions 4, 5 and 6 refer to the installation of
windows, and associated cross section plans and putty details etc. The
installation of windows is not part of this consent, and I am unaware of any
Article 4 direction in place within the CA that requires consent for the
installation of such windows. As such, the condition is not relevant to this
planning application, and would be unreasonable to impose and is therefore
deleted. Suggested Condition 7 relates to the retention of the green roof to
the single storey rear extensions and is considered necessary and
appropriate in the interests of the character and appearance of the CA.
48. Suggested condition 8 relates to the submission of a biodiversity
management plan for the installation of a green roof. Given the relatively
modest extension and size of green roof, to me the requirement for a
biodiversity management plan along with additional cross section plans etc
would be disproportionate to the approval and unreasonable and therefore
would not comply with the tests of conditions. This suggested condition is
therefore deleted. Suggested conditions 9-14 (consecutive), and 16, 17, 18
and 21, 22 and 23 relate to matters that do not have consent and therefore
are deleted. Condition 15 appears to restrict occupancy of the proposed
development until the energy efficiency measures are implemented. This
would be unreasonable given that the residents are already in occupancy
and would also be unnecessary and unenforceable. As such this condition is
deleted. Condition 20 places a restriction on the use of the rear extension so
that it is not used for sitting out, which is appropriate for the protection of
living conditions of surrounding residents. Paragraph 2.12 of the Appellant’s
SoC seeks that they would accept a pre-commencement condition requiring
submission of materials for the rear extension as well as for the heat pump
enclosure. This is considered appropriate and necessary to impose as a pre-
commencement condition.
J Somers
INSPECTOR
www.planningportal.gov.uk/planninginspectorate 1
ANNEX: Schedule of Conditions
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than three [3] years
from the date of this decision.
2) The proposed single storey rear extension, plant enclosure and roof light to
main roof shall be constructed in accordance with the following approved
plans:
• ‘Site Plan & Roof Plan’, Drg No. SR018-P001, Dated August 2020;
• ‘LG & UG Floor Plan,’ Drg No. SR018-P101 (A), Dated August 2020;
• ‘South Elevation,’ Drg No. SR018-P200 (A), Dated August 2020;
• ‘East Elevations,’ Drg No. SR018-P201 (A), Dated August 2020;
• ‘North Elevation,’ Drg No. SR018-P202 (A), Dated August 2020;
• ‘West Elevation,’ Drg No. SR018-P203 (A), Dated August 2020;
• ‘Plant Enclosure,’ Drg No. SR018-P300 (_), Dated August 2020;
3) Notwithstanding the approved plans and prior to the commencement of the
proposed development, full details of the following shall be submitted to and
approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. The development shall
thereafter be carried out in accordance with the approved details and
retained in perpetuity, unless further consent from a subsequent application
is given by the Local Planning Authority.
a) Details of the materials, colour, size, coursing and texture of the
brickwork to the rear extension;
b) Details of the materials, colour, size and texture of the materials for the
heat pump plant enclosure in the rear garden.
4) The roof area of the rear extension hereby permitted shall not be used as a
balcony, roof garden or similar amenity area.
5) The green roof shall be installed and carried out in accordance with the
approved plans and shall be maintained in perpetuity unless further consent
from a subsequent application is given by the Local Planning Authority.
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.