Erection of a replacement conservatory following the demolition of the existing conservatory, installation of a new front door to replace existing door and replacement of an existing window on the southern elevation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 14 September 2022
by Louise Nurser BA (Hons) Dip UP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 12th December 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/C3240/D/21/3287954
The Crossing, Church Road, Jackfield, TELFORD, TF8 7ND
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Justin and Sarah Bailey against the decision of
Telford and Wrekin Council.
• The application Ref TWC/2020/0989, dated 19 October 2020, was refused by notice
dated 30 September 2021.
• The development proposed is erection of a replacement conservatory following the
demolition of the existing conservatory, installation of a new front door to replace
existing door and replacement of an existing window on the southern elevation.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the replacement conservatory.
The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the installation of a new front door
to replace the existing door and replacement of an existing window on the
southern elevation and planning permission is granted for the installation of a
new front door to replace the existing door and replacement of an existing
window on the southern elevation at The Crossing Church Road, TELFORD, TF8
7ND in accordance with the terms of the application, Ref TWC/2020/0989,
dated 19 October 2020, and the plans submitted with it, so far as relevant to
that part of the development hereby permitted and subject to the following
conditions:
1) The development / works hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3
years from the date of this decision.
2) No development shall take place until details of the design of the front
door and replacement window including drawings at a scale of 1:20 have
been submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning
authority. The development shall be carried out in accordance with the
approved details.
3) No development shall take place until details of the design of the
proposed ironmongery, fixings, fittings, and finishes shall have been
submitted to and approved in writing by the local planning authority. The
development shall be carried out in accordance with the approved details.
4) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: Location Plan 13/11/2020 Block Plan
13/11/2020, Proposed South Elevation Plan 13/11/2020.
Appeal Decision APP/C3240/D/21/3287954
2
Background and Preliminary Matters
2. The description of development has been amended during the determination of
the application. I note that in Part E of the appeal form it is stated that the
description of development has not changed but, nevertheless, a different
wording has been entered. However, reference to the change in description has
been made by both the appellants and the Council. Therefore, I have used the
revised description of development in both the banner and decision.
3. The conservatory has already been built. I am aware that this replaced a larger
conservatory which had been constructed without planning permission, and
that the Council had not taken any action to regularise its status. Moreover, all
parties are agreed that the visual appearance of the conservatory, which is the
subject of the appeal, is smaller, and an improvement on the one which it
replaced.
4. Nonetheless, the previous conservatory no longer exists, and I must determine
the appeal on the basis of the scheme before me.
5. I am aware that Council raises no objection to the replacement of the existing
door and window on the southern elevation. I see no reason to disagree with
this conclusion.
Main Issue
6. The main issue is the effect of the conservatory on designated and non-
designated heritage assets; namely, the character and appearance of the host
property, the setting of nearby listed buildings, the character or appearance of
the Severn Gorge Conservation Area, and the protection of the Outstanding
Universal Value of the Ironbridge Gorge World Heritage Site.
Reasons
7. The host property is a non-designated heritage asset. It lies within the Severn
Gorge Conservation, the setting of the Grade II* listed buildings at Jackfield
Tile Museum, and various attached workshops, the Severn Gorge Conservation
Area, and the Ironbridge Gorge World Heritage Site.
8. Sections 66(1) and 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation
Areas) Act 1990 (the Act) require me to have special regard to the desirability
of preserving the setting of a listed building and preserving or enhancing the
character or appearance of a conservation area. Paragraph 189 of the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) sets out that heritage assets are
an irreplaceable resource and should be conserved in a manner appropriate to
their significance.
The host property
9. The host property is a former railway building constructed in the late
nineteenth century. It is of evidential significance as it was part of the wider
infrastructure that supported the transport of goods and raw materials within
the Severn Gorge, and, in particular, to the Jackfield Tile Works which lie
directly opposite. The property has been extended at either end following its
conversion to a dwelling. However, the central element is still recognisable as a
railway building. Although, the cumulative impact of the alterations to the
property has been to degrade its legibility.
Appeal Decision APP/C3240/D/21/3287954
3
10. The conservatory is attached to the western end of the property. It has been
moved from another property and is of a generic design, of thick brown wood
effect timbers, sat on a rendered dwarf wall. A brown decorative finial runs the
length of the ridge of the hipped roof and the glass panes have a lead effect
pattern. It is of a standard, generic suburban design which takes no visual cues
from the wider historic environment, and is constructed of materials which are
alien to the wider context.
11. Consequently, this not only appears incongruous, elongates the footprint of the
building, but further domesticates its design, undermining its legibility as a
former railway building and has an adverse effect on the character and
appearance of the host property.
Setting of listed buildings
12. The appeal site is particularly prominent within the orbit of the brick Jackfield
Tile Works, and its associated buildings, which lie directly opposite. These late
nineteenth century brick buildings are both listed as Grade 11* and were built
almost contemporaneously with the appeal property. In the context of this
appeal, they derive their significance from their historic importance as
exemplars of the industrial process by which encaustic tiles were produced,
including those which were used in culturally significant national buildings.
13. I took especial note of the topography of the area and the distance between
the conservatory and the road, together with the impact of the garden, which I
understand would be further landscaped and where new planting is to take
place. Nonetheless, the conservatory is, and would remain highly visible in the
wider streetscape. Indeed, at the time of my site visit, the sun was glinting off
the glass roof, making the conservatory appear very conspicuous when viewed
from the road.
14. As such, the conservatory adversely impacts on the setting of the listed
buildings by introducing an alien suburban element within what is a primarily a
historic industrial context, albeit there are a number of contemporary and more
modern residential properties nearby, consistent with the mix of housing and
industry. In addition, it negatively affects the historic significance of the Tile
works by further diluting the visual and evidential coherence of its wider
setting, with particular reference to the functional links to the former railway
building, and beyond. This results in less than substantial harm. Such harm, is
of considerable importance and weight.
15. In line with paragraph 202 of the Framework, where development leads to less
than substantial harm to the significance of the heritage asset, this harm
should be weighed against the public benefits of the proposal. I must have
special regard to the desirability of preserving the setting of the listed
buildings. I am aware that the appellants wish to enjoy the conservatory, and
to provide a ramped access to the property. However, these benefits are purely
private benefits. I have also been referred to the financial costs were the
conservatory to be dismantled. This is a private matter. Reference has been
made to the benefits accrued from the use of local labour to erect and
transport the conservatory, together with the benefits of reusing the fabric. I
attribute minimal weight to these benefits in favour of the proposal. Moreover,
I do not consider that the use of a material which will not degrade is a public
benefit.
Appeal Decision APP/C3240/D/21/3287954
4
16. Consequently, the purported public benefits do not outweigh the less than
substantial harm to the setting of the listed buildings which I have determined
results from the conservatory at this site. Therefore, the presumption in favour
of sustainable development does not apply.
Conservation Area
17. The Crossing lies within the Severn Gorge Conservation Area. This extensive
Conservation Area encompasses the important defined character areas of
Ironbridge, the Coalbrookdale Valley, Coalport, Madeley and Jackfield. In the
context of this appeal, the built environment within the Conservation Area,
together with the landform, including the steep gorge and resources, and tree
cover, evidences both the historic development of important industrial
processes on which the industrial revolution is based, as well as the wealth and
cultural offshoots which resulted, and the subsequent decline.
18. The Jackfield Tile Works which lies opposite the appeal site, plays a significant
role in the Conservation Area as a whole, as the form of the building
demonstrates, and is integral to the important industrial history of the factory
and the wider area. So too is the appeal property, whose former use as a
railway building, contributes positively to the historic significance of the
Conservation Area as a whole, notwithstanding the previous extensions and
alterations. Moreover, given the topography of the Conservation Area, the
appeal site is highly visible, both on foot and from within vehicles, no doubt
including tourists to the area. Consequently, as previously set out, the
conservatory the subject of the appeal, results in harm to the host property
which in turn impacts adversely on the significance of the Conservation Area.
19. Therefore, the conservatory neither preserves or enhances the character or
appearance of the Conservation Area. This harm is less than substantial.
20. In such cases, as set out above where there is less than substantial harm to
the significance of a designated heritage asset, this harm should be weighed
against the public benefits of the proposal. As has previously been
demonstrated, the public benefits of the scheme are minimal. Therefore, the
public benefits do not outweigh the less than substantial harm to the
significance of the Conservation Area.
World Heritage Site
21. The appeal site lies within the Ironbridge Gorge World Heritage Site (WHS)
which was inscribed into the Unesco World Heritage List in 1986. The
Outstanding Universal Value (OUV) derives from its unique role in the
development of the Industrial Revolution, whose genesis began in the
eighteenth century within the WHS and spread throughout the world. A number
of attributes have been identified which are particularly relevant to the appeal.
These include infrastructure and transport within the WHS, together with the
plethora of industrial buildings which tell a story of industrial innovation and
development.
22. The management plan accepts that there is a tension between the WHS, being
a modern living environment and the conservation of its historic authenticity,
and an overriding need to prevent the cumulative impact of unsympathetic
development. Nonetheless, given my conclusions above in relation to the harm
Appeal Decision APP/C3240/D/21/3287954
5
derived from the conservatory, its presence does not protect the Outstanding
Universal Value of the WHS.
23. Given the above and the absence of any defined public benefit, I conclude that
the conservatory element of the appeal fails to preserve the setting of the
Grade II* listed buildings, and the character or appearance of the Severn
Gorge Conservation Area, and adversely affects the Outstanding Universal
Value of the World Heritage Site, as well as adversely affecting the non-
designated heritage asset which is a building of local interest. This fails to
satisfy the requirements of the Act, paragraph 197 of the Framework and
conflicts with policies BE1 -B6 of the Telford and Wrekin Local Plan 2011- 2031,
adopted 2018, and the Severn Gorge Conservation Area Appraisal and
Management Plan that seek, amongst other things, to promote good design,
protect the WHS, the Conservation Area, and the setting of listed buildings,
together with buildings of local interest. Consequently, the conservatory does
not accord with the development plan, and therefore is not sustainable
development.
24. However, as previously accepted, the replacement door and window would not
result in any harm and would therefore not conflict with the development plan
or national policy
Conditions
25. In relation to the development which I have permitted, I have imposed the
standard commencement conditions and a condition specifying the approved
drawings. However, in line with paragraph 56 of the Framework, in the
interests of clarity, and to ensure that the condition is both enforceable and
precise, I have imposed a pre-commencement condition requiring that details
of the design of the front door, and replacement window be submitted and
agreed. In addition, submission of details of the proposed window and door
furnishings is necessary. Both of which have been agreed by the appellants1.
Other Matters
26. I am aware that there have been no objections to the scheme from the Gorge
Parish Council, neighbours, nor from Shropshire Council’s Historic Environment
Team.
27. I also took the opportunity to carefully consider the impact of the uPVC
conservatory at a nearby property on Church Road. However, I do not have the
details of its planning history, or indeed whether it benefits from planning
permission. Nonetheless, rather than supporting the appellants’ case, it serves
to illustrate the corrosive impact of unsympathetic development within such a
sensitive location.
28. In any case, I must determine any planning application on the individual merits
of the case before me.
Conclusion
29. The element of the proposed development that I have found to be
unacceptable is severable from the remainder of the proposal. Therefore, for
the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should succeed in relation
1 Email received 20 September 2022.
Appeal Decision APP/C3240/D/21/3287954
6
to the replacement door and window. However, in relation to the conservatory,
I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Louise Nurser
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.