New second floor extension to access existing roof terrace after removal of existing second floor terrace access structure
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Ecology & Biodiversity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 26 January 2022
by G Roberts BA (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:15TH February 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/W1715/D/21/3287494
Swan House & Swan Cottage, 1,2 Oyster Quay, High Street, Hamble-Le-
Rice, SO31 4BQ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by David de Krester against the decision of Eastleigh Borough
Council.
• The application Ref H/21/90418, dated 20 April 2021, was refused by notice dated
28 September 2021.
• The development proposed is new second floor extension to access existing roof terrace
after removal of existing second floor terrace access structure.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. The main issues are: (a) the effect of the proposed development on the
character and appearance of the area, with particular regard to the sites
location within the Hamble Conservation Area; and (b) whether the proposed
development would have an adverse effect on protected species.
Reasons
Character and appearance
3. The appeal site lies within the Hamble Conservation Area (HCA). Section 72(1)
of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Area) Act 1990 requires,
therefore, that special attention be paid to the desirability of preserving or
enhancing the character or appearance of that area. Similar advice is to be
found in the National Planning Policy Framework (July 2021) (Framework) and
in saved policy 169.LB of the Eastleigh Borough Local Plan Review 2001-2011
(ELPR).
4. The Council’s Delegated Report states that the appeal property forms part of a
residential development of 14 units that was granted planning permission in
February 2004. The Report continues by referring to the committee report and
development brief for that development, which highlighted the importance of
the roofscape of the development and the need to maintain an informal and
haphazard roofscape. Whilst I have not been provided with a copy of either
document, these references are consistent with those set out in the
Conservation Area Appraisal (2008) (CAA) for the HCA, which I understand has
been adopted as a Supplementary Planning Document.
Appeal Decision APP/W1715/D/21/3287494
2
5. As the CAA confirms and as I observed on my site visit, the appeal site forms
an intrinsic and important part of the HCA and specifically the area around The
Quay, foreshore (including the public car park) and River Hamble. I concur
with the Council that this is a sensitive part of the HCA, the importance of
which is underlined by the presence, to the north of the appeal site, of The
Bugle Public House (The Bugle), a designated Grade II Listed Building.
6. Whilst the appeal site forms part of a modern development, its design
replicates some of the prevailing architectural detailing and features that are
found on the older properties within the surrounding area, which combined
contribute to the historic importance of the conservation area. These features
and detailing are referred to in the ‘Architectural Appraisal’ section of the CAA.
The latter states that the majority of buildings within the HCA are domestic in
scale, often found in terraced form of 2 -3 storeys in height with pitched roofs
of clay tiles and roof accommodation served by small hipped or gable dormers
subservient to the overall roof. It continues by stating that chimney stacks and
pots make a significant contribution to the roofscape, which together with the
roofs are an important part of the character of the area especially when viewed
from the river.
7. All of the above factors contribute, in my judgement, to the significance of the
HCA as a whole.
8. The appeal proposal would involve the demolition of the existing second floor
access structure and its replacement with a new extension to provide access to
the existing roof terrace. Whereas the existing access structure is sited close
to the common boundary with The Bugle, to the north, the proposed structure
would be located towards the southern end of the existing roof terrace
emerging from the existing ridged pitched roof. The proposal would entail the
removal of an existing chimney and the replacement of the existing metal
balustrading with a frameless glass balustrade. Whilst the existing access
structure houses a staircase, the proposed structure would include a staircase
as well as a room that would serve as new living space.
9. Within the above context, the scale, massing, design and siting of the proposed
extension would, in my judgement, be overly dominant within the existing
roofscape to the host property and streetscene. It would introduce a large
discordant feature that would overwhelm this part of the roofscape, harming
the important role it plays within the streetscene and HCA. It would also
introduce an awkward juxtaposition between the proposed extension and the
existing ridged pitched roof, giving the impression of an extension that does
not harmonise well with the roofscape and is not subservient to it. The result
is a development that does not sit comfortably within the existing roofscape or
the streetscene.
10. The harm that results is accentuated by the removal of the existing chimney.
Notwithstanding that the latter may be redundant, it is feature that, combined
with similar chimneys on this new development and on the older properties
nearby, provides a certain built rhythm, and which together form an important
part of the character of the existing roofscape. As I observed on site, this
roofscape is highly visible from a number of public vantage points within the
HCA, specifically the river, foreshore (including the public car park) and The
Quay.
Appeal Decision APP/W1715/D/21/3287494
3
11. The existing metal balustrade currently provides some consistency with similar
detailing found on the roof terrace to the property to the south of the appeal
site. I do not agree that this balustrading is in any way incongruous and its
replacement by a frameless glass balustrade would again harm the rhythm and
appearance of the existing roofscape. Whilst I accept that frameless glass
balustrading has been installed on the lower levels of the host property, the
latter is viewed against the backdrop of the main elevation to the host and is
not as visible or as prominent as the balustrading at roof level.
12. The Appellant considers that the proposed access would integrate better with
the existing roofscape. For the reasons set out above, I do not agree. Whilst
the existing roof access does occupy a central and visible position within the
roofscape, its impact is mitigated by its small scale and massing and the fact
that it is sited side-on to the rear elevation of the host. As a result, it is not an
unduly dominant feature within the existing roofscape. In comparison, the
scale, width and massing of the proposed extension, combined with its
awkward relationship with the existing ridged pitched roof, the removal of the
chimney and replacement of the metal balustrade with glass, results in a
development that would cause significant harm to the roofscape of the host
property and streetscene.
13. Reference has been made to the consultation response from the Council’s
Conservation Officer, who raised no objection to the proposal. As the
Delegated Report states, the Case Officer had regard to those comments, but
disagreed with the conclusion reached. It is not uncommon for officers to
disagree, particularly in a case where the assessment of the acceptability of the
proposal requires an element of judgement. Even so, I have also had regard to
the Conservation Officers comments, but, as I confirmed above, reached a
similar finding to the Case Officer.
14. The Appellant has also drawn attention to the modern extension with a glazed
roof structure at Rope House in Rope Walk. However, I do not know the full
planning circumstances of this case and it is not possible for me, therefore, to
determine whether it is in any way relevant or comparable to the appeal
proposal. Even so, I can only consider the proposal that is before me and
determine it, as is required, on its individual merits having regard to the
particular circumstances of this case. Neither this example nor the existence of
other roof structures or extensions in the area, also referred to in the
submitted evidence, affect the findings I have reached on this issue.
15. For the reasons set out above, I find that the appeal proposal would result in
significant harm to the character and appearance of the area, and as such it
would not preserve or enhance the HCA. In view of this finding and as is
required, particularly by the Framework, considerable importance and weight
must be attached to the harm to this designated heritage asset. The appeal
proposal would, in my judgement, lead to less than substantial harm to the
significance of the designated heritage asset. The level of harm would be high,
and there are no public benefits, delivering either economic or social or
environmental objectives, which would outweigh that harm.
16. Accordingly, I find that the proposed development would be contrary to saved
policy 169.LB of the ELPR and paragraphs 189, 197, 199 - 200 and 202 of the
Framework. The proposal would also be contrary to the corresponding
provisions of saved policies 59.BE and 171.LB of the ELPR and policies DM1 and
Appeal Decision APP/W1715/D/21/3287494
4
DM12 of the emerging Eastleigh Borough Local Plan 2016 – 2036 (Emerging
Plan).
Protected species
17. The Council contend that the proposal would involve works to the existing roof
which has the potential to support bats due to the sites location close to the
waterfront and the existence of two European Protected Species (EPS)
mitigation licences within 2km of the site. The Council consider that there is a
reasonable likelihood that bats would be affected by the appeal proposal. In
the absence of any submitted survey work the Council state that they have,
therefore, adopted a precautionary approach to a species that is protected
under the Conservation of Habitats & Species Regulations 2019 (as amended).
This finding is based on the consultation response received from the Council’s
Ecology Officer.
18. In response, the Appellant argues that as the roof is only 20 years old and
unlikely to permit bat roosting, the requirement for a preliminary bat roost
assessment is unjust and excessive. The Appellant continues by stating that
they will ensure, if deemed necessary, compliance with all the relevant
environmental legislation and the requirements of Natural England.
19. Circular 06/2005, Biodiversity and Geological Conservation, states that the
presence or otherwise of protected species and the extent to which they might
be affected by a development is a material consideration and must be
established before planning permission is granted. In this particular case, the
likelihood of a protected species (bats) being present is a matter of judgement
based on the evidence that is before me.
20. The Appellant has not provided any specialist evidence to challenge the
consultation response from the Ecology Officer. In addition, there is no
indication that the Appellant has undertaken a desk top study or walk over
survey of the appeal site to identify whether there are any features that are
likely to be used by protected species. In view of this, I agree with the Council
that, on balance, there is credible evidence of a reasonable likelihood of
protected species being affected by the proposed development. In the absence
of any survey information or substantive evidence to the contrary, even if the
appeal proposal was otherwise acceptable, planning permission could not be
granted.
21. The above finding is supported by saved policy 25.NC of the EBLP (policy DM1
of the Emerging Plan). This policy states that new development which
adversely affects a habitat or feature of importance to wild fauna should not be
permitted unless it can be demonstrated that the benefits outweigh the
adverse impact; the impacts are unavoidable; and appropriate measures are
taken to mitigate the adverse impact. There is insufficient evidence before me
to conclude whether the appeal proposal would be compliant with that policy.
22. Accordingly, I find that the appeal proposal would not be complaint with saved
policy 25.NC of the EBLP or with the corresponding provisions of policy DM1 of
the Emerging Plan.
Other Matters
23. As I confirmed above, the appeal site lies within the setting of a designated
Grade II Listed Building, namely The Bugle. Section 66 of the Planning (Listed
Appeal Decision APP/W1715/D/21/3287494
5
Buildings and Conservation Area) Act 1990 requires, therefore, that special
regard must be had to the desirability of preserving this building’s setting.
Similar advice is to be found in the Framework. The removal of the existing
access structure, abutting the common boundary with The Bugle, would
improve the setting of this heritage asset. In relation to the new extension,
this would be re-sited to the southern end of the existing roof terrace to the
host property, further away from the common boundary with The Bugle.
Given, therefore, the distance that would separate the two and based on my
observations on site, I am satisfied, on balance, that the appeal proposal would
not result in any harm to the setting of this listed building.
Conclusion
24. For the reasons given above and having taken all other matters into account, I
conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
G Roberts
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.