Two-storey side and single storey rear extensions
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 5 May 2023
by L McKay MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 August 2023
Appeal Ref: APP/M3645/D/21/3287239
1 Carewell Cottages, St. Piers Lane, Lingfield RH7 6PN
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr T Grimley against the decision of Tandridge District Council.
• The application Ref 2021/1259, dated 5 July 2021, was refused by notice dated
8 October 2021.
• The development proposed is two-storey side and single storey rear extensions.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Applications for costs
2. An application for costs has been made by Mr T Grimley against Tandridge
District Council. This is the subject of a separate decision.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
i) whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
having regard to national and local policies;
ii) the effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt;
iii) the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area; and
iv) if inappropriate development, whether any harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, would be clearly outweighed by other
considerations so as to amount to the very special circumstances required to
justify the proposal.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development and openness
4. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) sets out that the
construction of new buildings in the Green Belt should be regarded as
inappropriate, other than where they meet any of the exceptions listed. These
include the extension or alteration of a building, provided that it does not result
in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
Inappropriate development is, by definition, harmful to the Green Belt and
should not be approved except in very special circumstances.
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/21/3287239
2
5. Policies DP10 and DP13 of the Tandridge District Local Plan Part 2: Detailed
Policies (2014) (LPP2) set out very similar provisions. For the purposes of
Policy DP13, for residential dwellings ‘original building’ means as it existed on
31 December 1968 or, if constructed after 1968, as it was built originally. The
Framework defines the date of an ‘original building’ as 1 July 1948, or as
originally built if constructed after that date. Nevertheless, the LPP2 policies are
consistent with the Framework.
6. The supporting text to LPP2 Policy DP13 provides guidance on how to interpret
the policy, and sets out in paragraph 13.3 that the Council will adopt a
pragmatic approach in determining what constitutes a disproportionate
addition. It notes that the Framework does not provide any direction as to what
may be regarded as disproportionate, and states that the approach will be to
judge each proposal on its individual merits. It sets out that it will take into
account factors such as the size of the original building, the bulk, height, mass
and prominence of the extension or alteration and the impact of the proposal
on the openness of the Green Belt. Paragraph 13.4 goes on to say that as a
general rule, the Council will use a calculation of external volume rather than
floor area or footprint as the measure of whether a proposal is mathematically
disproportionate.
7. In correspondence during the application process, the Council has referred to a
‘generic rule’ that additions over 40% of the original volume of the dwelling
would be disproportionate. This does not however appear in any of the policies
provided to me, or their supporting text. It has not been applied in the
Council’s assessment of this proposal in the committee report, where volume is
only one of the matters considered. Nor does it appear in the other decisions
provided to me. Therefore, it has not been demonstrated that this is a ‘rule’ in
adopted policy or guidance or that it should be an overriding factor. Whether
the size of an extension would be disproportionate is not simply a mathematical
calculation, although that is one factor to consider, and I shall apply the
pragmatic approach in LPP2, as previous Inspectors have done.
8. The appeal property is a very modest two-storey semi-detached dwelling with a
single storey projection at the rear containing the only bathroom. I saw on site
that the materials and building style of the bathroom were consistent with the
rest of the dwelling. The brickwork is tied into the two-storey part of the house
with no obvious join. The appellant’s photograph also shows the structure
previously continued across the rear of No 2, before alterations to that
property. The Council considers that the bathroom was an addition based on
historic site plans for No 2, however I have not been provided with those plans.
There is nothing in the planning history before me to suggest that it was added
after the relevant date in 1968. Therefore, based on the evidence before me it
is likely that the bathroom was part of the original building as defined in LPP2.
9. To the rear of this is a shed constructed of various timber panels with a
corrugated metal roof, and a concrete coal bunker. Both are to be removed
under this proposal. The appellant asserts that they were part of the original
building and the Council disagrees, but neither has provided any detailed
evidence to support their point of view such as plans or historic maps or
photographs.
10. A dwelling of this age may well have had an outbuilding and coal bunker when
it was built, or at least prior to 31 December 1968. The existing structures are
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/21/3287239
3
weathered but are made of types of materials that have been in use for many
decades, so it is difficult to ascertain their age. Reference is made to historic
plans, but these have not been provided. Consequently, there is no substantive
evidence before me that the shed or coal bunker existed before the relevant
date. There is therefore insufficient evidence to enable me to reach a firm
conclusion on whether they were part of the original building or not.
11. The appellant has provided calculations of the volume of the existing dwelling
and structures, and the proposal. If the shed and coal bunker were also part of
the original building, these calculations indicate that the proposed extension
would represent a 38.9% increase in the volume of the building. This would be
a moderate increase in size. However, for the reasons set out above this is not
the only factor that should be taken into account.
12. The proposed extension would significantly increase the width of what is
currently a small, narrow dwelling. Although reduced from previous schemes, it
would nonetheless almost double the width of the front section of the dwelling.
While set slightly back from the front wall and down from the main ridge, it
would nonetheless add considerable bulk and mass to the side of the existing
dwelling, particularly at first floor level.
13. The extension would be clearly visible from the road and on higher ground,
with little in the way of screening, therefore it would appear as a prominent
addition despite being designed to match the existing building. The proposal
would have a much greater visual impact than the existing shed and coal
bunker, which are much lower in height and partly screened by an existing
outbuilding. Consequently, despite efforts to reduce its scale, the proposal
would dominate the existing small dwelling and significantly and harmfully alter
its very modest form.
14. The attached dwelling has been extended, however the frontage of that
property is wider than that of No 1 and the extensions are contained to the
rear rather than the side, so do not materially affect the frontage. The
extensions are seen from the commercial premises adjacent and from the rear
of the appeal site, but are otherwise largely screened from public view by the
appeal property and vegetation. The visual impact of the appeal proposal and
its proportions and relationship to the host property would therefore be
materially different to the extensions at No 2. Therefore, the extensions to the
neighbour do not justify the scale and bulk of the appeal proposal.
15. The appellant has provided details of other schemes where larger proportionate
additions have been permitted by the Council or at appeal. The Inspector’s
visual assessment of St Deny’s Orchard was that it would appear as a modest
addition from the front and not disproportionately large in context with
neighbouring extensions. Screening also meant that it would not be unduly
prominent. The visual impact of that development was not therefore
comparable to the proposal before me.
16. The development at Oakfields was allowed in the context of an extant
permission for visually similar extensions on the adjoining property, which is
not the case here. The extensions allowed for 2 Burstow Lodge Farm and
Gaysland House were both assessed as not visually or mathematically
disproportionate, with the latter also considered modest in scale having regard
to the dwelling. The Inspector for 3 Effingham Croft found that the extension
would have a footprint broadly similar to an existing extension, would
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/21/3287239
4
assimilate well with the original building and would not dominate its
appearance.
17. There are therefore material differences between those developments and the
scheme before me in terms of their visual impact. Furthermore, all of those
decisions support the approach that volumetric increase should not be used as
the sole factor in assessing whether a proposal is disproportionate.
18. In this case, the increase in the bulk and massing of the dwelling and the
prominence of the proposed extensions would also result in a reduction in
openness in both spatial and visual terms. Existing vegetation and outbuildings
would provide limited screening, and the proposal would be clearly visible
above the hedge from the front, and across the driveway at the side. This
would result in modest harm to the openness of the Green Belt.
19. Accordingly, I find that even if the shed, coal bunker and bathroom were part
of the original building, the overall scale and visual impact of the proposal and
consequent reduction in openness mean that it would result in disproportionate
additions over and above the size of the original building.
20. Therefore, the proposal would not fall within the exceptions in either LPP2
Policy DP13 or the Framework and would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt.
Character and appearance
21. Although this pair of dwellings are of different widths at the front, the porch of
No 2 set is centrally between the windows of both properties, giving the front
elevation a degree of symmetry. The porch to No 1 projects to the side, and
the two-storey side projection is set well back and of very limited width. As set
out above, the extensions to No 2 have limited visual impact from the public
realm.
22. The proposed two-storey extension would be set back from the front wall and
down from the roof ridge of the main dwelling, but only by a limited amount.
This, combined with the increased width, bulk and scale of the proposal mean
that it would visually compete with the very modest original dwelling and would
not appear subservient to it.
23. The limited set back and position of the en-suite window in the junction would
create an awkward juxtaposition and reinforce the uncomfortable relationship
between the proposed two-storey extension and the host building.
24. Consequently, although the proposed two-storey extension would use matching
materials, it would be a dominant and prominent addition which would harm
the character and appearance of the host building and the pair, and therefore
detract from the character and appearance of the area.
25. The proposed single storey rear extension would have a limited visual impact
due to its small scale, and in itself would not harm the character or appearance
of the area. This does not justify the harm from the proposed two-storey
extension however.
26. Accordingly, the proposal would conflict with Policy CSP18 of the Tandridge
District Core Strategy (2008) and LPP2 Policy DP7 which require new
development to be of a high standard of design that must reflect and respect
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/21/3287239
5
the character, setting and local context, integrate effectively with its
surroundings and reinforce local distinctiveness.
Whether very special circumstances exist
27. The evidence before me is that the significant extensions to No 2 were
approved under a different policy context. The large outbuilding was approved
as a replacement building, so was considered under a different Green Belt
policy exception to the appeal proposal. The scale and nature of that dwelling
and the visibility of the additional development from the public realm is also
materially different to the scheme before me. Therefore, the presence of these
extensions carries very limited weight.
28. The proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt and result
in a loss of openness, matters which I give substantial weight, having regard to
the Framework. It would also harm the character and appearance of the area,
and I give substantial weight to the resulting development plan conflict, given
the importance afforded to good design in national and local policy.
29. Overall, therefore, I find that the other considerations in this case do not
clearly outweigh the Green Belt and other harm that I have identified.
Consequently, the very special circumstances necessary to justify the
development do not exist. The proposal would not therefore comply with LPP2
Policy DP10.
Conclusion
30. The proposal would be harmful to the Green Belt and the character and
appearance of the area, in conflict with local and national planning policies.
There are no material considerations that justify granting permission for
development which conflicts with the development plan. Therefore, the appeal
is dismissed.
L McKay
INSPECTOR
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 5 May 2023
by L McKay MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 August 2023
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/M3645/D/21/3287239
1 Carewell Cottages, St. Piers Lane, Lingfield RH7 6PN
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr T Grimley for a full award of costs against Tandridge
District Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for two-storey side and single
storey rear extensions.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Preliminary matter
2. The Council was given the opportunity to respond to the application for costs,
but no comments were received.
Reasons
3. Parties in planning appeals normally meet their own expenses. However, the
Planning Practice Guidance (PPG) advises that costs may be awarded against a
party who has behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying
for costs to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process.
4. The PPG sets out types of behaviour which may give rise to an award of costs
against a local planning authority, including: preventing or delaying
development which should clearly be permitted, having regard to its
accordance with the development plan, national policy and any other material
considerations; failure to produce evidence to substantiate each reason for
refusal on appeal; and vague, generalised or inaccurate assertions about a
proposal’s impact, which are unsupported by any objective analysis.
5. In correspondence with a local Councillor during the application process, a
Council officer advised that they had concerns about the proposal on both
character and Green Belt grounds. When asked what percentage volume
increase would be acceptable, they set out a ‘generic rule’ of 40% increase.
6. The applicant has sought to demonstrate that their proposal falls below the
40% increase, whereas the Council considers it exceeds that. Both the Council
and applicant have provided figures for the volume of the existing dwelling. The
applicant sets out these details on a coloured plan and the Council gives a final
figure with limited details of its calculations. The differences between the
respective figures suggests that the Council did not agree with the figures on
the applicant’s plan.
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/21/3287239
2
7. The key difference between the parties in respect of volume increase relates to
whether certain features of the existing building were part of the original
building at the relevant date. They rely on different information in relation to
the existing bathroom. The Council had regard to other plans from the
neighbouring property, whereas the applicant refers to the layout and physical
features of the building and a photograph. I have not had sight of the plans the
Council refers to and therefore have reached a conclusion based on the
evidence before me. It was not however unreasonable for the Council to have
regard to other information available to it when assessing the bathroom.
8. The applicant highlights that the Council has not provided any evidence to
support its view that the bunker and shed are not original. However, I also only
have generalised statements from the applicant on this matter, with no
substantive evidence from either party to demonstrate their age. Consequently,
like the Inspectors before me, I have not therefore been able to reach a firm
conclusion as to whether these features were part of the original building. On
that basis, it was not unreasonable for the Council to take the view that it did,
although it would have been helpful if it had set out the reasons for its
conclusions in more detail, and mentioned the arguments put to it.
9. The committee report did not set out the applicant’s evidence in respect of this
part of the building, which would have been helpful. Nonetheless, the
application documents would have been publicly available to the Committee
members. Furthermore, the local Councillor who requested that the application
be brought to the Planning Committee had visited the site and was aware of
the applicant’s case in this respect.
10. The requirements for Committee Members to visit an application site are a
matter for individual Councils to determine. There is no evidence before me to
suggest that the applicant was not able to put their views to the Planning
Committee or that any Committee procedures were not followed. Therefore,
while I have not been provided with the minutes of the meeting, it has not
been demonstrated that the Planning Committee was not aware of the
applicant’s evidence when it determined the application.
11. Consequently, while it could have been more clearly articulated in the
committee report, it has not been demonstrated that the Council did not take
into account the applicant’s evidence in relation to the ‘original building’, or
that the Council made unreasonably generalised or inaccurate assertions on
this matter.
12. The committee report assesses the proposal against the relevant development
plan policies and sets out how the conclusions were reached. Reference is
made to previous applications and appeal decisions, however it is not
unreasonable to refer back to previous decisions where they are relevant, as
the applicant has in their appeal submissions.
13. The report sets out its assessment of whether the proposal was inappropriate
development in the Green Belt. This did not rely solely on mathematical
calculations of the volumetric increase proposed, but also included the visual
impact of the proposal and its impact on the openness of the Green Belt,
identifying harm to the Green Belt in these respects as well. This was in line
with the pragmatic approach set out in the supporting text to Policy DP13 of
the Tandridge Local Plan Part 2: Detailed Policies 2014 – 2019, which requires
several factors to be taken into account when assessing whether additions are
Appeal Decision APP/M3645/D/21/3287239
3
disproportionate. The Council therefore carried out an objective analysis of the
scheme against various different factors before reaching its conclusion that the
proposal would result in both mathematically and visually disproportionate
additions. Consequently, I find that the Council has adequately substantiated
its case in the appeal.
14. Even if the Council had agreed with the applicant’s volume calculations, the
visual and openness impacts on the Green Belt and the harm identified to the
character and appearance of the area may still have led to a refusal and an
appeal. Indeed, I have reached similar conclusions even if the bathroom, shed
and coal bunker are considered as part of the original building. Accordingly,
this is not a case where the development should clearly have been permitted
having regard to local and national policy and other material considerations.
15. Therefore, unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary or wasted expense
has not occurred and an award of costs is not warranted.
L McKay
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.