Erection of two storey rear extension and installation of windows to side
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Policy Weight
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 1 March 2022 by G Sibley MPLAN MRTPI
Decision by L McKay MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 4 May 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/P4605/D/21/3287131
115 St. Andrews Road, Nechells, Birmingham B9 4LW
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Evans Consulting Engineers Limited against the decision of
Birmingham City Council.
• The application Ref 2021/05961/PA, dated 1 July 2021, was refused by notice dated
22 October 2021.
• The development proposed is erection of two storey rear extension and installation of
windows to side.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to the erection of two storey rear
extension.
2. The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to the installation of windows to side
only and planning permission is granted for installation of windows to side at
115 St. Andrews Road, Nechells, Birmingham B9 4LW in accordance with the
terms of the application, Ref 2021/05961/PA, dated 1 July 2021, subject to the
following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years
from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans only insofar as they relate to the
installation of windows to side: Topographical and Coverage Plan DWG No
B21008/ECEL/DRG/BU/110 Rev F; Proposed Elevations DWG No
B21008/ECEL/DRG/BU/117 Rev C; Proposed Ground Floor Plan DWG No
B21008/ECEL/DRG/BU/113 Rev A; and Proposed First Floor Plan DWG No
B21008/ECEL/DRG/BU/114 Rev C.
3) The materials used in the construction of the windows hereby approved
shall match the materials used in the existing windows.
Appeal Procedure
3. The site visit was undertaken by an Appeal Planning Officer whose
recommendation is set out below and to which the Inspector has had regard
before deciding the appeal.
Preliminary Matters
4. The appellant submitted late evidence in relation to the original planning
application for 115 St Andrews Road and the surrounding dwellings. As this was
only made available to them following the submission of the appeal, I consider
Appeal Decision APP/P4605/D/21/3287131
2
this amounted to an exceptional circumstance and accepted it. The Council was
given the opportunity to comment on this late evidence and I am therefore
satisfied that it has not been prejudiced by accepting this late evidence.
5. The description of the development on the application form states that the first
floor of the proposed extension would be 3 metres (m) deep and the ground
floor 4m deep, however during the determination of the application amended
plans were submitted, showing the first floor as 4m deep. Submissions indicate
this change was subject to publicity and that the Council’s decision was made
on the basis of those amended plans. Therefore, in the header above I have
used the description of development from the Council’s decision notice, as this
more accurately describes the development proposed.
6. The Development Management in Birmingham Development Plan Document
(DMB) (2021) was adopted after the appeal was submitted and supersedes the
policies referred to in the decision notice from the Birmingham Unitary
Development Plan (adopted 1993). I have been provided with the DMB policy
relevant to this appeal and both parties have been given the opportunity to
comment on the change in policy context.
Main Issue
7. The effect of the proposed development upon the living conditions of the
occupiers of 117 St. Andrews Road with regard to outlook and light.
Reasons for the Recommendation
8. No 115 is a two-storey semi-detached property stepped back from the attached
property. Thus, its rear elevation projects beyond that of No 117. The closest
first floor window of No 117 is a bathroom, so is not a habitable room. The
second window, a bedroom, is set well away from the proposed extension and
has an open outlook to the rear, over the garden. At ground floor there are two
windows and a part-glazed door on the rear elevation, all serving the same
habitable room.
9. The Council’s guidance “The 45 Code” seeks to ensure that two storey
extensions are designed so as not to breach a line drawn at 45 degrees from
the quarter point of the nearest ground floor window to a habitable room, in
the interests of the outlook and daylight of the neighbouring occupiers. The
Council advises that the proposal would breach this 45-degree line in respect of
both the ground and first floor windows of No 117, which is not disputed by the
appellant. Nevertheless, it is necessary to consider whether that breach would
result in any harmful effects on the living conditions of the occupiers of No 117.
10. The existing flank wall of No 115 restricts the outlook from the ground floor
windows of No 117 to some extent but given its limited depth and the relatively
open outlook elsewhere across the garden, it does not have a significant impact
on the outlook from that room. The proposal would extend this blank wall
considerably further along this boundary, dominating and significantly
diminishing the outlook from the nearest window and creating a substantial and
harmful sense of enclosure.
11. Because of the depth and height of the proposed extension relative to the
ground floor windows, the daylight the ground floor room would receive would
be reduced. However, as the proposed extension would be to the north of
No 117 there would be no adverse impact on sunlight. Nevertheless, in
Appeal Decision APP/P4605/D/21/3287131
3
combination, this loss of daylight and outlook would create a significantly less
pleasant and useable space for the occupiers of No 117, and harmfully affect
their living conditions.
12. Despite its depth, the proposed extension would be seen at an angle from the
first-floor bedroom, so the outlook from this window would not be significantly
reduced. Due to the orientation, sunlight to this room would not be adversely
affected and, because of the lower ridgeline relative to the main roof, the
proposal would not result in a harmful loss of daylight to this room.
13. The proposal includes three new windows on the flank wall of the dwelling.
These windows would face the flank wall of No 113 and would not overlook the
rear garden of that property. Additionally, given the oblique angle and
separation distance between these windows and the window on the flank wall
of No 113 there would be no intervisibility between them. Consequently, this
element of the proposal would not lead to a loss of privacy for the occupiers of
No 113. Given their location and size, they would not harm the appearance of
the property provided they used matching materials, which could be secured by
condition.
14. Consequently, the proposed two storey rear extension would harm the living
conditions of the occupiers of No 117 with regard to outlook and light. It would
therefore be contrary to Policy PG3 of the Birmingham Development Plan 2031
(adopted 2017) and Policy DM2 of the DMB, which expect proposals to respond
to site conditions and not result in unacceptable adverse impacts on the
amenity of occupiers and neighbours. Furthermore, it would conflict with the
Places for Living Supplementary Planning Guidance (2001), Extending Your
Home Supplementary Planning Document (2007) and paragraph 130 f) of the
National Planning Policy Framework (Framework) which all seek to safeguard
the living conditions of neighbouring occupiers.
15. The proposed new side windows would accord with the above policies and
guidance and would not harm the living conditions of the occupiers of No 117.
This element of the proposal is clearly severable from the proposed extension;
therefore, I can issue a split decision. In respect of this element, in addition to
the materials condition previously mentioned, conditions regarding
implementation and compliance with the approved plans are necessary in the
interests of certainty.
Other Matters
16. The staggered building line along this section of St Andrews Road has resulted
in No 113 projecting significantly further to the rear than No 115, creating a
large flank wall along the shared boundary which the appellant raises concerns
about. However, it appears that No 113 may not have been built in accordance
with plans permitted in 1992, and therefore it is far from certain that the
Council allowed this relationship. Nevertheless, if there had been a breach of
planning control it is likely that the buildings would now be immune from
enforcement action. In any case, that permission predates the current
development plan and supplementary guidance, and therefore would have been
considered in a different policy context to that now before me. Each case must
be assessed on their own merits and the relationship between Nos 113 and 115
does not justify a proposal which would lead to harm to another neighbouring
occupiers’ living conditions.
Appeal Decision APP/P4605/D/21/3287131
4
17. The extension would create larger living accommodation for the occupant’s
family, in particular additional space for their children. This would be a private
benefit however, and it has not been demonstrated that it could not be
achieved in another, less harmful form. Therefore, I afford it limited weight.
The appellant advises that the occupiers of No 117 support the proposal,
however no evidence to that effect has been submitted to me, therefore I can
give it very little weight. These factors do not outweigh the harm the proposal
would cause to the living conditions of the neighbouring occupants.
18. A single storey rear extension of the same depth might be able to be built as
permitted development but would need to follow the prior approval process,
where amenity might stand to be considered. Even if allowed through that
process, such a development would be significantly lower in height than the
appeal proposal and therefore would not have a comparable impact on the
living conditions of No 117 in respect of outlook and light. Therefore, this
potential fallback position would not justify the appeal proposal.
19. While I recognise that the appellant has significant concerns in respect of the
Council’s handling of the planning application, it is not my role to consider
these matters in determining this appeal, which I have considered on its own
merits and the evidence before me.
Conclusion and Recommendation
20. The proposed development insofar as it relates to the two-storey rear
extension would not accord with the development plan as a whole. In contrast
the proposed installation of windows to the side of the dwelling would be
acceptable and would accord with the development plan. I therefore
recommend issuing a split decision. There are no material considerations that
justify determining the appeal other than in accordance with the development
plan and I recommend that the appeal should be dismissed insofar as it relates
to the two storey rear extension and allowed insofar as it relates to the
installation of windows to side.
G Sibley
APPEAL PLANNING OFFICER
Inspector’s Decision
21. I have considered all the submitted evidence and the Appeal Planning Officer’s
report and, on that basis, I agree with the recommendation and shall dismiss
the appeal insofar as it relates to the erection of a two -storey rear extension
and shall allow the appeal insofar as it relates to the installation of windows to
side.
L McKay
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.