Converting the garage into habitable space and adding a side extension for a new garage and home office
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Conversion/Use
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 25 January 2022
by P. D. Biggers BSc Hons MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 02 February 2022.
Appeal Ref: APP/K0235/D/21/3287026
2 Tewkesbury Road, Elstow MK42 9GD.
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Dr Chambers against the decision of Bedford Borough Council.
• The application 21/01303/FUL, dated 22 April 2021, was refused by notice dated
26 August 2021.
• The development proposed is converting the garage into habitable space and adding a
side extension for a new garage and home office.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed in respect of the side extension.
2. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted in respect of the
conversion of the garage into habitable living space at 2 Tewkesbury Road, Elstow
MK42 9GD in accordance with that part of the application 21/01303/FUL, dated 22
April 2021 relating to the conversion of the garage and the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall be begun no later than the expiration
of 3 years from the date of approval.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with the
submitted documents and the following approved plans as far as they relate to
the conversion of the garage only: Block Plan; 0021-01 Existing Plans; 0021-02
Proposed Plans; 0021-03 Existing Elevations; 0021-04 Proposed Elevations.
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of the
garage conversion hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
Main Issue
3. The main issue is the effect of the proposed development on the character and
appearance of the host dwelling and its surroundings on Tewkesbury Road and
Waltham Drive.
Reasons
4. The appeal property sits on the north side of Tewkesbury Road on a corner plot on
the junction of Tewkesbury Road and Waltham Drive. The property, as with most
of the others in the vicinity is a large, detached, two storey house built in brick
and tile with integral garage and front and rear gardens. As in a number of
locations in the estate a grassed and landscaped side garden open to the road lies
between the back of footpath line and the current rear garden boundary wall on
the west side of the property. Although, this lies within the ownership of the
appellant and is private ground it plays a role in the openness of Waltham Drive
Appeal Decision APP/K0235/D/21/3287026
2
and complements the extensive grassed and treed verge between the highway
and the footpath.
5. I have been referred to two other extensions in the vicinity which have been
granted and which the appellant considers justifies allowing the appeal proposal.
Whilst on the site visit I took the opportunity to look at these extensions. With
respect to No 6 Tewkesbury Road, the side extension, granted on appeal, is
attached to the gable wall of the main house and does not extend in depth in the
way proposed at No 2. Regarding No 3 Tewkesbury Road which was permitted
recently and not yet built, the plans show that the two storey element of the
extension would be restricted to the gable wall of the main house and the single
storey extension would be more modest in depth than that proposed at No 2. I do
not therefore consider these examples are comparable to the appeal proposal and
I will determine it on its own merits.
6. The side extension on the gable end of the house would have a lean-to roof from
the main house over the proposed garage but which then would continue virtually
the full depth of the rear garden under a double pitched roof. The whole of the
side extension extends beyond the building line on Waltham Drive which is
established by the gable wall of No 2 and the garage of the dwelling to the north
of No 2 on Waltham Drive. It would therefore be prominent and obtrusive in the
street scene.
7. The depth of the extension extending approximately 10 metres beyond the rear
elevation of the house would be excessive and disproportionate to the main
house. Even screened by landscaping as proposed, the positioning of the side
extension, almost on the back of footpath line, and, notwithstanding the treed
verge to the highway, would have the effect of reducing the sense of openness on
this side of Waltham Drive. I have been referred to No 7 Waltham Drive opposite
which has a two storey gabled elevation and garden boundary wall on the back of
footpath line which the appellant considers has a similar effect to what would be
the result at No 2. However, in the case of No 7, this appears to be the original
design for the property and the effect of its positioning on the back of footpath
line simply reinforces the fact that a similar approach at No 2 Tewkesbury Road
would further reduce the open character on this prominent corner.
8. It has been put to me that there is a ‘fallback position’ which the appellant could
carry out without permission and which they consider would result in a similar
impact to the proposed side extension – namely the relocation of the boundary
wall to the rear garden westwards to the back of footpath line on the highway. I
accept this could be done but it could only be rebuilt to a maximum height of 1.8
metres without permission. The height to eaves of the proposed extension would
be about 2.5 metres and to ridge on the side extension about 3.4 metres.
Therefore, the visual impact of the extension would be significantly greater than a
relocated boundary wall. I therefore conclude that the fallback is not relevant.
9. In terms of the proposed garage conversion to habitable space, provided the
installation of windows and the new brickwork is carried out in the same materials
as the existing house (which can be conditioned), there would be no direct impact
on the character and appearance of the house or its surroundings. There would be
a loss of garage accommodation for cars but the forecourt to the property could
accommodate an additional vehicle and therefore the proposal would not reduce
parking beyond the level required for the size of house. The parking of an
additional vehicle would have some impact on the appearance of the frontage but
not significant as the vehicles would not be a permanent fixture in the street
scene. This element of the proposal would therefore not conflict with Bedford
Appeal Decision APP/K0235/D/21/3287026
3
Borough Local Plan (BBLP) Policy 31 dealing with the access impacts of
development.
10. It is open to me to issue a split decision where different elements of a proposal
are not physically or functionally linked and one element is acceptable whilst the
other is not. That would be the case here where the garage conversion could take
place independently of the side extension without adverse impact on character
and appearance or highway safety.
11. The National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) at paragraph 130
requires that developments must be sympathetic to local character to create high
quality buildings and spaces amongst other things and at paragraph 134 that
development that is not well designed should be refused. Policies 28S and 29 of
the Bedford Borough Local Plan (BBLP), on place making and design quality
respectively, reflect the Framework in requiring high quality design that integrates
with and complements the character of the area and takes opportunities to
enhance that character. In addition, BBLP Policy 30 in requiring development to be
designed to contribute to townscape and landscape qualities and to be compatible
with the scale, massing, height, layout and materials of the context in which it sits
is also consistent with the Framework. The Council, in order to assist householders
in designing extensions and alterations has prepared the Residential Extensions
New Dwellings and Small Infill Developments Supplementary Planning Document
(RENSID). The RENSID stresses in Extensions Design Code No 3 the importance of
space around buildings when designing extensions and I am not satisfied that due
regard has been paid to this aspect in designing the appeal proposal.
12. For the reasons above the proposed side extension to the property as a result of
its positioning and excessive length would be disproportionate to the scale and
form of the original building and detrimental to its character and appearance as
well as detrimental to the open character of Waltham Drive. Rather than enhance
the character of the estate at this point the proposed side extension would conflict
with the objectives of BBLP Policies 28S, 29 and 30 and the RENSID guidance.
13. However, as set out above, whilst I will dismiss the appeal in respect of the
proposed side extension I will allow the conversion of the garage and grant
permission for that element.
Other Matters
14. I understand the appellant’s wish to achieve additional family accommodation and
private home work space through the conversion and side extension and in that
way make sustainable and effective use of housing land, an objective which is
encouraged by the Framework in Section 11. However, paragraph 124 in the same
section of the Framework states that this should not be at the expense of
maintaining an area’s prevailing character and setting. As such, sustainable and
effective use of the dwelling to create workspace in a side extension would not
outweigh the harm to the character and appearance of the original dwelling and
Tewkesbury Road and Waltham Drive as a result of the proposal.
Conclusion
15. In reaching my decision I have had regard to the matters before me and, for the
reasons above, the appeal in respect of the side extension should be dismissed
but allowed in respect of the garage conversion and planning permission granted.
P. D. Biggers
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.