Install replacement windows and French doors to property
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Extensions
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 25 January 2022
by Mrs H Nicholls FdA MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 1 March 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/C1760/D/21/3286624
Yew Tree Cottage, Up Somborne Lane, Up Somborne SO20 6RB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Dr Jones against the decision of Test Valley Borough Council.
• The application Ref 21/02344/FULLS, dated 6 August 2021, was refused by notice dated
13 October 2021.
• The development proposed is install replacement windows and French doors to
property.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. The appeal, whilst relating to a planning matter, would involve works to a listed
building for which separate Listed Building Consent (LBC) would be necessary.
Though LBC was applied for and refused by the Council1, that refusal is not the
subject of a separate appeal.
3. For the purposes of this appeal, I have had special regard to section 66(1) of
the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 (the Act).
Main Issue
4. The main issue is whether the proposal would preserve the Grade II listed
building known as ‘Yew Tree Cottage and Maisemore’, its setting, and any of
the features of special architectural or historic interest that it possesses.
Reasons
5. The appeal building, Yew Tree Cottage, (listed as Yew Tree Cottage and
Maisemore as one Grade II building, list entry number: 140805), is one of a
pair of semi-detached cottages within the small rural village of Up Somborne.
The statutory list entry description identifies the appeal building as a pair of
early C19 cottages, constructed of red brick and with a thatched roof. The
cottages have a shared central stack and separate stacks to the original outer
walls. They also have front doors under open pent-roofed porches, timber
casement windows, and upper window heads set within eyebrow dormers.
6. The cottages are two storeys in height, originally with three small bays. The
appeal building has previously been extended so that it now has a fourth bay,
constructed in the same style as the rest of the cottage. The rear of the
1 Under application reference 21/02345/LBWS, refused on 13 October 2021
Appeal Decision APP/C1760/D/21/3286624
2
cottages have also been altered and individualised. The appeal building hosts
a timber conservatory projection (with double glazed timber-framed glazing),
in addition to a rearward projection over two storeys which also forms part of
the extension to its side. The symmetry of the appeal building has been partly
eroded by the side extension, but its construction true to the style and in the
materials of the original building has not harmed its overall integrity.
7. Given the above, I find that the special interest of the listed building, insofar as
it relates to this appeal, to be primarily associated with its early C19 date, its
vernacular design, overall composition of the principal elevation, surviving
traditional materials, along with its detailing and construction.
8. The proposal seeks to replace 15 windows, from timber, single pane, side-hung
casement windows to timber, flush-fitting casements with double glazed units.
The glazing would have an overall thickness of 28 mm. The proposal also
includes the replacement of the double doors with timber double doors which
would have double glazed lights.
9. Of the existing windows, five are within the extension to the building, and I
observed that 10 windows (5 within the front and 5 in the rear) are older. The
newer windows in the extension, all single glazed, appeared to be in reasonable
condition. Of the older windows, those in the front appeared to have some
signs of age and wear, despite layers of paint. The older rear windows
appeared to be in a poorer condition still, with some cracks and areas of repair
work. The evidence of the appellant, albeit limited, is that the window frames
are rotten in places and have already been repaired with filler.
10. Irrespective of their condition, the windows add to the listed building’s
authenticity, and thus to its significance and special interest. The newer
windows and double doors in the extension do not add special interest, but
their single glazed form and style is true to the appearance of those historically
installed in the building, helping to maintain its character and integrity. Given
that the character of the older windows has been acquired over many years,
their replacement would result in the loss of a feature that adds to the special
architectural and historic interest of the listed building.
11. Whilst the proposed replacement timber casements have been designed to
replicate the existing windows in terms of their frame size, glazing bar patterns
and number of divisions, the glazing units would be at the thickest end of the
spectrum at 28mm. This thickness of unit would appear particularly bulky, with
limited reveals, and lacking finesse when compared to the existing slender,
single glazed windows.
12. On the evidence before me, I am not satisfied that the windows could not be
repaired by traditional means. Moreover, it seems unlikely that replacement of
all of the windows would be justified on the grounds of decay. Even if there
were justification to replace one or more of the windows, I am not satisfied
that the design of the units before me is the most appropriate option. Nor is
there clear evidence that this is the only way to improve thermal insulation.
13. Whilst the appellant indicates that the scale and visual appearance of the
windows would be unchanged, and that the distance of the dwelling from the
road means that it is not prominent, I do not agree that this would be the case.
Whether or not the windows would be seen, they are historic fabric, the loss of
which is not taken lightly. In any event, the building is visible from the public
Appeal Decision APP/C1760/D/21/3286624
3
realm and the windows, in the form they are seen, contribute to the aesthetic
of the listed building as a whole.
14. Removing the existing windows would fail to preserve the listed building. The
proposal would, therefore, conflict with Policies E1 and E9 of the Test Valley
Borough Council Local Plan (2016), which seek to secure a high quality of
development, in terms of design and local distinctiveness, and permit
development only where it would make a positive contribution to sustaining or
enhancing the significance of the heritage asset taking account of its character,
appearance and setting. It would also conflict with the expectations of section
66(1) of the Act.
15. Under the terms of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework),
the degree of harm would be less than substantial. The Framework requires
that where a proposal would lead to less than substantial harm to the
significance of a designated heritage asset, this harm should be weighed
against the public benefits.
16. The public benefits in this case would result from the potential improvement to
the building’s thermal efficiency, which is also suggested links with the need to
replace its main heating source in the near future. However, in the absence of
detailed evidence regarding the thermal performance of the proposed windows
or comparison with the existing or any alternatives considered, I attribute this
public benefit only limited weight. Furthermore, the marginal soundproofing
and safety benefits that would accrue from new double glazed units are also
very limited.
17. As such, in my view, the limited public benefits are not of a magnitude that
outweighs the identified harm to the significance of the heritage asset, and the
considerable importance this carries.
Conclusion
18. For the reasons set out above, the appeal is dismissed.
Hollie Nicholls
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.