Retrospective application for non-porous driveway and pillar to include additional bi-fold (sic) front gates, pedestrian access gate and additional pillar
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Flood Risk
Highways & Transport
Parking Provision
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 29 December 2021
by Andrew Dale BA (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 19 January 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/F5540/D/21/3286474
17 Howard Road, Isleworth TW7 6JL
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Laila Khatun against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Hounslow.
• The application ref. 00633/17/P1, dated 13 July 2021, was refused by notice dated
15 September 2021.
• The development proposed is described on the application form as “retrospective
application for non-porous driveway and pillar to include additional bi-fold (sic) front
gates, pedestrian access gate and additional pillar”.
Preliminary matter
1. The Council’s description of the proposal in its decision notice clarified that the
existing non-porous driveway benefits from drainage to a soakaway which is
already in place. The descriptions of the proposal given on the application form
and the decision notice are misleading as a reader is alerted to one existing
pillar and one additional pillar. It is apparent that the proposal would include 3
pillars in total (each 2m high), 2 of which were in place at the time of the
application. I have assessed the appeal proposal on the basis that it relates to
“an existing non-porous driveway (draining to a soakaway) and 2 existing 2m
high pillars and the proposed inclusion of bifold front vehicular gates, a
pedestrian access gate and one additional 2m high pillar”.
Decision
2. The appeal is dismissed insofar as it relates to 2 existing 2m high pillars and
the proposed inclusion of bifold front vehicular gates, a pedestrian access gate
and one additional 2m high pillar and planning permission is refused for 2
existing 2m high pillars and the proposed inclusion of bifold front vehicular
gates, a pedestrian access gate and one additional 2m high pillar.
3. The appeal is allowed insofar as it relates to an existing non-porous driveway
(draining to a soakaway) and planning permission is granted for an existing
non-porous driveway (draining to a soakaway) at 17 Howard Road, Isleworth
TW7 6JL in accordance with the terms of the application, ref. 00633/17/P1,
dated 13 July 2021 and the plans submitted with it so far as relevant to that
part of the development hereby permitted and subject to the following
conditions:
Appeal Decision APP/F5540/D/21/3286474
2
1) The non-porous driveway (draining to a soakaway) hereby permitted shall not
be used for the parking of motor vehicles until the 2 existing 2m high pillars
have been taken down and removed from the site frontage or reduced in overall
height to no more than 600mm above the level of the adjacent public footway.
2) Part of the non-porous driveway (draining to a soakaway) hereby permitted
close to the eastern side boundary shall be kept available as a minimum 1.2m
wide clear path running to the front door of the property from the street and
that route shall be retained free from any obstruction along its length.
Main issue
4. The main issue is the implications of the development for pedestrian safety.
Reasons
5. No. 17 lies at the end of a short terrace of 4 houses on the southern side of
Howard Road which is a one-way residential street with a 20mph speed limit
marker painted on the carriageway. The front door to the property is in the side
elevation facing the eastern side boundary.
6. The proposed scheme of works would utilize an existing crossover which would
not be altered. The previous concrete-based driveway was in a poor condition
and laid without drainage facilities. This has been replaced by another non-
porous surface in the form of dark grey block paving with a channel drain and
soakaway, both of which have been installed. The hardstanding has been laid to
a high standard. There are lighter coloured blocks set within it to create patterns
and define the edges. The gradient of the driveway is acceptable. A potential
flower bed has been retained along the western side boundary as before. Viewed
purely as a replacement physical construction, I could not identify any objections
to the hardstanding in itself given the drainage and visual upgrades over the
former situation. The Council also reached the view that the proposal, in its
entirety, would avoid harm to the appearance of the area.
7. However, the difficulties arise from the use of the driveway when allied to the
existing and proposed front boundary treatments.
8. The scale to which the site block plan has been drawn makes its interpretation
somewhat problematical. Nonetheless, I found the driveway to be 6.5m deep
and the parking spaces appear to be 4.8m deep, taking both measurements
from the front of the house and not the drainage channel set out in front of it.
However, there is a conflict between the 3 parking spaces indicated upon that
plan and the categoric statement on the application form at section 11 that the
number of proposed car parking spaces would be 2, just as the pre-existing
situation. I note also the most easterly of the 3 indicative car parking spaces on
the plan would be almost impossible to use if the central space was occupied, as
it would be partly placed behind the proposed pedestrian gate and one of the
pillars. The plan also shows that the opening and closing of the proposed bifold
vehicular gates could be restricted by vehicles parked on the forecourt.
9. Of more concern is the fact that the 3 pillars (2 of which are in place) would
reach an overall height of about 2m above the level of the adjacent public
footway. The Council’s Residential Crossovers and Off-Steet Parking Policy
(RCPP), adopted in October 2016, says that pedestrian visibility splays of 2.4m x
Appeal Decision APP/F5540/D/21/3286474
3
2.4m at the back of the footway and on both sides of the crossover will be
required and that there must be no obstructions over 600mm high in this area.
Generally, this will require the front boundary of the property to be no higher
than 600mm. All parts of the proposed front boundary structures (gates and
pillars) would be between about 1.5m high and about 2m high. As such, it has
not been demonstrated that there would be the required pedestrian visibility
splays. It would therefore be very difficult for drivers making an exit from the
appeal property to safely see pedestrians approaching along the public footway
on this side of Howard Road. In turn, pedestrians would not be adequately
aware of vehicles emerging from the property’s driveway. There would be an
unacceptable impact on pedestrian safety.
10. The appeal scheme would not: create a place that is safe; minimize the scope
for conflicts between pedestrians and vehicles; or respond to design standards. I
accept that the proposal is modest in scale and that the vehicular manoeuvres
from the property would take place at low speeds and would not be as frequent
as those along say an adopted road or for other land uses but the relevant
design standards are applicable to single family dwellings. If accident records for
the locality confirm that no single incident involved vehicle movements to and
from existing crossovers, this might be to do with the generally low height of the
front boundary structures I saw along Howard Road. I also acknowledge the
safety and security reasons for the proposed works as expressed in the
appellant’s personal statement at Appendix A of the appeal statement and I do
not dismiss them lightly but they do not provide justification for the creation of a
situation that would result in hazards for pedestrians.
11. I conclude on the main issue that the adverse implications of the development
for pedestrian safety would place the scheme in conflict with the aims of Policy
EC2 of the Hounslow Local Plan 2015-2030 which, amongst other things, seeks
to secure a more sustainable local travel network that maximises opportunities
for walking and avoids adverse impacts on the transport network. This policy is
not inconsistent with the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework).
12. The appellant has not commented on the Council’s other identified concern; the
absence on the plans of a minimum 1.2m wide clear path running to the front
door of the property from the street as required by the RCPP. This would be very
difficult to achieve if the plan was to be fully implemented as submitted. I
consider that this matter could be addressed by a planning condition as I explain
in the next paragraph when summing up my overall approach to this appeal.
13. The Framework advises that local planning authorities should approach decision
making on proposed development in a positive and creative way and should
consider whether otherwise unacceptable development could be made
acceptable through the use of conditions. As I have found that no harm would
result from the hardstanding in itself, I intend to issue a split decision on this
appeal: this will permit the existing non-porous driveway (draining to a
soakaway) but not the 2 existing 2m high pillars or the proposed inclusion of
bifold front vehicular gates, a pedestrian access gate and one additional 2m high
pillar. The part of the proposal I am allowing has already been implemented but
2 conditions are necessary which should not come as a surprise to any party.
Firstly, the 2 existing 2m high pillars need to be taken down and removed from
the site frontage or at least reduced in overall height to no more than 600mm
Appeal Decision APP/F5540/D/21/3286474
4
above the level of the adjacent public footway. This would achieve some
consistency with the other part of the proposal which is not being permitted. Any
other approach to those pillars would be illogical and harmful to pedestrian
safety. Secondly, in the interests of pedestrian safety, part of the driveway close
to the eastern side boundary should be kept available as a minimum 1.2m wide
clear path running to the front door of the property from the street and that
route should be retained free from any obstruction along its length. I see no
need for it to be marked out as such or laid in a different material. It is sufficient
that such a route is kept available for pedestrians.
14. As the part of the development I am permitting has already been carried out, I
see no need for any of Council’s suggested conditions relating to the time period
for the commencement of development, the specification of plans and the use of
matching materials.
15. I have considered all the submitted evidence from all the parties but I find no
other matters to outweigh the findings that have led to my decision on this
appeal. I should emphasize that the appellant remains at liberty to discuss
alternative proposals for the front boundary with the Council, regardless of the
outcome of this appeal.
Andrew Dale
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.