Conversion of roof space to habitable use to include front and rear dormers, and conversion of roof from hip to gable end to include new gable end window
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Conversion/Use
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 5 January 2022
by Terrence Kemmann-Lane JP DipTP FRTPI MCMI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 19 JANUARY 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/B5480/D/21/3285680
20 St Albans Avenue, Upminster, RM14 3JS
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Edward Stuckey against the decision of the London Borough
of Havering.
• The application Ref P1497.21, dated 28 July 2021, was refused by notice dated 22
September 2021.
• The development proposed is the conversion of roof space to habitable use to include
front and rear dormers, and conversion of roof from hip to gable end to include new
gable end window.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the conversion of
roof space to habitable use to include front and rear dormers, and conversion
of roof from hip to gable end to include new gable end window at 20 St Albans
Avenue, Upminster, RM14 3JS in accordance with the terms of the application,
Ref P1497.21, dated 28 July 2021, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin not later than 3 years from
the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall not be carried out otherwise than
complete accordance with the approved plans reference 101, 102, 103, 104,
105, and 106.
3) All new external finishes shall be in materials to match those of the existing
building.
4) Notwithstanding the provisions of the Town and Country Planning (General
Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015, no window or other opening
(other than those shown on the submitted and approved plans,) shall be
formed in the flank wall of the development hereby permitted, unless
specific permission under the provisions of the Town and Country Planning
Act 1990 has first been sought and obtained in writing from the Local
Planning Authority.
5) The proposed flank windows serving the landing and bathroom as shown on
drawings numbers 105 and 106, with the exception of any top hung
fanlight, shall be permanently glazed with obscure glass not less than level
Appeal Decision APP/B5480/D/21/3285680
2
4 on the standard scale of obscurity and permanently fixed shut and shall
thereafter be maintained in that form.
Main Issues
2. There are 2 main issues in this case: i) the effect of the gabled roof on the
character of the host dwelling and the semi-detached bungalows in the road;
and ii) the effect of the front dormer window on the character and appearance
of the host dwelling and the semi-detached pair of which it is part.
Reasons
3. St Albans Avenue consists of semi-detached bungalows, all of which originally
had hipped roofs. There are 2 basic designs in the original development, some
have forward projections, but still under hipped roofs. A number of bungalows
have been extended upwards by the insertion of dormer windows in the roof,
and there are evident examples of conversion to a gable roof to one dwelling in
a pair. The council states that such examples of conversions to gables have
occurred outside of planning control and a Lawful Development Certificate was
given by the council in respect of No. 14 St Albans Avenue for a hip to gable
conversion and rear dormer. This alteration to the roof at No. 14 has since
been carried out, as I saw at my site visit. A similar Certificate at No. 16 is also
referred to.
4. In respect of the first issue, at present the avenue has largely retained a
pleasant character from the original construction period. The odd examples
where there have been changes to the roof of one of a pair are conspicuous in
the street scene. It is understandable why the officer took the view that
resulted in the refusal of permission, bearing in mind the policies in the
Residential Extensions and Alterations Supplementary Planning Document
which stems from Policy DC61 of the council’s Core Strategy and Development
Control Policies Development Plan Document. A single hip to gable alteration to
a pair of semi-detached does indeed unbalance the pair and have a rather
incongruous appearance. Had that been the only consideration, I would have
concluded as the officer did.
5. However, the matter of a ‘fallback position’ has been raised, and this is a
material consideration in this case. The decision in the case of Gambone v.
Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government and Wolverhampton
City Council [2014] EWHC 952 (Admin) is referred to in some detail in the
appellants appeal statement, such that I need not set it out here. Suffice to say
that a fallback can be a material consideration where there is a greater than
theoretical possibility of the development taking place, and can be a form of
development that is allowed for by virtue of entitlements such as provided by
the General Permitted Development Order (GPDO). The weight to be given to
such a fallback is a matter for the decision maker in the circumstances of the
case, including the scale of harm which would arise.
6. The appellant accepts that the totality of the appeal proposal could not be
achieved by way of the fallback, which in this case is Class B – additions etc to
the roof of a dwellinghouse – of the GPDO. The front dormer is not permitted
under this class because it fronts a highway, and the hip to gable and rear
dormer does not conform because the volume exceeds 50 m3. However, in
respect of the latter, the appellant’s argument is that the excess above 50 m3
is marginal at 7 m3, and the proposal for the dormer could be reduced by this
Appeal Decision APP/B5480/D/21/3285680
3
amount, providing the appellant with most of the accommodation (in this part
of the proposal) that is sought.
7. Looking at the extent to which this is a real possibility rather than theoretical, it
seems to me that the fact that a scheme was drawn up, a planning application
submitted, and an appeal entered, all point to a desire by the appellant to carry
out the development and suggest that some financial planning has also taken
place. The fact that the fallback would provide less that is desired, is a negative
factor in terms of it being a likely path to follow, but it may be something of a
cheaper option, which could have attraction. I conclude that there is a greater
than theoretical possibility of the fallback development taking place in the
event of this appeal being dismissed. The other cases referred to that have
been carried out without express planning permission also show that this is
seen as a beneficial addition to these bungalows. I will turn to the weight to be
given to this in my overall conclusions.
8. I now turn to the second issue - the effect of the front dormer window on the
character and appearance of the host dwelling and the semi-detached pair of
which it is part. Clearly the front dormer is part of a single scheme that
provides the accommodation sought, and it could not be developed as a stand-
alone element without the gable and rear dormer. Nevertheless, at this point it
is necessary to separate this element from the rest of the appeal scheme,
before coming to an overall conclusion, since the outcome of the second issue
could have a decisive effect on the decision on the total appeal proposal.
9. Looking at the front dormer alone, it must be seen in the context that there are
a substantial number of front dormers in St Albans Avenue already; thus a
front dormer does not have the impact of being unusual in the street scene.
Furthermore, there are examples that I consider are more intrusive than the
appeal proposal. This is because, in some instances they combine in a pair of
semi-detached bungalows to be incongruous through a difference in scale and
form, taking no account of each other. In other cases their size and position in
the roof is unsympathetic and out of scale with the roof within which they are
set.
10. The appeal proposal is relatively small, being set down from the ridge, well up
from the eaves and having suitable gaps on either side. I consider that in the
context of existing front dormers the appeal proposal is acceptable and would
not have an overly harmful effect on the character and appearance of the host
dwelling or the semi-detached neighbour. But, since it relies on the gable form
of roof, can only be considered favourably if the hip to gable can be approved.
Overall conclusion
11. In my judgement the fallback proposition is a material consideration of some
weight: it is certainly more that a theoretical possibility, and I regard it as
being more than likely to be implemented in the event of the appeal being
dismissed. Taken with the fact that there are other examples in the vicinity and
that it is likely to be an enlargement of the quite modest bungalows that will be
attractive to others, it seems to me that the balance comes down to accepting
a likely hip to gable outcome, and permitting a scheme that would provide a
designed solution to the appellant’s wish for greater accommodation more
suited to modern lifestyles. In this case this includes the provision of a home
working space, as proposed on the ground floor. I reach this view with the
Appeal Decision APP/B5480/D/21/3285680
4
recognition that a gable on one roof of a pair introduces the unfortunate effect
that I have referred to in paragraph 4 above.
12. In the situation where the hip to gable configuration is accepted because of the
strength of the fallback, the front dormer becomes a feature that is rather
familiar in St Albans Avenue, and the particular form and proportions proposed
minimise its impact. Overall I find that the front dormer is an acceptable
feature in the composition of the overall appeal proposal.
13. In the light of these conclusions, and having taken all other matters into
account, I will allow the appeal.
Conditions
14. The Council has suggested a number of conditions in the event that the appeal
is upheld. I have considered these in the light of Planning Practice Guidance
(PPG). For clarity and to ensure compliance with the PPG I have amended some
of the text. I consider that the conditions should be imposed for the following
reasons: condition 2 is required for certainty and avoidance of doubt as to the
development permitted; condition 3 is to ensure that the appearance of the
development permitted integrates with the existing in a visually satisfactory
manner; conditions 4 and 5 are to ensure no loss of privacy to the
neighbouring property.
Terrence Kemmann-Lane
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.