First-floor rear extension (retrospective) to form part of two-storey rear extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
No strong technical themes detected.
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 22 February 2022
by M Cryan BA(Hons) DipTP MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 10 March 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/L5240/D/21/3285653
184 Parchmore Road, Thornton Heath CR7 8HA
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Ms Debbie Dwyer against the decision of the Council of the
London Borough of Croydon.
• The application Ref 21/02565/HSE, dated 13 May 2021, was refused by notice dated
23 August 2021.
• The development proposed is described on the application form as “a first-floor rear
extension (retrospective) to form part of two-storey rear extension”.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. As described in the banner heading above, the development for which planning
permission is sought has already been constructed, and I was able to view it at
the time of my site visit.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are the effect of the proposed development on:
• The character and appearance of the area; and
• Living conditions for neighbouring occupiers of Nos 182 and 186 Parchmore
Road, with particular regard to overshadowing and loss of privacy.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal site is a semi-detached house on a long and narrow plot on the
north-east side of Parchmore Road. To the north, No 186 forms the other half
of the semi-detached pair; to the south lies a modern four storey block of flats
at No 182 Parchmore Road, beyond which (and also adjoining the rear garden
of the appeal property) is Queensbury Court, a development of two three-
storey blocks of flats on either side of a grassed courtyard. The surrounding
area is predominantly residential, although there are some community and
commercial uses, including tyre and vehicle repair/MOT garages opposite the
appeal site.
5. The appeal property has been extended to the rear in various stages, including
a dormer extension and detached outbuilding for which a certificate of lawful
Appeal Decision APP/L5240/D/21/3285653
2
development was granted1, and alterations to form a single storey side and
rear extension which was granted planning permission in 20172. The appellant
now seeks planning permission for the retention of a first-floor rear extension,
which it is stated has been in place since 2015. This comprises a flat-roofed
extension above the property’s original rear outrigger, connected to a large
first-floor rear extension with a side-facing pitched gable roof. The
development was previously the subject of an appeal in respect of an
enforcement notice which had been served in 2016, which was dismissed in
December of that year (“the 2016 appeal”)3.
6. The Council’s 2018 Suburban Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document
(“the SPD”) provides guidance in respect of residential extensions and
alterations, with the aim of ensuring that they do not have a detrimental effect
on the character and appearance of either the host property or the wider area.
This includes advising that extensions should respond to the character of the
area and the existing dwelling, should generally be subservient in scale to the
existing property. It also advises that windows and doors should be designed to
avoid poorly proportioned, positioned and detailed openings, and that
architectural details and decorations should respond to existing features.
7. The extension which has been built is a substantial addition to the appeal
property. Although it is partly obscured by the four-storey flats at No 182 it is
nevertheless visible from Parchmore Road. The two-storey rear gable is also a
prominent feature when seen from the courtyard of Queensbury Court; the
extension is therefore prominent in public and semi-public views in the area.
The bulk and massing of the extension mean that it dominates and overwhelms
the original dwelling. The rear gable roof gives the extension the impression of
being barely related to the original property, while the detailing, notably the
size, scale and positioning of the windows on the rear extension, also bears
little relation to the features of the original building. From Queensbury Court in
particular, the extension therefore gives the impression of being a separate
property. An additional side extension – not shown in the submitted drawings –
has the appearance of a conservatory at first-floor level, adding to the chaotic
visual impact of the property.
8. In upholding the Council’s enforcement notice, the Inspector in the 2016
appeal described the rear extension as having a “squat form”, and the overall
massing of the development as being “neither balanced nor subservient”. They
described the window detailing as “haphazard” and “visually unsettling”, and
other detailing and decoration as “clumsy and ill-matched”. I concur with all of
these observations; in my view, the bulk, massing, design and detailing of the
extension make it overbearing and incongruous, and it detracts from the
original restrained and modest character and appearance of the host property.
9. Since the decision of the Inspector in the 2016 appeal, the appellant argues
that there are now “exceptional and extenuating circumstances […] relating to
the site and its surroundings, that suggest that planning permission must be
granted”. In particular, the appellant is aggrieved that the Council has granted
planning permission for development at both 182 and 186 Parchmore Road,
while refusing planning permission for the development of the appeal property.
1 LPA Ref: 09/00882/LP
2 LPA Ref: 17/01198/FUL
3 PINS Ref: APP/L5240/C/16/3150489
Appeal Decision APP/L5240/D/21/3285653
3
10. In respect of character and appearance, the appellant’s arguments centre on a
development of single- and two-storey side and rear extensions at No 186, for
which planning permission was granted in January 20194. The extensions at
No 186 have not yet been constructed, however, the submitted drawings which
the appellant has provided show that it would have a two-storey rear extension
with a side-facing pitched gable roof, and would be connected to the existing
dwelling by a flat-roofed extension at first-floor level. It would therefore, in
bulk and massing at least, reflect the extension already built at the appeal
property.
11. If the only harm caused by the extension at the appeal property were as a
consequence of its bulk and massing, the Council’s subsequent decision in
respect of No 186 would in my view be likely to justify allowing the appeal,
notwithstanding my misgivings which I have set out above. However, the
submitted drawings show that the fenestration and other detailing proposed at
No 186 would be more in keeping with the original property than is the case in
this appeal. The harm which I have found arising from the poor detailing and
subsequent very weak visual relationship between the extension and the
original appeal property would remain. While the grant of planning permission
for a similar development at No 186 is a material consideration which carries
some weight in favour of the appeal scheme, in my view it does not outweigh
all of the harm which I have found in respect of character and appearance, nor
does it therefore justify allowing this appeal.
12. I conclude that the extension for which planning permission is sought is,
because of its bulk, massing and detailed design, harmful to the character and
appearance of the area. The development therefore conflicts with Policies SP4
and DM10 of the 2018 Croydon Local Plan (“the CLP”), and with Policy D3 of
the London Plan 2021; together these policies seek to ensure that development
is well-designed, and that its design and detailing contributes positively to local
character.
Living conditions
13. The extension at the rear of the appeal property stands directly to the south of
the rear garden of No 184. Although my site visit was carried out on an
overcast and rainy day and therefore there was no visible overshadowing, I
note the observations of the Inspector in the 2016 appeal that “in the late
morning of a sunny November day, the tall, wide extension cast deep shadows
over the whole width of garden immediately to the rear of the attached house”,
and that although it would be less pronounced in the summer months “the
[overshadowing] effect is seriously harmful”. Clearly the relative orientation of
the properties has not changed, and there is no reason for me to take a
different view to my predecessor on the facts of this matter.
14. The first-floor side and rear windows on the extension overlook the courtyard
of Queensbury Court, and the side windows overlook the small rear garden of
No 182. There is consequently a loss of privacy for the occupiers of both of
those neighbouring properties; in respect of Queensbury Court, the separation
distances are such that, given the communal nature of the courtyard, I do not
consider this to be seriously harmful. However, the direct overlooking of the
garden at the rear of No 182 from a very short distance seriously and
adversely harms privacy for the occupiers of that block.
4 LPA Ref: 18/05948/HSE
Appeal Decision APP/L5240/D/21/3285653
4
15. In respect of No 186, I do not accept the appellant’s assertion that “the
approved extension on that property exhibits the exact same relationship as
that of the appeal scheme”; the proposed extension at No 186 would be to the
north of the appeal site, and therefore regardless of similarities in bulk and
scale there could be no overshadowing. At the same time, while I note the
Council’s observation that the extension there has not been built, again the
permission is a material consideration, and again were the effects of the
extension on No 186 the only point of conflict it might well have led my
decision in a different direction. However, that an extension is likely to be built
at the rear of No 186 could not mitigate the effects of the appeal property in
respect of No 182, and the harm in respect of loss of privacy would remain.
16. In respect of No 182, the appellant has commented that “it is somewhat
perverse of the Council to suggest that there is overlooking of the rear amenity
space to these flats. To the contrary, the appellant has experienced a severe
loss of outlook, daylight and sunlight, and loss of privacy, as a result of the
construction of these flats”. The flats replaced a bungalow which previously
stood at No 182, and from the rear garden of the appeal property I saw that
not only is the block visually overbearing and dominant, it must also have
significantly increased overshadowing and reduced privacy in the appellant’s
rear garden compared to the situation previously. I therefore have considerable
sympathy with the point made by the appellant in respect of No 182. However,
that another harmful development has been permitted nearby, even as close as
next door, does not justify allowing the further harm to living conditions which
arises from this scheme.
17. I conclude that, because of its harmful effect on privacy in the rear garden of
No 182, the appeal scheme causes significant harm to living conditions for the
occupiers of that property. The development therefore conflicts with Policies
SP4.1 and DM10 of the CLP and Policy D3 of the London Plan 2021, as well as
advice in the SPD, which among other things seek to ensure that development
protects the amenity of occupiers of adjoining buildings.
Conclusion
18. The appellant argues that the extension has been in existence for several years
and that there are considerable extenuating circumstances. That the extension
has been constructed without planning permission has not had a bearing on my
decision; however, I have found that it causes material harm to the character
and appearance of the area, and to neighbours’ living conditions.
19. The scheme therefore conflicts with the development plan taken as a whole.
There are no material considerations, including the Framework, which indicate
that a decision should be made other than in accordance with the development
plan. For the reasons given above, the appeal is therefore dismissed.
M Cryan
Inspector
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.