Rear extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Policy Weight
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 February 2022
by Ian McHugh DipTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date:2ND March 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/B3438/D/21/3285214
The Dairy, Ringe Hay Farm, Basford, Leek, Staffordshire, ST13 7ET
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Hickinson against the decision of Staffordshire
Moorlands District Council.
• The application Ref SMD/2021/0321, dated 8 May 2021, was refused by notice dated
30 July 2021.
• The development proposed is a rear extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for a rear extension
at The Dairy, Ringe Hay Farm, Basford, Leek, Staffordshire, ST13 7ET in
accordance with the terms of the application Ref SMD/2021/0321, dated
8 May 2021, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin no later than 3 years from
the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: Drawing Numbers: 21-0007-10-001
rev P1; 21-0007-10-002 Rev P1; 21-0007-10-101 Rev P1; 21-0007-20-
001 Rev P1; 21-0007-20-002 Rev P2; and 21-0007-20-101 Rev P2.
3) No works shall commence until details and samples of all external facing
materials have been submitted to and approved in writing by the local
planning authority. The relevant works shall be carried out in accordance
with the details thereby approved.
4) No works shall commence until a sample panel of the external facing
masonry work has been provided on site and approved in writing by the
local planning authority. The sample panel shall show the proposed
walling materials, masonry block size, coursing structure, mortar mix and
pointing, written details of each of which shall also be submitted to and
approved in writing by the local planning authority before works
commence. All pointing shall be of a strength and style appropriate to the
type of walling materials used and shall not include ‘tuck’, ‘strap’ or
‘recessed’ pointing. The works shall be carried out in accordance with the
details and sample panel thereby approved. The approved sample panel
shall be retained on site for the duration of the works and shall not be
removed until the external walls of the extension hereby approved are
completed.
Appeal Decision APP/B3438/D/21/3285214
2
5) No works shall commence until detailed joinery plans and sections of the
proposed frame structure and glazing to all openings, at a scale of 1:5,
1:10 or 1:20 as appropriate, and details of the frame materials and
finishes to all openings have been submitted to and approved in writing
by the local planning authority. Those plans shall include details of the
side (north east) glazing, the two rear (north west) ground floor
windows, and the rooflights to the extension. The works shall be carried
out in accordance with the details thereby approved.
6) Notwithstanding the submitted development site shown by red edge in
drawing 21-0007-10-001 revision P1 ‘existing site and location plans’
nothing in this permission shall be taken as conferring consent for
residential use of any of the land which falls outside of the area granted
Certificate of Lawfulness of proposed use or development as permanent
private dwellinghouses with associated gardens and Parking under
reference SMD/2019/0033.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of
the existing dwelling and its surroundings.
Procedural Matter
3. As part of the appellants’ appeal submission, revised plans have been
submitted to show alterations to the design of the proposed extension. These
alterations propose the deletion of two windows on the rear elevation. In my
opinion, the amended plans are relatively minor and their submission does not
prejudice the Council. Consequently, I have taken these into account in
reaching my decision.
Reasons
4. The appeal property is two-storey dwelling, which was originally a barn
associated with Ringe Hay Farm. The dwelling is constructed of stone with a
plain tiled roof. The planning history shows that it was originally converted to
form holiday accommodation in 2008, but it is now a private dwelling. I note
that permitted development rights have been withdrawn. The building is part
of a group of former agricultural buildings that are located around an open yard
and close to the original farmhouse. Open countryside surrounds the site.
5. There is some discussion by both parties regarding the heritage significance of
the appeal property and the site in general, but it is common ground that the
buildings are not listed, nor are they within a conservation area. Nevertheless,
I agree with the Council that there can be some significance, even if buildings
are not designated heritage assets. In this case, there is some heritage
importance, due to age and location of the farmstead and the traditional
arrangement and scale of the buildings. I also note that it is recorded in the
Staffordshire Historic Farmstead Survey 2009 and in the Staffordshire Historic
Environment Record.
6. There is clearly some uncertainty over the extent of the original building that
was retained during the original conversion. However, the evidence before me
shows that the work (both internal and external), including some demolition
was significant. Notwithstanding, I accept that the building has retained an
Appeal Decision APP/B3438/D/21/3285214
3
agricultural character, although there are the inevitable domestic interventions,
particularly in terms of fenestration and door details.
7. The proposal is to construct a single storey extension at the rear of the
building. The proposal was amended during the application stage, which
reduced the size of the extension to the effect that it now covers approximately
60 – 65%% of the width of the dwelling, as opposed to the full width, as
originally submitted.
8. The extension would provide additional living area space and would also
facilitate internal alterations to the existing space in order to provide a ground-
floor accessible shower room and utility area. The applicants state that a
ground floor shower room is necessary for health reasons as accessing the
first-floor facilities is becoming increasingly difficult.
9. The Council refers to a number of Development Plan policies in its decision
notice. Policies DC1 and DC2 of the adopted Staffordshire Moorlands Local Plan
2020 (LP) state (amongst other things) that the design of new development
should be of high quality and should seek to preserve or enhance buildings or
features that contribute to the character or heritage of an area. Policy SS10
also requires development to have a positive effect, whilst Policy DC3 seeks to
ensure that development respects the local landscape. The Council also
references Policy H1, but this relates to new housing development.
Consequently, I am not persuaded that it is directly relevant to the proposal. I
consider these policies to be ‘up to date’ and in accordance with the National
Planning Policy Framework 2021 (The Framework), which contains similar
provisions.
10. In reaching my decision, I have also taken into account the advice contained in
the Council’s Supplementary Planning Document -Design Guide 2018 (SPD)
and in earlier Supplementary Planning Guidance – Design Principles (SPG).
The Council states that the latter is still relevant. I note that that the Council’s
guidance advocates that extensions should harmonise with the existing building
and that extensions to converted rural buildings are generally discouraged.
11. One of the Council’s reasons for refusal points to the absence of a supporting
Heritage Statement. However, the building is not a heritage asset and, in any
event, I consider that the appellants’ grounds of appeal and officer report are
sufficient to gain an understanding of the site’s significance and history.
12. The extension would appear as a relatively simple and subordinate addition to
the dwelling. It would match a similar extension that has been built on the
adjoining property. I accept that the adjoining extension was constructed
whilst that building was still in agricultural use, but nevertheless, I agree with
the appellant that many buildings change and adapt over time, irrespective of
their use.
13. It is a matter for debate as to how much of the original wall would be covered
or removed by constructing the extension. I also note that some of the
existing rear windows would be removed and detailing around the existing rear
door would be lost. However, taking the proposed extension on its individual
merits, I consider it to a sympathetic addition to the property in terms of its
scale, simple design and materials. Furthermore, it would not be readily visible
from public viewpoints and, therefore, it would not impact on the local
landscape.
Appeal Decision APP/B3438/D/21/3285214
4
14. Although the Council states that some of the reasons put forward by the
appellants regarding the need for the extension are desirable rather than
essential, I attribute weight to the appellants’ requirements, as the provision of
washing and wc facilities on the ground floor will improve their living conditions
within the dwelling.
15. As stated above, the appellants have submitted revised drawings, which amend
the rear elevation of the extension by deleting two windows. However, these
windows are relatively small and would provide an additional source of natural
light into, what is already, a relatively dark living space, notwithstanding the
proposed glazed door on the side elevation. I consider the windows to be
acceptable and, therefore, I have made my decision on the basis of the original
plans.
16. For the above reasons, the proposed extension would not have an adverse
effect on the character or appearance of the appeal property or on its
surroundings. Therefore, there is no conflict with the policies of the
Development Plan or with The Framework, as referred to above.
Conditions
17. The Council has suggested conditions in the event of the appeal being allowed.
In addition to the standard conditions relating to the time period for
commencement and the listing of approved plans, I have also imposed the
Council’s suggested conditions in respect of materials and the submission of
further details in respect of joinery. These are necessary to ensure a
satisfactory appearance and finish to the development.
18. The Council has also suggested a condition that effectively states that the
permission does not grant approval for a change of use of adjoining land, which
is shown within the red line on the submitted plans. For reasons of clarity and
the avoidance of doubt, I consider this to be reasonable and necessary.
Conclusion
19. For the reasons given above, it is concluded that the appeal be allowed.
Ian McHugh
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.