For carport, garage and home office outbuilding
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 23 November 2021
by K Stephens BSc (Hons) MTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 10th January 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/T3725/D/21/3284178
Pear Tree Cottage, 5 Vicarage Road, Stoneleigh CV8 3DH
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Beaumont against the decision of Warwick District
Council.
• The application Ref W/20/2116, dated 18 December 2020, was refused by notice dated
16 July 2021.
• The development proposed is for carport, garage and home office outbuilding.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issues
2. As the site is located within the West Midlands Green Belt, the main issues are:
• Whether the proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt
having regard to the National Planning Policy Framework (‘the Framework’)
and the development plan;
• The effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt;
• Whether the proposed development would preserve the setting of the appeal
property, Pear Tree Cottage, a Grade II listed building;
• Whether the proposed development would preserve or enhance the
character or appearance of the Stoneleigh Conservation Area (the ‘CA’);
• The effect of the proposal on the living conditions of existing occupiers of
Holly House with particular regard to privacy;
• Whether any harm by reason of inappropriateness, and any other harm,
would be clearly outweighed by other considerations which amount to very
special circumstances required to justify a grant of planning permission for
the proposed development.
Reasons
Whether the scheme is inappropriate development in the Green Belt
3. Paragraph 147 states that ‘inappropriate development’ in the Green Belt is, by
definition, harmful to the Green Belt and should not be approved except in very
special circumstances. The Framework regards the construction of new
Appeal Decision APP/T3725/D/21/3284178
2
buildings as inappropriate development in the Green Belt, subject to various
exceptions set out in paragraph 149.
4. Policy DS18 of the Warwick District Local Plan (the ’Local Plan’) seeks to protect
Green Belt from urban sprawl and inappropriate development unless the
development falls within the exceptions listed in the Framework. I am satisfied
that Local Plan Policy DS18 is broadly consistent with the Framework.
5. The proposal is for the erection of a detached outbuilding that would comprise
a single garage plus a single open-fronted carport. In the roof space there
would be a ‘home office’ accessed by an external wooden staircase. The
outbuilding would be sited towards the rear and side of Pear Tree Cottage, on
what is currently private garden laid to grass with sunken trampolines. The
outbuilding would be timber-framed and clad with feather-edge timber
boarding, with a reclaimed plain clay tile pitched roof.
6. The proposed development does not fall within any of the exceptions for new
buildings listed in 149a) to g). Nor does it fall within any of the other types of
exception development listed in paragraph 150. Accordingly, the appeal
development would constitute inappropriate development, as described in
paragraph 149 of the Framework and Local Plan Policy DS18.
Effect on the openness of the Green Belt
7. Paragraph 137 of the Framework identifies that the fundamental aim of
national Green Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by keeping land
permanently open. The essential characteristics of Green Belts are their
openness and their permanence.
8. Openness requires consideration of both spatial and visual aspects and
consideration of the impact or harm, if any, wrought by the change. Even
though the proposed building would be sited within the private garden of a
dwelling, which is located in a village with other dwellings nearby, the
principles of protection apply to all Green Belt land.
9. The outbuilding would be physically present as it would have a sizeable
footprint and occupy space on the ground that is previously free of built
development. It would also have volume due to its height, and hence would
introduce a structure with substantial bulk and massing in the rear garden
where there is currently none. I saw on my visit that the proposed building
would also be easily seen from both the public highway and a nearby public
footpath.
10. The proposed building would be a material addition to the amount of built
development on the site. This change would see a reduction in both the spatial
and visual openness of the Green Belt in this location and hence cause harm to
the Green Belt. This in turn would undermine the fundamental aim of keeping
land permanently open.
Effect on the listed building
11. Section 66(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act
1990 (the ‘LBCA Act’) requires that special regard is had to the desirability of
preserving a building or its setting.
Appeal Decision APP/T3725/D/21/3284178
3
12. According to Historic England’s official listing the appeal property is a timber
framed cottage, encased in red brick, with a steeply pitched roof with gabled
ends and brick chimney stacks. The three gabled attic dormers on the front
roof slope facing the road, and a small timber frame and painted brick wing at
the rear, are specifically mentioned in the listing. Due to its age and being an
example of local vernacular, Pear Tree Cottage has both architectural and
historic significance.
13. The property has a T-shaped form. The original cottage runs parallel to the
road and various extensions and outbuildings extend out at the rear, getting
progressively lower and more diminutive towards the rear of the plot. The
garden to the side provides the cottage with space, allowing the legibility of the
property to be read. The garden, the gap it creates and the progressively lower
buildings make an important contribution to the setting of the listed building.
14. The proposed outbuilding would occupy part of this space, even though the
outbuilding would be set back from the original cottage and roadside. Despite
the outbuilding being sunken into the sloping ground, the ridge of the roof
would be almost the same height as the dwelling and taller than some of the
rear extensions, as shown on the submitted plans. This would make the
outbuilding overly dominant and disrupt the diminutive progression and
relationship of the rear extension buildings.
15. The height and dominance of the outbuilding would be exacerbated by the two
large dormer windows in its front roof slope. These would give a domestic
appearance to the outbuilding, at odds with its proposed function as an
ancillary outbuilding. Furthermore, their presence and size would visually
compete with the historic dormer windows in the front roadside-facing roof
slope of the cottage. Due to its width and siting the outbuilding would also be
partially hidden behind the front elevation of the dwelling when viewed from
the road. This would reduce the space and gap to the side of the cottage,
effectively creating a terrace.
16. I find these factors would combine to diminish the significance of the cottage
and its surrounding space. Consequently the proposed development would
cause harm to the setting of the listed building and hence would not preserve
it.
Effect on the Conservation Area
17. The appeal property and site lie within the village of Stoneleigh and the
Stoneleigh CA. For buildings or other land in a conservation area Section 72(1)
of the LBCA Act requires that special attention is paid to the desirability of
preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of that area.
18. I have not been provided with a CA Appraisal, but I saw on my visit that the CA
comprised a substantial village with properties and roads emanating from the
central village green, with period properties of varying ages, styles and
designs, many of which were timber-framed or brick. I also saw that a number
of the older properties had been extended and some had more modern
garages. Nonetheless, the significance of the CA is derived from its age and
historic and architectural interest. The cottage is small-scale, but due to its
prominent roadside location it makes a positive contribution to the character
and appearance of the CA and the street scene.
Appeal Decision APP/T3725/D/21/3284178
4
19. The siting, size, height, materials and design, including the dormer windows,
would result in an overly large and visually dominant outbuilding that would
detract from the cottage’s quiet and small-scale nature in the street scene.
Furthermore, much of the side gable of the outbuilding would be highly visible
above the side boundary wall that runs along the private drive leading to Holly
House at the rear. It would also be very visible from the public footpath that
runs along the private drive, reinforcing the visual dominance the outbuilding
would have.
20. Whilst timber-clad outbuildings are not uncommon structures in general, it
would be an unsympathetic choice of materials in this location, where brick is
the predominate material.
21. I find that the proposed outbuilding would cause significant harm such that it
would not preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the CA
Weighing up any public benefits
22. There is no dispute between the parties that the harm caused to the Grade II
listed Pear Tree Cottage and the CA, which are both designated heritage
assets, would be less than substantial. In such circumstances paragraph 202 of
the Framework requires that the harm should be weighed against any public
benefits of the proposal.
23. The appellant has advanced a number of benefits of the proposed outbuilding.
It would provide a home office, a facility now more acutely needed during the
Covid-19 pandemic. By not needing to commute to work the appellants would
reduce their carbon footprint and hence the development would have
associated environmental benefits. They would also save money on transport
fuel. The proposed development would also provide the appellants with some
secure parking. Furthermore, the erection of a detached outbuilding would not
require works to the fabric of the listed building itself.
24. In accordance with paragraph 199 of the Framework I attach great weight to
the conservation of the designated heritage assets. Taking into account the
appellant’s matters, I find they do not amount to a public benefit, alone or in
combination, sufficient to outweigh the harm that would be caused to these
heritage assets. I therefore conclude that the significance of the heritage assets
has been diminished and that the proposed outbuilding would not preserve the
setting of the Grade II listed building and would neither preserve or enhance
the character or appearance of the CA.
25. Accordingly, the proposal would be contrary to Local Plan Policy HE1, which
requires, amongst other things, that where there would be less than substantial
harm to the significance of a designated asset that the harm is weighed against
the public benefits of the proposal.
Living Conditions
26. The proposed outbuilding would be sited in close proximity to the rear
boundary of the appeal site, which comprises a brick wall with shrubs and
vegetation planted in front of it. I saw that this currently helps provide mutual
screening for occupiers of the appeal property and Holly House, which sits to
the rear of the appeal site.
Appeal Decision APP/T3725/D/21/3284178
5
27. On my visit to Holly House I saw that windows serving habitable rooms at
ground floor (lounge and dining room) and at first floor level (two bedrooms)
face towards the rear boundary wall of the appeal site and hence would face
the rear of the proposed outbuilding with its rooflights and external staircase.
Due to the orientation of the Holly House, parts of its private garden and a
patio sitting area are located at the front of the property. The building would be
about 9.5 metres away from the neighbour’s first floor windows, which is less
than suggested distances in the Council’s Supplementary Planning Document
Residential Design Guide (the ‘Design SPD’).
28. Although the outbuilding would be sunken down, the difference in ground levels
would mean that users of the home-office and the external staircase would be
able to look towards the habitable rooms and down into the garden and patio
area of Holly House, although some views would be more oblique.
29. It was evident to me on my visit that the proposed outbuilding would have an
unneighbourly and intrusive effect by allowing overlooking of these habitable
rooms and part of the garden. As the stated purpose is as a home-office this
would indicate to me more frequent usage of the space and staircase than if
the roof space was a play room, guest room or storage for example.
Consequently, the proposal would result in a loss of privacy to an unacceptable
degree. Any loss of vegetation screening along this boundary would further
exacerbate overlooking and reduce privacy, and there would not be adequate
space between the building and the boundary wall for any meaningful
landscaping to survive and mature to offer any screening.
30. The appellants have suggested a condition could be imposed requiring the
rooflights to be obscure glazed, fixed shut or even removed completely. This
would overcome some of the overlooking issues. However, as I have found
harm to the Green Belt and the designated heritage assets, any mitigation of
overlooking from the rooflights that could be achieved is a neutral factor in my
consideration of the appeal proposal as a whole.
31. The appellants also suggest an obscure balustrade could be added to the
external staircase. I have no details of how this would be constructed, its size
or what it would look like to be able to judge its effectiveness. Moreover,
imposing a condition requiring details of any balustrading could make the
development substantially different from that proposed and would deny
interested parties the opportunity to comment. It may also introduce additional
bulk and massing to the building and further reduce openness of the Green
Belt. Therefore, such a condition would not overcome my concerns nor make
the scheme acceptable.
32. I therefore find the proposed development would harm the living conditions of
existing occupiers of Holly House to an unacceptable degree. Accordingly, the
development would be contrary to Local Plan Policy BE3, which does not permit
any development proposal that would have an unacceptable adverse impact on
the amenity, including privacy, of nearby residents. It would also be contrary to
the guidance in the ‘Design SPD’.
Other Matters
33. I acknowledge the appellants’ concerns about the Council’s handling of the
application, but in reaching my decision I have been concerned only with the
planning merits of the case.
Appeal Decision APP/T3725/D/21/3284178
6
34. The lack of representations from the occupiers of Holly House at the time does
not mean there is no unacceptable harm nor diminish the harm that I have
identified. As planning permission runs with the land I must determine the
proposal on its own planning merits.
Other Considerations and Green Belt Balance
35. The appeal development would represent inappropriate development in the
Green Belt which is, by definition, harmful. I have also found significant harm
to openness and conflict with one of the Green Belt purposes. Inappropriate
development should not be approved except in very special circumstances,
which will not exist unless the harm to the Green Belt, by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm is clearly outweighed by other
considerations.
36. Paragraph 148 of the Framework states that any harm caused to the Green
Belt must be given substantial weight. Following the statutory tests, great
weight must also be given to the harm that would be caused to the heritage
assets. In addition, there would be unacceptable harm caused to the living
conditions of existing occupiers of the neighbouring property. These are serious
planning objections.
37. On the other side of the balance, the appellants advance a number of other
considerations to support their appeal. I have already taken some of these into
account in paragraph 23 above. I find collectively they weigh only moderately
in favour of the proposal.
38. The Covid-19 pandemic and the various government restrictions has made
home-working a necessity at times for a significant proportion of the working
population. It is not uncommon or unreasonable for people to work from home
and need space to do so if there is no space within the dwelling. However,
there is limited evidence to demonstrate why the outbuilding has been
designed in the way it has, or that this is the only way to provide the proposed
accommodation. I note the appellants’ view that the Council’s suggestion to
extend the dwelling instead would be more harmful to the listed building.
However, such a scheme does not form part of the appeal before me. I
therefore give the need for home-working moderate weight. In my view, the
environmental benefits, laudable as they are, are not of significant magnitude
to overcome the harms I have identified.
39. I understand a previous scheme for a detached single garage was approved in
20061 in a similar location. The Council describes the differences in that the
approved garage building would have been smaller in scale and height and
would have been built from reclaimed brick. The garage would also have
maintained the gap between it and the rear of the dwelling. Neither party has
provided any plans of the previously approved garage. Nonetheless, the
previously approved garage does not represent a ‘fallback’ position because the
permission has lapsed and cannot be implemented lawfully.
40. The Council may well have allowed other outbuildings and garages in the
village or elsewhere in the Green Belt, and I saw a prominent garage opposite
the appeal property. However, I have not been provided with the details or
particular circumstances of these or indeed their legitimacy. Their existence
1 LPA ref: W/06/0184
Appeal Decision APP/T3725/D/21/3284178
7
does not set a precedent or justify allowing harmful development. I cannot
make any meaningful comparisons with the appeal scheme before me. In any
event as I must consider the appeal proposal on its own merits.
41. However, the fact that the previously approved smaller garage and other
outbuildings or extensions have been allowed in the Green Belt demonstrate to
me that the Council has found that development can be designed or located in
a way that does not cause harm to the Green Belt or designated heritage
assets.
42. Imposing conditions that the rooflights are removed, or are fitted with obscure
glazing, or fixed shut, and/or adding an obscure balustrade to the external
staircase may overcome some issues of overlooking. However, this would not
sufficiently mitigate against the harm I have found to the heritage assets or to
the Green Belt.
43. The appellants refer to being able to erect an outbuilding under ‘permitted
development’2. However, buildings erected within the curtilage of a listed
building would not be permitted development and would thus require planning
permission.
44. The appellants want secure parking. I give this only moderate weight as I have
not been provided with any substantive evidence of the necessity of this.
Furthermore, I saw that the garden area is accessible from the highway via
picket-style timber gates, such that the site is not without space for some
secure on-site parking behind some form of lockable gates.
45. To conclude, the appeal proposal would be inappropriate development in the
terms set out in the Framework and would lead to a harmful loss of openness
to the Green Belt. The proposal would also have a detrimental effect upon the
Grade II listed Pear Tree Cottage from development within its setting and
would not preserve or enhance the character or appearance of the CA. I find
the other considerations advanced by the appellants, taken alone or in
combination, do not clearly outweigh the totality of the harm to the Green Belt.
Consequently, the very special circumstances necessary to justify inappropriate
development in the Green Belt do not exist.
46. The proposal would therefore conflict with Local Plan Policies DS18, HE1 and
BE3, whose aims have already been outlined above, and the Framework.
Conclusion
47. The proposed development would not accord with the development plan and
there are no material considerations to outweigh this finding. For the reasons
given above, the appeal is dismissed.
K Stephens
INSPECTOR
2 Under the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015 (as amended)
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.