Development proposed is: “Demolish outbuildings, erect new extension for disabled relatives, form garage at street level and landscaping works
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Highways & Transport
Parking Provision
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 19 October 2021
by Nigel Harrison BA (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 02 November 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/J4423/D/21/3282217
117 Machon Bank, Sheffield, South Yorkshire, S7 1GS
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Nahim Khan against the decision of Sheffield City Council.
• The application Ref: 21/00480/FUL dated 29 October 2020, was refused by notice dated
23 August 2021.
• The development proposed is: “Demolish outbuildings, erect new extension for disabled
relatives, form garage at street level and landscaping works”.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed, and planning permission is granted for: “Demolish
outbuildings, erect new extension for disabled relatives, form garage at street
level and landscaping works” at 117 Machon Bank, Sheffield, South Yorkshire,
S7 1GS, in accordance with the terms of the application, Ref: 21/00480/FUL
dated 29 October 2020, subject to the following conditions:
1) The development hereby permitted shall begin no later than 3 years from
the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance
with the following approved plans: Drawing Nos: 20/09/07/011
(Proposed Foundations); 20/09/07/012 (Proposed Street Level Plan);
20/09/07/013 (Proposed Ground Floor Plan); 20/09/07/014 (Proposed
Roof Plan); 20/09/07/015 (East Elevation to Emily Road); 20/09/07/016
(Elevation to Patio, Long Section); 20/09/07/017 (North Elevations); and
20/09/07/018 (West Elevation).
3) The materials to be used in the construction of the external surfaces of
the development hereby permitted shall match those used in the existing
building.
Main Issue
2. The one main issue is the effect of the proposed development on highway
safety.
Reasons
3. The site comprises an end-of-terrace house with rear garden at the junction of
Machon Bank and Emily Road. It is proposed to erect a partly sunken garage
with doors in the boundary/retaining wall facing Emily Road. The proposal also
includes a single-storey extension projecting from the rear elevation of the
dwelling, and this would involve the demolition of an existing outbuilding.
Appeal Decision APP/J4423/D/21/3282217
2
4. I am satisfied that the extension would not materially harm the character and
appearance of the area and the living conditions of neighbours. It would accord
with saved Policies H14 and BE5 of the Sheffield Unitary Development Plan
(UDP), adopted 1998, Policy CS74 of the Sheffield Development Framework
Core Strategy (CS), adopted 2009, and the Council’s Supplementary Planning
Guidance on Designing House Extensions (SPG).
5. The Council’s sole concern relates to the garage element of the proposal,
saying the position of the garage doors immediately adjacent to the footway on
Emily Road is unacceptable in highway safety terms due to restricted visibility
for vehicles entering and leaving the garage, and the potential for conflict with
pedestrians and other highway users.
6. However, an important material consideration in this case derives from the
Council’s recent approval of a comparable garage proposal at No 119 Machon
Bank, directly opposite the appeal site (Ref: 20/03935/FUL). The garage doors
in that scheme would also directly front the footway on Emily Road. Whilst this
does not necessarily set a precedent, the two schemes are very similar in
terms of their highway safety implications, and this is accepted by the Council.
7. Significantly, the Planning Officer’s report for the approved application does not
incorporate a response from the Highway Officer and concludes that: ‘The
development does not adversely affect highway safety’. However, in response
to the appeal proposal the Highway Officer expressed strong highway safety
concerns which the Council says could not simply be ignored just because they
were not expressed or flagged up in connection with the approved scheme prior
to its determination.
8. Furthermore, and only in relation to the appeal proposal, the Council raised
concerns that the construction of the garage might compromise the structural
integrity of the highway and refers to the statutory obligation to ensure that
any necessary structural surveys and steps are taken before granting planning
permission which involves works within or adjacent to a highway. Whilst it
acknowledges that it may have been possible to secure a resolution to the
structural stability concerns via a planning condition, the Council says the
highway safety objections would remain and thus render the proposal
unacceptable in principle. However, highway structural issues fall to be dealt
with under other legislation and are not a valid material considerations to be
addressed in the determination of a planning application and appeal.
9. At my site visit I noticed very high levels of on-street parking in the area,
which hinders the free and safe movement of traffic along the streets. Due to
the high-density layout very few properties in the area have, or can provide,
off-street parking. In this context the appeal proposal would reduce the
pressure for on-street parking, albeit to a modest extent. This is a benefit
which I consider partly offsets the potential for pedestrian/vehicle conflict and
attracts significant weight in favour of the proposal.
10. I accept that pedestrian/vehicle intervisibility for vehicles entering or leaving
the garage would be less than ideal. However, on balance I consider this would
not be to a degree that would be materially harmful on highway safety. As
stated above, the Council’s decision to allow a comparable scheme in very close
proximity has also influenced my decision.
Appeal Decision APP/J4423/D/21/3282217
3
11. Overall, I favour a pragmatic approach and conclude that the proposal would
not materially harm highway safety. As such, I find no conflict with UDP Policy
H14 (d), which requires proposals to provide safe access to the highway
network and appropriate off-street parking, advice in the SPG, or Government
policy in paragraph 111 of the National Planning Policy Framework, (the
Framework) which says developments should only be refused on highway
grounds if there would be an unacceptable impact on highway safety.
Conclusion
12. Therefore, for the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be
allowed.
Conditions
13. I have considered the suggested conditions in the light of the advice in the
Framework and the Government’s Planning Practice Guidance (PPG). In
addition to the 3-year time limit for the commencement of development, a
condition is needed to secure compliance with the approved plans for the
avoidance of doubt and in the interests of proper planning. A condition
requiring matching materials is needed in the interests of the appearance of
the area.
14. The Council also suggests a condition be imposed requiring a ‘structural
approval in principle document’ (AIP) to be submitted and approved in relation
to safeguarding of the highway and to the temporary support required for the
public footpath and carriageway during excavation and construction. The
condition would require the AIP to be carried out in accordance with Highways
England Guidance CG300 Technical Approval of Highway Structures. Planning
conditions must satisfy all six tests set out in the Framework and the PPG. One
of the tests is that conditions must be relevant to planning and must not be
used to control matters that are subject to other (non-planning) legislation and
regulations. This condition fails this test and accordingly I shall not impose it.
Nigel Harrison
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.