Rear mansard dormer with roof lights on front slope
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Extensions
Heritage & Conservation
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 8 December 2021
by C Cresswell BSc (Hons) MA MBA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government
Decision date: 23 December 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/H5960/D/21/3278802
46 Eversleigh Road, London SW11 5XA
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by James Pigott against the decision of the Council of the London
Borough of Wandsworth.
• The application Ref 2020/5047, dated 23 December 2020, was refused by notice dated
4 May 2021.
• The development proposed is rear mansard dormer with roof lights on front slope.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
2. The main issue is whether the proposed development would preserve or
enhance the character or appearance of the Shaftesbury Park Estate
Conservation Area.
Reasons
3. The appeal concerns a terraced house which faces Eversleigh Road. It is within
the Shaftesbury Park Estate Conservation Area, the significance of which lies
mainly in the quality of the historic buildings in the vicinity, including the
terraces which line Eversleigh Road and the adjoining streets.
4. The terrace in which the appeal property is situated maintains a high degree of
visual consistency along the Eversleigh Road frontage. With a few exceptions,
most of the houses in this part of the street are of a broadly similar design and
appear to have retained most of their original features. A strong sense of
consistency is also displayed in adjoining streets, including Ashbury Road
immediately to the south. These attributes directly contribute to the quality of
the Conservation Area.
5. The proposed alterations to the front of the appeal property are relatively
minor and would have little effect on the appearance of the terrace as seen
from Eversleigh Road. However, the proposed mansard roof extension would
represent a more significant change as it would alter the shape of the roof.
Although this would be situated at the rear of the appeal property, it would
nonetheless be visible from some parts of Ashbury Road.
Appeal Decision APP/H5960/D/21/3278802
2
6. The rear elevation of the terrace has a somewhat less consistent appearance
than the front. I saw on my site visit that the appeal property has a first-floor
rear extension, while No 54 Eversleigh Road (further along the same terrace)
has both a first-floor rear extension and a mansard roof extension similar to
that being proposed in the current appeal. All of these features can be seen
from public vantage points in Ashbury Road, although views are confined to the
part of the street closest to the junction with Eversleigh Road.
7. Yet despite the presence of a skylight window, the rear roof slope of the appeal
property maintains its original form. When walking along Ashbury Road in a
westerly direction towards the Eversleigh Road junction, the roof of the appeal
property comes into view and can be seen alongside the unaltered roofs of the
adjoining properties on either side. Hence, seen from this part of the street,
the rear roof slope of the terrace appears to maintain a consistent appearance.
The mansard roof extension at No 54 Eversleigh Road does not come into view
until closer to the road junction and is most noticeable in views looking down
Ashbury Road in an easterly direction. In contrast, the rear roof slope of the
appeal property can be seen when approaching the site from both the east and
west and hence is in a somewhat more sensitive location.
8. Although the existing first-floor extensions at the rear of the appeal property
and No 54 Eversleigh Road are larger and bulkier structures than the proposed
mansard, they are lower in height and do not affect the consistency of the
roofline. By changing the shape of the roof and introducing glazing, the
mansard extension would disrupt the relatively consistent roofline in the part of
the terrace which the appeal property is situated. Even though the extension
would represent a comparatively small feature within the wider streetscape, it
would nonetheless erode the consistent appearance of the terrace thereby
undermining the significance of the Conservation Area.
9. I note that mansard extensions of the type being proposed are recommended
within the Housing SPD1. Indeed, I have been provided with examples of
similar roof extensions that have been approved elsewhere in the area.
However, in my view, the circumstances of those cases are not equivalent to
that of the proposal before me in this appeal. While mansard extensions may
be appropriate in some locations, they are not typical features of the street
scene in the immediate vicinity of the appeal property. In this particular case,
the proposed extension would appear inconsistent with the prevailing pattern of
development and so would not preserve the heritage asset in the manner
advocated by the Housing SPD and associated policies.
10. My attention has also been drawn to an Appeal Decision2 where a proposal for
a mansard roof extension at No 22 Eversleigh Road was dismissed on the basis
that it would disrupt the unbroken roof slope of the terrace. I was able to view
this property myself and note that no other mansard roof extensions are visible
from the rear (unlike in the current appeal where the roof extension at No 54
can be seen from Ashbury Road). However, for the reasons given above, the
roof extension being proposed in the current appeal would also have a
disruptive effect on the traditional appearance of the rear roof slope, despite
the presence of the existing mansard nearby.
1 Wandsworth Local Plan Housing Supplementary Planning Document, Adopted November 2016.
2 Appeal Decision: APP/H5960/D/18/3195310
Appeal Decision APP/H5960/D/21/3278802
3
11. In reaching this decision, I am mindful that paragraph 199 of the Framework3
says that ‘great weight’ should be assigned to the protection of heritage assets.
However, the harm would be less than substantial and in such circumstances
the Framework advises that this harm should be weighed against any public
benefits associated with the development. Although I do sympathise with the
appellant’s desire to improve the property, the benefits would be entirely
private in nature. Hence the harm would not be outweighed in this case.
12. I therefore conclude that the proposed development would not preserve or
enhance the character or appearance of the Shaftesbury Park Estate
Conservation Area. It would conflict with Policies DMS1, DMS2 and DMH5 of
the Wandsworth Development Management Policies4. Together, these policies
promote appropriate standards of design and the protection of heritage assets.
The appeal is therefore dismissed.
C Cresswell
INSPECTOR
3 National Planning Policy Framework, July 2021
4 Wandsworth Local Plan Development Management Policies Document Adopted March 2016
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.