Erection of a timber skate board half pipe ramp
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Noise & Disturbance
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 28 February 2022
by Robin Buchanan BA (Hons) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 8th March 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/G3110/D/21/3278013
47 White Road, Oxford OX4 2JJ
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr S Ledward against the decision of Oxford City Council.
• The application Ref 21/00380/FUL, dated 9 February 2021, was refused by notice dated
8 April 2021.
• The development proposed is the erection of a timber skate board half pipe ramp.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. The development has already been carried out.
Main Issues
3. The main issues in this case are the effect of the development on the living
conditions of the occupiers of neighbouring dwellings, with particular regard to
privacy and noise, and its effect on the character and appearance of the area.
Reasons
Living Conditions
4. The skate board ramp is situated almost at the end of the long rear garden of
the appeal property, which is a two-storey house in a row of similar houses and
gardens in White Road. The ramp is 10.9m long, 6.1m wide and has two
opposing curved slopes, separated by an intervening flat surface, with
platforms either end 2.1m above ground level. A safety rail 1.1m high runs
around the outside edge of the platforms.
5. The occupiers of some houses in White Road may be able to see a skater from
rear windows or the upper ends of their rear gardens. However, even at its
closest point the ramp is sufficiently distant (approximately 35m) that from the
platforms it is not possible to discern activity in these rooms or these more
private parts of gardens. There is also, therefore, no reasonable prospect of
any unacceptable perception of being overlooked in these regards.
6. A thick belt of evergreen laurel hedge (about 4m high and 3m deep) behind the
ramp means that there is no view from the platforms of windows or the rear
garden of the house to the rear at No 92 Normandy Crescent. A line of tall
conifer trees and shrubs along the boundary with No 49 White Road restricts
views from the ramp and platforms towards most of this rear garden and
Appeal Decision APP/G3110/D/21/3278013
2
gardens next to it. However, there is a gap in this planting beside the ramp.
While some views in this direction are restricted by large outbuildings and
planting in some gardens, or distance, there is direct overlooking of the lower
end of the garden of No 49, which currently has a low boundary fence.
7. In the other direction, there are extensive and largely uninterrupted views from
the platforms over the lower ends of the rear gardens of a number of houses in
White Road. Some, in particular the closest at No 45 and No 43, contain
domestic outbuildings (eg garden rooms) or outdoor living or entertaining
space (eg decked areas) or well-used or equipped garden play space. These
more distant parts of these long gardens are ordinarily where there is a
reasonable expectation of enhanced privacy and tranquillity.
8. I appreciate that a skater in motion would appear to a neighbour as a fleeting
presence and likely be mainly focussed on the task in hand, rather than what is
going on around them. Nevertheless, the ramp fills nearly all the width of the
garden and a skater would clearly be noticed in close proximity and cause a
tangible perception of being overlooked. Moreover, a skater standing or sitting
stationary on the platforms, between ‘rides’ or at rest, and especially when the
appellant has friends present who could not all skate at once, would inevitably
lead to actual overlooking, intended or not.
9. The unusually high and unexpected vantage point for skaters would be
significantly more intrusive than views from most children’s climbing frames
and camouflage side netting would not, by virtue of its open weave
construction, prevent views towards these gardens. Moreover, at 1.5m high,
netting would not affect standing views from the ramp or, if erected higher up,
from the platforms. Any existing or proposed garden boundary fence would
have to be taken to a height of about 4m to have any meaningful screening
effect. Both measures would, in my view, therefore, be somewhat contrived
and indicative of the fundamentally inappropriate positioning and height of the
ramp and platforms in relation to these parts of gardens in White Road.
10. I accept that children playing in gardens (and similar noise at the nearby
primary school) or other normal domestic activity, such as mowing the lawn or
barbeques, is likely to result in some noise and will vary depending on the
activity. However, none of the typical activities will result in such a distinctive
and persistent noise due to the roll and resonance of skateboard wheels on the
timber surface of the ramp and ‘thuds’ at an elevated height, including as
skaters land on the platforms. This would occur even if the ramp was used only
for a 2 hour duration, twice a week, including at times of the day and year
when gardens are most likely to be in active use.
11. I have no reason to doubt that the skateboard activity can be heard at some
more distant houses nearby, as I note some local residents have suggested.
However, and in the absence of any objective evidence such as a noise survey
or assessment, I consider that it is likely to overly disturb use of the closest
gardens at Nos 43 to 51 White Road (excepting the appeal site) and No 92
Normandy Crescent. I note that consideration has been given to applying an
insulation material to the ramp to try and alleviate noise. However, there are
no details of this before me or any acoustic report to confirm that it would have
a certain and meaningful effect. Even if it did, it would not outweigh or
overcome the adverse impact of overlooking.
Appeal Decision APP/G3110/D/21/3278013
3
12. I acknowledge that there will often be a degree of mutual overlooking and
disturbance due to noise in an urban situation. I also appreciate that the
appellant has located the ramp furthest from nearby houses in White Road, at
the end of these long gardens, and does not use it during hours of darkness.
However, the siting of the ramp is nonetheless extremely close to parts of
neighbouring gardens which could be well-used during daytime or early
evening. The position and height of the ramp, and particularly the platforms,
significantly compromise and unduly undermine normal expectations for
enjoyment of gardens and domestic activity by existing or future occupiers of
the neighbouring houses at Nos 43, 45, 49 and 51 White Road and No 92
Normandy Crescent. Even if a condition to remove the ramp upon the appellant
ceasing to own the appeal property met the requisite tests1, it would not
alleviate unacceptable adverse impact meantime.
13. Taking all of the above into account, I find that the development significantly
harms the living conditions of the occupiers of these neighbouring dwellings,
with particular regard to privacy and noise. It is contrary to the Council’s
Local Plan2 (the LP) Policy H14 which seeks to ensure reasonable privacy for
occupants of existing homes, including with regard to overlooking. It also
conflicts with the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) which
aims to achieve a high standard of amenity for existing occupiers and avoid
noise giving rise to significant adverse impacts on the quality of life.
Character and Appearance
14. Observed close up, from within the lower end of the garden at the appeal
property, the ramp is a large structure in footprint dimensions and is
substantial in extent and construction. However, it does not take up a large
proportion of the garden and a significant part is low down close to the ground,
behind existing boundary fences. Only a small, narrow ‘solid’ side part and top
edge of the slopes at either end project above existing, or the maximum height
of new3, boundary garden fences. These parts are broadly comparable in height
to a typical eaves level of a domestic outbuilding. The safety rails protrude
further upward but are comparable in height to a pitched roof outbuilding and
are not solid structures.
15. The upper parts of the ramp, platforms and safety rails are also screened in
views from some lower ends of neighbouring gardens by trees, hedgerow or
shrubs. The ramp has been mostly painted dark green and has camouflage
netting facing up the garden towards the appeal property such that in
conjunction with intervening planting it is largely out of sight.
16. Overall, the ramp is an unusual and in some closer views from neighbouring
gardens, in part, a noticeable structure. However, it is not an overly ‘intrusive’
feature in the appellant’s rear garden taken as a whole, nor in the context of
the openness of neighbouring gardens, the extent and direction of views
available to people in those gardens and the siting, size and form of some
other nearby outbuildings and planting. It does not, therefore, ‘dominate’
private residential visual amenity and there is no public view of any part of the
ramp.
1 Framework paragraph 56 and Planning Practice Guidance paragraph 21a-003-20190723
2 Oxford Local Plan, adopted June 2020
3 If erected as permitted development (The Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development)
(England) Order 2015, as amended).
Appeal Decision APP/G3110/D/21/3278013
4
17. Considering the above, I find that the development does not harm the
character or appearance of the area. It does not conflict with LP Policy DH1
which seeks high quality design. It would also accord with the Framework in
that it would function well and be sympathetic to local character, including the
surrounding built environment and landscape setting.
Other Matters
18. It has been suggested by some local residents that the ramp may be available
for public use, including by children. That is not part of the proposal before me,
which is for personal use as a hobby. In this respect, I have no reason to doubt
the sincerity of the appellant and I sympathise with his aspirations. I also
appreciate that a number of local residents have expressed support for the
ramp and I recognise that it facilitates health and well-being and that
skateboarding is a recognised sport.
19. Notwithstanding the above, some local residents have objected. I also consider
that these benefits could be achieved by using more appropriately located
facilities elsewhere. I appreciate that this would be less convenient for the
appellant but the planning system operates in the wider public interest, not in
any individual private interest. I have, in any event, considered the
development and the appeal on its individual planning merits.
Conclusion
20. Notwithstanding my findings on the character and appearance of the area, the
proposal would cause significant harm to living conditions and as a result would
not accord with the development plan overall. There are no other material
considerations, including the provisions of the Framework, which outweigh this
finding.
21. Therefore, for the reasons given above I conclude that the appeal should not
succeed.
Robin Buchanan
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.