Demolition of existing garage and storage buildings, and the construction of a new detached garage building
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Character & Appearance
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 25 October 2021
by J D Westbrook BSc(Hons) MSc MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 03 November 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/J3720/D/21/3277962
Trevose Cottage, Bottom Street, Northend, SOUTHAM, CV47 2TH
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Alex Attley against the decision of Stratford-on-Avon District
Council.
• The application Ref 21/00595/FUL, dated 21 February 2021, was refused by notice
dated 28 April 2021.
• The development proposed is described as the demolition of existing garage and
storage buildings, and the construction of a new detached garage building.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Main Issue
• The main issue in this case is the effect of the proposed extension on the
character and appearance of the area around Bottom Street in Northend.
Reasons
2. Trevose Cottage is a detached house situated on the western side of
Bottom Street, close to The Green in the village of Northend. It is a wide-
fronted brick house with a two-storey rear extension and a high single-
storey extension at its southern end. The main body of the house is set a
short distance back from the front boundary, and the southern extension
abuts the rear of the pavement. There is a detached garage/outbuilding
further south in the plot, which is in a poor state of repair, and a
greenhouse and outbuilding at the southern end of the garden. The south-
eastern boundary consists of a 1.8 metre high wooden fence.
3. The existing garage would be demolished as part of the development and
the proposed new garage and store building would be set back 6 metres
from the front boundary of the property at the southern end of the plot.
The proposed building would be some 11 metres long by 6.3 metres wide.
It would have an ironstone gable wall to the eastern elevation and timber
walls to the south and west. It would include an open-fronted double
garage and storeroom on the ground floor, with a small log store attached,
and stairs to a first-floor room providing an office/workspace with wc. The
building would have a high-pitched roof with two flat-roofed dormer
windows in the north roof slope.
Appeal Decision APP/J3720/D/21/3277962
2
4. The Council contends that the proposed garage, by reason of its size, scale
and design would introduce a large, prominent and domesticized building
that would compete with the main dwelling-house. The proposal would
therefore harm the character and appearance of the host dwelling and
visually detract from the amenities of the wider street scene.
5. The appellant contends that the design and appearance of the garage are
appropriate with regards to the provisions of the relevant local policies and
guidance, and that the garage would not be of a scale that would compete
with the dwelling and is subservient to the dwelling in both floor area and
height. In addition, the building would be set down some 0.6 metres below
the level of the pavement and would not be readily visible in the street
scene. Finally, the appellant notes the existence of other garages and
outbuildings in the vicinity that are positioned at or close to the front
boundary of their respective plots.
6. Policy CS9 of the Council’s Core Strategy (CS) indicates that proposals,
including layout and orientation, should be sensitive to the setting, existing
built form, neighbouring uses, and topography of the site and locality.
Proposals should reflect the context of the locality, ensuring a continuity of
key design features that establishes the identity of the place, not harming
existing public views. Policy CS20 of the CS indicates that proposed
outbuildings should be of an appropriate scale, and subservient in relation
to the existing building, taking into account the site location and the
cumulative impacts of previous extensions and development on the site
where appropriate. Part E of the Council’s Development Requirements SPD
indicates that flat roofed dormers with cornice moulding may be acceptable
on buildings in a Classical idiom.
7. The appeal site slopes down gently from east to west, and also from south
to north, such that the proposed building would be set with a base level
approximately the same as the southern extension of the house and a little
above the base level of the main house. The proposal would result in a
large, effectively two-storey building sited some 12 metres from the house
and a similar distance from ‘The Bungalow’, the adjacent property to the
south. It would have an overall height of around 5.9 metres to roof ridge.
On this basis, it would appear higher than the southern extension to the
house and only a little lower than the ridge of the house itself.
8. By virtue of the forward projection of the southern extension to the house,
the proposed new building would not be readily visible in the street scene
when approaching from the north. However, it would be a prominent
feature when viewed from the front of the site and when approaching from
the south. Although it would be sited 6 metres back from the front
boundary, because of its height and relatively open position, it would be
clearly visible above the front boundary fence and would have the
appearance of a more dominant structure than the bungalow to the south.
Moreover, its overall scale, while smaller than the existing house, would be
large enough, and the building high enough, to result in it appearing as a
significant feature on the plot that would compete with the main house.
9. I note the existence of a large garage building at Blencow Brow, the
dwelling opposite, but in this case, by virtue of its design and lower overall
height, it is less prominent and is of significantly lower height in relation to
Appeal Decision APP/J3720/D/21/3277962
3
the dwelling behind it. Similarly, other garages and outbuildings visible
along Bottom Street and close to the rear of the pavement, are much lower
in height than that currently proposed for Trevose Cottage and are
generally better integrated into the street scene by way of boundary
planting and tree screening in the immediate vicinity.
10. Finally, I consider the use of flat-topped dormer windows in the north roof
slope to be an alien and unsatisfactory feature within the general
surrounding area, where such dormers characteristically have a gable
fronted design with a small pitched roof above the window.
11. I accept the view of the council that the overall materials used for the
proposed building are appropriate to the area. However, in view of its large
scale and siting within the context of the host property and its immediate
surroundings, it would result in a somewhat over-dominant visual impact,
accentuating the cumulative impacts of previous extensions and
development on the original house. This would result in the building having
a harmful effect on the character and appearance of both the host property
in its context and also on the wider street scene.
12. On this issue, therefore, and in the light of the above, I find that the
proposed extension would be harmful to the character and appearance of
Bottom Street in this part of Northend. It would, on this basis, conflict with
policies CS9 and CS20 of the CS, and with guidance in the SPD.
Conclusion
13. I find that the proposed extension would be harmful to the character and
appearance of the area around Bottom Street. Accordingly, I dismiss this
appeal.
J D Westbrook
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.