Kitchen/bathroom and bedroom extension only
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 15 February 2022
by K Savage BA(Hons) MPlan MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 07 March 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/W2465/D/21/3277818
5 Granby Avenue, Leicester LE5 3RB
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Arif Mohamed Sadik Boodi against the decision of Leicester
City Council.
• The application Ref 20211046, dated 24 April 2021, was refused by notice dated
24 June 2021.
• The development proposed was originally described as ‘kitchen/bathroom and bedroom
extension only’.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matter
2. The original description of development set out above is somewhat vague.
Thus, I have based my consideration on the Council’s description on its decision
notice of ‘construction of part two-storey and part single storey extension at
rear/side of house (Class C3)’, which more fully describes the proposal.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are:
i) the effect of the proposal on the character and appearance of the area;
ii) the effect of the proposal on the living conditions of neighbouring
occupants, with respect to light and outlook, and
iii) whether the proposal would provide adequate external space for
occupants.
Reasons
Character and appearance
4. The appeal dwelling addresses Granby Avenue but is physically the end
dwelling of the terrace to the north on Baggrave Street. The dwelling has an
existing two storey rear outrigger which matches the height and depth of those
along the terrace. The dwelling has a shallow single storey addition beyond the
outrigger and a detached outbuilding at the rear of the site.
5. The proposal would see the rear outbuilding enlarged to meet the existing
extension, subsuming the single storey element at the rear of the outrigger in
the process and adding a shallow pitched roof. Above this, at first floor level,
the outrigger would be extended rearward by 2.38 metres.
Appeal Decision APP/W2465/D/21/3277818
2
6. Full depth ground floor additions are common to the terrace, and in terms of
site coverage, this element of the proposal would not be uncharacteristic of the
surroundings. The shape of the pitched roof would be a departure from the roof
forms of adjacent extensions, but this would not be discernible from the street
as the neighbouring extensions would be screened from view. Given the
extension would address the street, some variation in design and orientation is
to be expected. Having regard to the immediate street scene, which features a
number of different sizes and forms of roofs and openings to buildings, I am
content that the proposed roof, door and window would not appear as
uncharacteristic or disruptive features.
7. However, the extended outrigger to the first floor would add significant bulk at
high level. It would clearly disrupt the consistent building line at this height
along the Baggrave Street terrace, and would obscure views along the rear of
the terrace from Granby Avenue. It would appear excessive in scale by
comparison with its neighbours and so would harm the character and
appearance of the area.
8. I note that the corresponding building on the opposite side of Granby Avenue
has extended at the first floor level. However, this appears to be shallower in
depth than that proposed, and forms part of a separate group of dwellings. Any
symmetry to be gained within the street scene from the proposal extending at
first floor level would be limited and would not offset the loss of consistency to
the rear building line of the terrace of which the appeal dwelling forms part.
9. For these reasons, I conclude that the proposal would significantly harm the
character and appearance of the area, contrary to Policy CS03 of the Core
Strategy (July 2014) (the CS) and saved Policy PS10 of the City of Leicester
Local Plan (January 2006) (the LP), which require high quality, well designed
developments that contribute positively to the character and appearance of the
local natural and built environment, and set out that the visual quality of the
area, and its ability to assimilate development, are factors to be considered in
determining planning applications. The proposal would also conflict with the
aims of the National Planning Policy Framework to secure high quality design in
all developments.
Neighbours’ living conditions
10. The proposed first floor extension would have a significant enclosing effect on
the rear courtyard of the adjacent dwelling at 9 Baggrave Street. At present,
the gap between the rear outrigger and the side wall of 7 Granby Avenue
provides a valuable source of sunlight and daylight through to the rear of the
terrace from the south.
11. The proposal would narrow this gap considerably, with No 9 most affected as
the adjacent dwelling. The extension would stand immediately above the
ground floor windows, severely restricting outlook from them and reducing
sunlight and daylight to them. Outlook from the rear first floor window is
already limited to some extent by the existing extension at the appeal dwelling,
but there is still a sense of light and openness beyond it due to the existing gap
to No 7. The narrowing of this gap would significantly diminish the extent and
quality of light reaching the rear first floor window, and would further reduce
the outlook to a narrow tunnel view rearward.
Appeal Decision APP/W2465/D/21/3277818
3
12. For these reasons, I conclude that the proposal would cause significant harm to
the living conditions of neighbouring occupants, by reason of increased sense
of enclosure, loss of outlook, sunlight and daylight. This would conflict with
Policy PS10 of the CS, which requires that the amenity of existing or proposed
residents is considered in determining planning applications, having regard to
factors including light and overshadowing.
Private external space
13. The Council argues that the proposal would contravene the requirements of its
Residential Amenity Supplementary Planning Document by providing less than
the recommended 75sqm of private external space and covering more than
50% of the original yard area.
14. I recognise the benefits for occupants in having suitable private space for
relaxation, play, exercise and other activities. However, I saw that the existing
property has only an narrow L-shaped path that extends along the side of the
rear outrigger and turns between the outrigger and the outbuilding. I saw it
was being used to dry clothes but, apart from this, it is not a suitable size or
shape for any meaningful activity, even sitting out. As such, the site already
falls well short of the SPD thresholds, and has no prospect of achieving them,
short of removing the existing outbuilding altogether, which is unrealistic.
15. Given the existing site circumstances, I find that the further reduction in
private amenity space would not make a material difference to the standard of
accommodation for occupants of the dwelling, and no conflict would arise with
Saved Policy PS10 of the LP in terms of its requirement that proposals have
regard to the amenity of existing or proposed residents.
16. The Council refers to Policy PS10 in its officer report, but cites conflict with
Policy CS03 in its reason for refusal. This may be in error, as PS10 appears to
me to be the most relevant policy. Nonetheless, I find no conflict with Policy
CS03 either, having regard to its more general aims to create buildings and
spaces that are fit for purpose yet are innovative, adaptable and flexible.
Conclusion
17. For the reasons set out, the proposal would conflict with the development plan,
taken as a whole. The proposal would provide extended living space for the
present occupants, but this would be a private benefit, rather than a public
one, and a modest one at that. Any economic benefits for the local construction
trade in implementing the development would also be modest in scale. None of
these considerations would justify making a decision other than in accordance
with the development plan.
18. Therefore, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
K Savage
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.