Demolition of an existing single storey side extension and the erection of a two storey side extension
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Rural Impact
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 17 August 2021
by Darren Hendley BA(Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 31st August 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/E2734/D/21/3277064
Walton Head Farm, Princess Royal Way, Pannal HG3 1LF
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Murray against the decision of Harrogate Borough Council.
• The application Ref: 21/01233/FUL, dated 23 March 2021, was refused by notice dated
13 May 2021.
• The development proposed is the demolition of an existing single storey side extension
and the erection of a two storey side extension.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The revised National Planning Policy Framework (Framework) was published
during the course of the appeal. The national planning policy it provides in
relation to the Green Belt has not changed, as is relevant to this appeal.
Accordingly, I have considered the appeal on this basis.
Main Issues
3. The main issues are a) whether the proposal would constitute inappropriate
development in the Green Belt for the purposes of the Framework and the
development plan policy, b) its effect on the openness of the Green Belt, and c)
if it is inappropriate development, whether the harm by reason of
inappropriateness and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances necessary to
justify the development.
Reasons
4. The appeal property comprises a 2 storey house. On the side where the
proposal would be sited, there is already an existing 2 storey extension, as well
as the single storey extension that would be demolished to make way for the
proposal. There is also an adjacent patio area. On the opposite side, there is a
further 2 storey extension. A detached garage also lies on this side of the
property.
5. The property is one of 3 dwellings that are positioned around a courtyard. It is
understood that it was formerly a complex of farm buildings. It is well set back
from the A61, from where access is taken to these properties via a shared
Appeal Decision APP/E2734/D/21/3277064
2
driveway. Otherwise, the immediate surroundings to the appeal site are
countryside in nature. The site lies in the Green Belt.
Inappropriate Development
6. Paragraph 149 of the Framework states that the construction of new buildings
is inappropriate in the Green Belt unless, amongst other exceptions, it involves
the extension or alteration of a building provided that it does not result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
7. Policy GS4 of the Council’s Harrogate District Local Plan 2014 – 2035 (2020)
reaffirms the extent of the Green Belt as shown on the policies map and states
that proposals for development in the Green Belt will be determined in
accordance with relevant national policy.
8. Neither the Framework nor Policy GS4 provide guidance over whether a
proposal would constitute a disproportionate addition. The Council’s House
Extensions & Garages Design Guide Supplementary Planning Document (2005)
refers to extensions up to a 50% ground floor area increase. However, the
Framework refers to ‘size’. I have also been referred to a 30% volume limit
with regard to other appeal decisions, but this does not appear in policy or
guidance. The application of these percentage figures carries limited weight in
my decision.
9. The Framework defines an original building “as a building as it existed on 1 July
1948 or, if constructed after 1 July 1948, as it was built originally.” Based on
the evidence before me, I find the original building constitutes the house
without the extensions that I have described above. With regard to the
garage, there is broad agreement between the main parties that it should not
be included in an assessment of inappropriate development as it is located a
fair distance away. I see no reason to disagree.
10. The appeal property has clearly already been considerably extended from what
would have been the original building with the existing 2 storey extensions, in
particular. The proposal would further add to this not insignificant level of
existing extensions by increasing the 2 storey elements of the property. The
first floor would in part be more open to create a terrace, but this would still be
elevated and the remaining 2 storey part would be fully enclosed.
11. The proposal falls to be considered with the existing extensions because the
Framework requires an assessment against the original building, not the
extended building. The cumulative enlargement would be significant. Hence,
that the proposal would not on its own add markedly to what is already a fairly
large sized property is not decisive.
12. The appellant has pointed to that the cumulative extensions would be under
the 50% ground floor area increase under the SPD. However, this
demonstrates the shortcomings of the SPD approach because it does not take
account of the volume and all external dimensions. I have considered the
matter of inappropriate development on this basis, which is consistent with the
Hoveringham appeal decision1 that I have been referred to where the Inspector
considered the scale, bulk, massing and built form. Comparisons with the
proposal that was the subject of that decision itself and other appeal decisions
1 Appeal Ref: APP/B3030/D/19/3241277
Appeal Decision APP/E2734/D/21/3277064
3
that I have been referred to do not greatly inform my deliberations as the
proposal is to be dealt with on its own merits.
13. In these terms, assessing proportionality with regard to the policy which the
Framework sets out is principally a test based on size. Compared to what I
consider would have been the size of the original building, the proposal would
constitute a disproportionate addition when considered with the existing 2
storey extensions. Hence, it would not comply with this exception. No other
exceptions in the Framework would apply.
14. I conclude that the proposal would constitute inappropriate development within
the Green Belt, and so it would not comply with paragraph 149 of the
Framework. For similar reasons, it would not comply with Policy GS4.
Openness
15. Under the Framework, openness is an essential characteristic of the Green Belt.
In relation to the spatial dimension, it would alter the area of land on which it
would be sited in that it would increase the amount of built form. As it would
relate closely to the existing house, and would include part of the patio area
where there is already domestic paraphernalia, this effect would be slight. This
includes with regard to the amount of land that would be enclosed.
16. In visual terms, the proposal would be well screened by the existing house, and
vegetation and landform in the vicinity of the site, or else seen against the
larger backdrop of the existing house.
17. In considering the impact on the openness of the Green Belt wrought by the
change, the effect would be modest and I am not persuaded that it can be
considered adverse. As such, the openness of the Green Belt would be
preserved.
Other Considerations
18. It is not in dispute between the main parties that the proposal would not be
unacceptable with regard to the effect on the character and appearance of the
building and the area. The fairly modest nature of the alterations would
respect the form of the existing building and sit comfortably within this former
farm complex, as well as within the immediate countryside surroundings. The
lack of harm in respect of character and appearance attracts neutral weight.
Conclusion
19. The proposal would be inappropriate development in the Green Belt.
Paragraph 148 of the Framework establishes that substantial weight should be
given to any harm to the Green Belt. Other considerations which arise do not
clearly outweigh the harm. Consequently, very special circumstances do not
exist. Accordingly, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Darren Hendley
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.