None
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Character & Appearance
Heritage & Conservation
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 30 November 2021
by Jonathon Parsons MSc BSc(Hons) DipTP Cert(Urb) MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 22 December 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/A1910/D/21/3276969
Cloverleaf, Chapel Croft, Chipperfield WD4 9DR
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr and Mrs Gillespie against the decision of Dacorum Borough
Council.
• The application Ref 21/00506/FHA, dated 5 February 2021, was refused by notice dated
6 April 2021.
• The development proposed is an annex.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. The application description for the proposal refers to an annex. The proposal
involves the alteration and extension of an existing summerhouse/garage
building to incorporate a swimming pool and hot tub. Above the ground floor
extension, there would be a mezzanine floor and a first floor gym within a
pitched roof with rooflights and end gables.
Main Issues
3. The site is within the Green Belt and so the main issues are:
• whether the proposal would be inappropriate development for the
purposes of the National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework)
and the Development Plan;
• the openness of the Green Belt;
• character and appearance; and
• if the proposal is inappropriate development, whether harm by reason of
inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify it.
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/21/3276969
2
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
4. The appeal site comprises a substantial detached dwelling in a large plot, with
outbuildings, including garages and summerhouse. The dwelling has planning
permissions for two storey side and single storey rear extensions. The
Framework establishes that new buildings or development are inappropriate
development unless they fall within listed exceptions. One such exception is
the extension or alteration of a building provided that it does not result in
disproportionate additions over and above the size of the original building.
Amongst other matters, Policy CS5 of the Council’s Core Strategy (CS) 2013
sets out that limited extensions to existing buildings will be permitted in the
Green Belt.
5. The use of the word ‘limited’ within the CS policy is different to that of
“disproportionate” used in Framework. There is no planning guidance or
definition of the words but limited would indicate a smaller permissible
quantum of development than disproportionate. This would indicate an
inconsistency between the Framework and local policy.
6. The proposal would result in additional floor space of approximately 117sqm.
Saved Policy 22 of the Local Plan (2004) requires an assessment based on the
increase in floor area but judging proportionality on a single factor would be
misleading. In this regard, the proposal would also result in the summerhouse
being increased in height through the addition of a pitched roof with first floor
accommodation within it. The roof’s height would be approximately 0.5m
above that of the garage and at approximately 6m in height, it would be more
than double the height of that of the summerhouse.
7. The width of the extension would stretch across a significant part of the
summerhouse/garage building. The depth of the extension would be greater
than that of the host building as well. The altered and extended building would
enclose a significant sized swimming pool and hot tub area, and a first floor
gym. On this basis, there would be a significant increase in the size, scale and
bulk of the building which would be disproportionate.
8. In 2019, an Inspector allowed a proposal for a two storey extension to a
dwelling in Seale. While the cumulative additions would be sizeable, the
Inspector concluded that there was nothing substantive to indicate that the
proposal would overall be disproportionate. However, this decision indicates
that proportionality is not solely limited to floor space/volume increases and a
proposal has to be judged as a whole, taking into account different factors, and
their particular planning circumstances, as has been done above.
9. Under the Framework, another exception is limited infilling in villages and
similarly, there is no definition of this exception. The site is within the village
because it is part of a group of dwellings along Chapel Croft, a significantly
developed road, and close to facilities, including a local shop, despite being
outside of its development boundary. In my opinion, infilling would comprise
the filling in of space by built development between buildings within a planning
context. The proposal would involve an extension to an existing
summerhouse/garage which is next to a dwelling. However, the proposal
would involve significant extension and alteration of this building. In this
regard, there would be a new room incorporating the swimming pool, and plant
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/21/3276969
3
room within both the extended and existing part of the building. As such, the
new development comprises the extended and altered summerhouse/garage
and would not result in the filling in of a space between adjacent buildings. On
the other side of the adapted and extended summerhouse/garage, there would
be the undeveloped area of the neighbouring property’s garden.
10. In 2021, an Inspector confirmed that proposed extensions to a dwelling in
Bedmond would constitute limited infilling. However, this was a different
proposal in a different context where it was accepted that there was a gap
between two existing buildings. Therefore, there are material differences
between this proposal and that before me. In any case, every proposal has to
be considered on its particular planning merits. For all these reasons, the
appeal proposal before me would not comply with this Framework exception.
11. Another Framework exception is the limited infilling or the partial or complete
redevelopment of previously developed land, whether redundant or in
continuing use (excluding temporary buildings), which would not have a
greater impact on the openness of the Green Belt than the existing
development. The Framework definition of previously developed land excludes
land in built-up areas, such as a residential garden. The site is located within
semi-rural surroundings, but it is still within the built-up area of the village for
the reasons previously indicated. As such, it is excluded from the definition of
previously developed land.
12. In 2018, an Inspector found that an ancillary outbuilding was within the
‘previously developed land’ exception above. However, the surrounding area
contained a small number of properties, and despite the proximity of the M25
Motorway, it was concluded that overall, the area and property had a rural
character and appearance. Such circumstances do not apply here limiting the
weight to be attached to the decision. For all these reasons, the appeal
proposal before me would not comply with this Framework exception.
13. For all these reasons, the construction of the annex would be inappropriate
development under the Framework.
Openness
14. The fundamental aim of Green Belt policy is to prevent urban sprawl by
keeping land permanently open; the essential characteristics of Green Belts are
their openness and their permanence.
15. There would be a significant increase in the size of the summerhouse/garage
which would result in the building extending closer to the existing dwelling.
This would result in a loss of openness around the existing dwelling and
summerhouse/garage. The development would be screened, and it would be
within a group of buildings which would reduce the visual sense of the loss of
openness. The loss of openness would also be viewed against the backdrop of
existing development and the village. Public viewpoints are distant and
therefore, the visual loss of openness would be limited to residents close to the
development. However, openness has a spatial as well as visual dimension
which this development would harm by reason of its extent, irrespective of the
lack of visibility. Thus, there would be a small harmful loss of openness within
the Green Belt.
Appeal Decision APP/A1910/D/21/3276969
4
Character and appearance
16. The rear of the existing summer house is located within the Chipperfield
Conservation Area. The proposal would result in an awkwardly designed
building with a mixture of flat and pitched roofs. Nevertheless, the existing
summerhouse/garage has a similar mixed roofscape and the development
would not be conspicuous in its wider setting. Accordingly, there would be no
significant impact on the character and appearance of the area.
17. The Conservation Area comprises historic and architecturally attractive
buildings and spaces that are of importance and contribute to its significance
and its special interest. Considerable importance and weight are attached to
the desirability of preserving the character and appearance of the Conservation
Area. However, its character and appearance would be preserved for the
reasons given above. In conclusion, the proposal would comply with Policy CS5
of the CS in respect of character and appearance.
Other considerations
18. The proposed development would enhance existing leisure facilities which
would cater for the wellness needs of the appellants and their family. As a
result of the pandemic, health and well-being are important at a time when
access to gyms and sports facilities is more difficult. The extension and
alteration would represent an improvement to the property and local housing
stock. Nevertheless, this would primarily be a private benefit and therefore, it
would be a limited public benefit. The proposals would provide employment
and a business boost to the local economy during the construction period, at a
time, when the economy is suffering from a pandemic. However, such benefits
would be limited because they are mainly restricted to the duration of the
building works.
Conclusion
19. The proposal is inappropriate development in the Green Belt which is by
definition harmful. Although small, there is harm to the loss of the openness of
the Green Belt. The Framework establishes substantial weight should be given
to any harm to the Green Belt. Cumulatively, the weight of considerations in
favour of the development would not be great. For these reasons, ‘Very special
circumstances’ do not exist as the harm to the Green Belt by reason of
inappropriateness is not clearly outweighed by other considerations.
20. In terms of inappropriateness, the conflict of the proposal with CS Policy CS5
would be small because of its inconsistency with the Framework. Nevertheless,
the economy and housing benefits would be limited, and the question of
inappropriateness is central to the consideration of the proposal.
Consequently, the conflict would be material and there would be a conflict with
the development plan taken as a whole. There are no material considerations
to outweigh that finding. In any case, the conflict with the Framework policies
for the Green Belt would provide a clear reason for refusing the development.
Therefore, for the reasons set out above, this appeal is dismissed.
Jonathon Parsons
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.