First floor side extension with front and rear dormers
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Green Belt Policy
Extensions
Fallback Position
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site visit made on 4 January 2022
by Alison Partington BA (Hons) MA MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 11th January 2022
Appeal Ref: APP/M2325/D/21/3276242
Greenacres, Division Lane, Lytham St Annes, FY4 5EA
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Michael Ratcliff against the decision of Fylde Borough Council.
• The application Ref 21/0009, dated 5 January 2021, was refused by notice dated
9 March 2021.
• The development proposed is a first floor side extension with front and rear dormers.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Procedural Matter
2. A partial review of the Fylde Local Plan (adopted October 2018) (FLP) was
adopted in December 2021. However, this did not have any impact on Policy
GD2 of the FLP which is the only policy referred to in the reason for refusal.
Main Issues
3. The main issues in the appeal are:
• Whether or not the proposal would be inappropriate development in the
Green Belt for the purposes of the development plan and the National
Planning Policy Framework (the Framework);
• The effect of the proposal on the openness of the Green Belt and the
purposes of including land within it;
• If the proposal is inappropriate development, whether the harm by reason
of inappropriateness, and any other harm, is clearly outweighed by other
considerations, so as to amount to the very special circumstances
necessary to justify it.
Reasons
Whether inappropriate development
4. The appeal property lies within the Green Belt as defined by the FLP where
Policy GD2 indicates that proposals will be assessed against national policy for
developments within the Green Belt. Paragraphs 149 and 150 of the
Framework set out the forms of development that are not inappropriate in the
Green Belt. These include the extension or alteration of a building provided that
it does not result in disproportionate additions over and above the size of the
original building [paragraph 149 c)].
Appeal Decision APP/M2325/D/21/3276242
2
5. It has been argued by the appellant that paragraph 149 of the Framework
relates to new buildings and this is an extension to an existing building not a
new building. However, given that part c) of this paragraph specifically
addresses when extensions and alterations to buildings may potentially not be
inappropriate development, I consider that it can be taken that alterations and
extensions to buildings do fall within the remit of this paragraph.
6. What constitutes a disproportionate addition is not defined in either the FLP or
the Framework. Policy H7 of the FLP indicates that in the countryside
extensions to dwellings should not result in an increase in the original footprint
greater than 33%. Whilst this policy does not relate specifically to
developments in the Green Belt, which within national policy are subject to
different guidance than development within the countryside, it is a
consideration to be borne in mind. However, in the absence of any specific
guidance in national or local policy on what constitutes a disproportionate
addition, it is a matter of judgement for the decision maker.
7. The dwelling was originally a bungalow and has previously been extended on a
number of occasions, both by way of various single storey extensions and a
first floor extension over the eastern half of the property. The Council have
calculated that these have resulted in an increase in the footprint of the original
dwelling of around 32.5%. The proposal would not alter this. However, their
calculations also show that the volume of the original dwelling has already been
increased by around 63%. When taken cumulatively with the previous
extensions, the proposal would result in the volume of the original dwelling
being increased by approximately 100%. The appellant has not provided any
calculations to counter those of the Council.
8. Although the proposal would not increase the footprint of the building, I
consider that a cumulative increase in the volume of this scale can only be
considered to be disproportionate in size to the original dwelling.
9. In the light of the above, I conclude that the proposal would be inappropriate
development, which according to paragraph 147 of the Framework is, by
definition, harmful to the Green Belt.
Openness and purposes
10. Openness is an essential characteristic of the Green Belt. It can be taken as the
absence of buildings and development. The proposal would not increase the
footprint of the building, but the mass and bulk of the property would still be
increased by additional built development, and so the openness of the Green
Belt would be reduced. Although in isolation the loss would be minimal,
nonetheless, there is a degree of harm arising from this, in addition to that
arising from the inappropriate nature of the development.
11. There is no suggestion that the proposal would conflict with any of the
purposes of including land within the Green Belt – a conclusion with which I
agree. Nevertheless, a lack of harm in this respect is a neutral factor.
Other Considerations
12. The appellant has highlighted that Schedule 2, Part 1, Class AA of the Town
and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England) Order 2015
(as amended) allows the enlargement of a dwelling by the construction of an
additional storey and that this right applies whether or not a property is in the
Appeal Decision APP/M2325/D/21/3276242
3
Green Belt. It is suggested that using these rights would potentially allow a
higher, and less well designed, extension to be constructed on the host
property. The existence of a fall-back position is a material consideration.
13. However, the appellant’s evidence also indicates that informal advice from the
Council suggested that as the property has already had a first floor extension,
these provisions would not apply. I note that the appellant has not sought any
formal determination from the Council to ascertain whether any such extension
could be built. Nor is there any evidence to show that should the current appeal
be unsuccessful, it would be the intention of the appellant to build an
alternative scheme utilising these potential permitted development rights.
14. It is not within the scope of an appeal pursuant to section 78 of the Town and
Country Planning Act 1990 for me to determine the extent of the permitted
development rights asserted. In the absence of any formal determination with
regard to whether any such extension would be permitted development I give
this potential fall-back position little weight.
15. In 2017 permission was granted for a first floor extension in a similar position
to the proposal. This had a different design to the appeal scheme but overall,
the appellant has argued that the current proposal would be more in proportion
to the host property and would have less of an impact on openness. He
considers that the Council have been inconsistent in concluding that the former
scheme was not a disproportionate addition but that the current scheme is. I
do not know the full circumstances that led to the previous scheme being
considered acceptable. Whilst I can appreciate the appellant’s frustration that
the two applications have been determined differently, the former permission is
no longer extant and so does not represent a fall-back position. As a result, I
give it little weight.
16. The appellant has set out detailed arguments as to how he considers the
design of the proposal would ensure it was subservient to the main dwelling
and so would not appear a dominant or disproportionate addition. It is also
highlighted that the various different ground floor extensions individually are
relatively small.
17. Be that as it may, the test in the Framework is whether a proposal represents a
disproportionate addition over and above the size of the original dwelling. As
such, whilst the design of the extension in relation to the existing property is
an important consideration in terms of its impact on the character and
appearance of the area, the test in paragraph 149 c) of the Framework requires
an assessment of whether the proposal, in combination with any previous
additions to the original building, results in a disproportionate addition in terms
of its size not its design.
Conclusion
18. The proposed development would be inappropriate development in the Green
Belt, which is harmful by definition. It would also cause harm to the openness
of the Green Belt. In accordance with paragraph 148 of the Framework, I
attach substantial weight to the harm to the Green Belt. Despite having regard
to all the other considerations put before me, I consider that taken together,
the factors cited in its favour do not clearly outweigh the harm the scheme
would cause.
Appeal Decision APP/M2325/D/21/3276242
4
19. Consequently, the very special circumstances necessary to justify the
development do not exist. As a result, the proposal would be contrary to Policy
GD2 of the FLP and the Framework. Therefore, I conclude the appeal should be
dismissed.
Alison Partington
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.