Demolition of existing semi-derelict barn and replacement with new timber framed ancillary accommodation
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Residential Amenity
Character & Appearance
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site Visit made on 2 July 2021
by Mr A Spencer-Peet BSc(Hons) PGDip.LP Solicitor (Non Practising)
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 16 July 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/V1260/D/21/3275111
26 Stour Way, Christchurch, BH23 2PG
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr Simon Dunsby against the decision of Bournemouth
Christchurch and Poole Council.
• The application Ref 8/20/0617/HOU, dated 28 July 2020, was refused by notice
dated 12 March 2021.
• The development proposed is the demolition of existing semi-derelict barn and
replacement with new timber framed ancillary accommodation.
Decision
1. The appeal is allowed and planning permission is granted for the demolition of
existing semi-derelict barn and replacement with new timber framed ancillary
accommodation at 26 Stour Way, Christchurch, BH23 2PG, in accordance with
the terms of the application, Ref: 8/20/0617, dated 28 July 2020, subject to
the conditions in the attached schedule.
Applications for costs
2. An application for costs was made by Mr Simon Dunsby against Bournemouth
Christchurch and Poole Council. This application is the subject of a separate
Decision.
Main Issues
3. Although the Council has given two reasons for refusal on the decision notice,
having reviewed the evidence and submissions I have considered it appropriate
to identify a single main issue.
4. Accordingly, the main issue in this appeal is the effect of the proposed
development on the character and appearance of the surrounding area with
particular regard to the effect of the proposed development on non-designated
heritage assets.
Reasons
5. The appeal proposal seeks the removal and replacement of a barn structure
located within a residential area. The surrounding residential area is
characterised by well proportioned housing set within generous plots and which
predominately appear to be of modern construction. The barn, which is the
subject of this appeal, is separated from the host dwelling by a narrow
trackway which provides access to the rear of the host dwelling. The barn is of
timber construction and, at the time of my visit, appeared to be somewhat run
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/21/3275111
2
down in appearance with areas of external timber cladding having become
loose or were missing entirely.
6. The proposal seeks to replace the existing structure with ancillary
accommodation that would be of a similar external appearance and scale as
that exhibited by the existing structure. The appeal scheme would recognise
and reflect local distinctiveness and would be compatible with its built
surroundings in terms of style, scale, bulk, height and materials. In this regard,
the proposal would comply with the provisions of Policy HE2 of Christchurch
and East Dorset Local Plan Part 1 Core Strategy (2014) (the Core Strategy).
7. However, there is dispute between the main parties as to whether the barn
structure should be considered to be a non-designated heritage asset. The
National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework) defines a heritage asset
as “a building, monument, site, place, area or landscape identified as having a
degree of significance meriting consideration in planning decisions, because of
its heritage interest. It includes assets identified by the local planning authority
(including local listing)”.
8. Paragraph 190 of the Framework requires that local planning authorities
identify and assess the particular significance of any heritage asset that may be
affected by a proposal (including by development affecting the setting of a
heritage asset) taking account of the available evidence and any necessary
expertise. Whilst the Framework advises that it is important that all non-
designated heritage assets are clearly identified as such, the Planning Practice
Guidance1 also advises that local planning authorities may also identify non-
designated heritage assets as part of the decision-making process on planning
applications.
9. Whilst the evidence before me confirms that the existing barn building is not
locally listed, the Council has identified the barn structure to be a non-
designated asset as part of the planning application process. The Council has
used Historic England’s criteria for assessing non-designated heritage assets
and considers that the barn is a remaining outbuilding and important remnant
of Grove Farm - now known as Abbotswood - a Grade II Listed Building located
west of the site. The Council further considers that this type of structure is
uncommon within the area with its character and appearance reflecting its
function and historic relationship with Abbotswood.
10. Under section 66(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas)
Act 1990, I have a duty to have special regard to the desirability of preserving
listed buildings or their settings or any features of special architectural or
historic interest.
11. Based on the evidence submitted and on observations made on my site visit,
given the existence of modern substantially sized dwellings which separate the
barn structure from the dwelling at Abbotswood, the significance of the barn in
terms of its relationship with the former farm has been entirely lost.
Consequently, I find that the proposal would not have a harmful effect on the
setting or significance of the listed building at Abbotswood. Consequently, the
appeal scheme would not conflict with Policy BE15 of the Core Strategy which
requires that development does not adversely affect the setting of a listed
building.
1 Paragraph:040 Reference ID: 18a-040-20190723
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/21/3275111
3
12. Nonetheless, and irrespective of whether the building has been identified for
the purposes of the local list, the form and traditional materials used in the
construction of the barn remain such that the building retains its historic
appearance reflecting its historic function and, as such, it has a degree of
significance.
13. The proposal would result in the demolition of the non-designated heritage
asset. Policy HE1 of the Core Strategy seeks to ensure that the significance of
heritage assets, be they designated or non-designated, will be protected and
enhanced and, consequently, the proposal would not strictly accord with the
provisions of that policy. Paragraph 197 of the Framework provides that “the
effect of an application on the significance of a non-designated heritage asset
should be taken into account in determining the application. In weighing
applications that directly or indirectly affect non-designated heritage assets, a
balanced judgement will be required having regard to the scale of any harm or
loss and the significance of the heritage asset”.
14. As noted above, any significance of the existing barn as a non-designated
heritage asset appears to lie in its traditional form and age. I acknowledge that
its demolition would result in the substantial loss of this non-designated
heritage asset. Nevertheless, in this case, the barn does not feature on any
locally published list or other record of non-designated heritage assets despite
a number of applications for residential development having been recently
permitted immediately adjacent to the site. Moreover, given the somewhat run
down appearance of the barn, and that its historical setting has been removed
by residential development, the building has a limited significance, and so the
weight I give to this substantial loss would also be limited.
15. Further to the above, the Appellant’s submissions provide additional details and
confirmation regarding the structural soundness of the existing barn. In this
respect, the evidence before me indicates that, given its age and degree of
deterioration and by reason of previous alterations made to the barn which
included removing a large section of floor, the structure has, in places, started
to bow, with structural movement resulting in a building that is considered to
be unsafe for use, as well as raising safety concerns for those visiting or
passing by the site.
16. The proposal would remove the unsafe structure and would therefore provide
significant benefits in terms of the safety of future occupants of the host
building as well in terms of those using the narrow adjacent trackway. Through
careful design which reflects local distinctiveness, the proposal would improve
the appearance of the somewhat run down building and site. The proposal
would therefore accord with those parts of the Framework which concern
consideration of the potential impacts of development on the historic
environment.
17. Therefore, on balance, the benefits of the appeal scheme would outweigh the
limited harm that would result from the loss of this non-designated heritage
asset of limited significance. Consequently, these material considerations
outweigh the very limited conflict with Policy BE15 of the Core Strategy that
would result from the loss of the non-designated heritage asset.
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/21/3275111
4
Other Matters
18. Interested parties raise additional objections to the proposal on the grounds of
overlooking and loss of privacy. In this respect, whilst it is noted that the
proposed building would have a window at first floor level on its north
elevation, that opening would serve a stairwell and, consistent with the
Council’s findings, I conclude that the proposal would not have a significant
harmful effect with regards to overlooking or loss of privacy.
Conditions
19. I have had regard to the planning conditions suggested by the Council. Other
than the standard time limit condition, it is also necessary to ensure that the
development is carried out in accordance with the approved plans and that
details of external materials are submitted to, and approved by, the Council for
reasons of certainty.
20. Furthermore, it is necessary and reasonable to include a condition that requires
that the proposal is accrued out in accordance with the submitted bat survey in
the interests of ecology. An additional condition that the development be is
carried out in accordance with the submitted flood risk assessment is necessary
and reasonable in the interests of the environment and in the interests of the
living conditions of nearby residents.
21. Where necessary, and in the interests of clarity and precision, I have altered
the wording of the conditions suggested by the Council in order to better reflect
the relevant guidance.
Conclusion
22. For the reasons given above, the appeal succeeds and planning permission is
granted subject to the conditions identified.
Mr A Spencer-Peet
INSPECTOR
Appeal Decision APP/V1260/D/21/3275111
5
Schedule of Conditions
1) The development hereby permitted shall be begun before the expiration of
three years from the date of this decision.
2) The development hereby permitted shall be carried out in accordance with
the following approved plans: Site and Location Plans 898-20-05, Existing
Barn Plan 898-20-03 and Proposed Barn Plan 898-20-06 Rev A.
3) No development above damp proof course shall take place until details and
samples of all external facing and roofing materials have been provided and
approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority. All works shall be
undertaken strictly in accordance with the details as approved, unless
otherwise agreed in writing with the Local Planning Authority.
4) The development hereby approved shall be carried out strictly in accordance
with the mitigation, compensatory and enhancement measures specified
within the bat survey report carried out by David Leach Ecology Ltd dated
September 2020.
5) The development shall be carried out in accordance with the Flood Risk
Assessment by John Lewis and Associates dated 30 September 2020 and
Householder Flood Risk Assessment submitted on the 3 February 2021.
£
Costs decision section
Costs Decision
Site visit made on 2 July 2021
by A Spencer-Peet BSc(Hons) PGDip.LP Solicitor (Non Practicing)
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 16 July 2021
Costs application in relation to Appeal Ref: APP/V1260/D/21/3275111
Grove Farm, 26 Stour Way, Christchurch BH23 2PG
• The application is made under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990, sections 78,
322 and Schedule 6, and the Local Government Act 1972, section 250(5).
• The application is made by Mr Simon Dunsby for a full award of costs against
Bournemouth Christchurch and Poole Council.
• The appeal was against the refusal of planning permission for the demolition of existing
semi-derelict barn and replacement with new timber framed ancillary accommodation.
Decision
1. The application for an award of costs is refused.
Reasons
2. The Planning Practice Guidance (the PPG) advises that, irrespective of the
outcome of the appeal, costs may only be awarded against a party who has
behaved unreasonably and thereby caused the party applying for costs to incur
unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process.
3. The Applicant has put it to me that there was unreasonable behaviour by the
Council in relation to the identification of non-designated heritage assets, which
resulted in the Appellant having to incur unnecessary or wasted expense in the
appeal process.
4. As noted in the appeal decision, paragraph 190 of the National Planning Policy
Framework (the Framework) requires that local planning authorities identify
and assess the particular significance of any heritage asset that may be
affected by a proposal (including by development affecting the setting of a
heritage asset) taking account of the available evidence and any necessary
expertise. Further, although the Framework and PPG advise that it is important
that all non-designated heritage assets are clearly identified as such, the PPG
also advises that the local planning authorities may also identify non-
designated heritage assets as part of the decision-making process on planning
applications.
5. The Framework is clear that in weighing applications that directly or indirectly
affect non-designated heritage assets, a balanced judgement will be required
having regard to the scale of any harm or loss and the significance of the
heritage asset. The fact that a building is identified as a non-designated
heritage asset does not necessarily prevent its development.
6. With regards to the appeal building and site, it is clear from the Council
Officer’s report that, as part of the planning application, the Council’s Design
Costs Decision APP/V1260/D/21/3275111
2
and Heritage team were consulted and, given the buildings age, rarity,
aesthetic interest and historical association, it was determined that the building
would constitute a non-designated heritage asset. Furthermore, the Council’s
decision notice clearly explains what the Local Planning Authority considers to
be the harm arising from the proposal in terms of impact on the significance of
the non-designated heritage asset.
7. It will be seen from the appeal decision that, whilst I have found that the
proposal would not have any harmful effect with regards to the setting or
significance of the nearby Grade II Listed Building at Abbotswood, I concur with
the Council that the appeal building can properly be considered to be a non-
designated heritage asset. Whilst I have found that the appeal building has
only limited significance, in accordance with the provisions of the PPG and the
Framework, it has a degree of significance that merits consideration in the
planning application process.
8. Consequently, I find that the Council did not act unreasonably in terms of the
identification of the appeal building as a non-designated heritage asset.
Accordingly, it is not necessary to consider the matter of whether or not there
has been unnecessary or wasted expense in the appeal process.
9. In conclusion, I find that the unreasonable behaviour resulting in unnecessary
or wasted expense, as described within the PPG, has not been demonstrated in
this case and that, therefore, an award of costs is not justified.
Mr A Spencer-Peet
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.