Replacement of roof covering to front elevation on mid terrace property within the Toxteth Park Conservation Area
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Heritage & Conservation
Character & Appearance
Policy Weight
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site Visit made on 28 September 2021
by R Hitchcock BSc(Hons) DipCD MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 04 October 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/Z4310/D/21/3274330
37 Halkyn Avenue, Liverpool L17 2AH
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant planning permission.
• The appeal is made by Mr A Edem against the decision of Liverpool City Council.
• The application Ref 20H/2655, dated 9 October 2020, was refused by notice dated
8 March 2021.
• The development proposed is the replacement of roof covering to front elevation on mid
terrace property within the Toxteth Park Conservation Area.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Preliminary Matters
2. At the time of my site inspection the replacement roof covering was in place
and I shall deal with the development as one under s73A of the Act for
development already carried out.
3. The Council’s Decision Notice refers to emerging Policy HD1 of the Liverpool
Local Plan which is yet to be adopted. The plan has been considered at
examination following public consultation and found to be consistent with the
National Planning Policy Framework (the Framework), however, it remains
subject to modifications.
4. Nevertheless, Paragraph 48 of the Framework clarifies that weight may be
given to emerging policies according to the stage of preparation of the
emerging plan, the extent to which there are unresolved objections and the
degree of consistency with the Framework. Proposed Policy HD1 of the LLP
relating to Heritage Assets provides a detailed approach to the consideration of
proposals affecting designated and non-designated heritage assets. I find the
approach has broad alignment with the Framework’s aims to conserve and
enhance the historic environment and, in the absence of evidence to suggest
significant unresolved objections remain, I find emerging Policy HD1 is entitled
to significant weight in the determination of this appeal.
5. Since the time of the Council’s decision a revised version of the Framework has
been issued by the Government. However, it does not alter the status and
primacy of the development plan. Furthermore, I find that there is little
material change in the national approach to heritage assets within the context
of this appeal. There was no need, therefore, to invite the parties to make
further submissions in response to the revised Framework.
Main Issue
Appeal Decision APP/Z4310/D/21/3274330
2
6. The main issue is whether the new roof covering preserves or enhances the
character or appearance of the Toxteth Park and Avenues Conservation Area
(CA).
Reasons
7. The property is a mid-terrace 2-storey building set behind a short garden
contained by a low wall with a stone coping. The building has a number of
architectural features to its frontage which contribute to a streetscene of
similarly detailed houses. The terrace includes various forms of projecting bays,
feature chimneys, stone headers and sills, moulded bargeboards, contrasting
banding courses and ornate gables and cornices. Like much of the row of
terraces, the building’s frontage is finished in smooth-face Accrington brick.
The original roofing material was blue slate.
8. The site lies close to the eastern extent of the CA. The area, consisting of a
gridwork of terraces and villas about Toxteth Park Cemetery, was developed
over a relatively short period. The significance of the CA derives from buildings
which show common characteristics from their design period and a limited
range of construction materials resulting in consistency in the character and
appearance of buildings within the sub-areas of the CA. The Council has
imposed an Article 4 restriction on properties within the CA to prevent the
uncontrolled alteration of elevations and roofs fronting on to the roadways.
9. As the site lies within the CA, Section 72(1) of the Planning (Listed Buildings
and Conservation Areas) Act 1990 requires me to have special regard to the
desirability of preserving or enhancing the character or appearance of the CA.
10. The development that has taken place was the removal of the original slate
roof covering, ridge tiles and gable bargeboards. These have been replaced
with modern grey concrete interlocking tiles, concrete ridge tiles and plastic
verge units respectively.
11. Amongst other things, saved Policy HD10 of the Liverpool Unitary Development
Plan [2002] (UDP) states that ‘In considering proposals for the alteration,
extension or conversion of non-listed buildings in a conservation area, special
attention will be paid to the following: i. the retention, replacement and
restoration of historic features and details of buildings, including windows,
roofing materials, garden or forecourt features and boundary walls’.
12. The use of modern materials and associated edge fixings and trims has
removed the finer detailing apparent in the original main roofs and gables of
nearby properties. The slate roofs have a light and slightly varied hue and
texture. The individual thin slates have bevelled dressed leading and side edge
profiles. This provides a refined detail across the roofscape whereupon there is
little distinction between the vertical and horizontal joint lines.
13. In contrast, the uniformly coloured smooth grey concrete tiles have a thick,
square-cut, leading edge and are close-butted. This results in a comparatively
coarse appearance with highly prominent horizontal banding arising from the
deep faces of the tiles and flush side joints. This causes the main roof slope of
the building to visually stand out when compared to the appearance of the
original slate roofs.
14. The resultant banding reduces the perceived prominence of the ridgeline which,
in the original roof examples, is highlighted as standing proud of the main roof
Appeal Decision APP/Z4310/D/21/3274330
3
slope. Furthermore, in the absence of successively overlapping ridge tiles, the
butted ridge has a flat uniformity which lacks the detail of the earlier ridgelines.
15. The cloaked verges of the projecting gable introduce a modern material and a
poorly detailed overlapping cladding to the roof verge. This has little reference
to any original feature of the building and has resulted in the loss of the
painted bargeboards. Elsewhere these have a greater linear emphasis and
refined detail to the gable edges. Together these elements of the development
undermine the quality and parity in the detailing of the building.
16. As part of a long terrace with a high level of consistency in external finishes,
the differences are abundantly evident in views from the street level along
Halkyn Avenue. Moreover, the site lies directly opposite Rossett Avenue and
forms a closing vista to views along its length. Accordingly, the materials are
highly prominent and are seen to contrast starkly with the predominant roof
coverings. As a contrasting roof treatment with little regard to the traditional
materials and detailing, I find the development fails to preserve or enhance the
character or appearance of the building or this part of the CA.
17. Whilst most of the buildings on the avenue retain their original slate roofs there
are some examples of other roof coverings in the locality. The majority of these
are profiled clay tiles in a range of colours which have been extensively used as
replacement coverings in some of the terraced streets adjoining Halkyn
Avenue. A modern flat concrete tile has been added to the adjacent property at
35 Halkyn Avenue.
18. However, the development neither reflects the original materials or the profiled
replacement coverings found nearby streets. Although they have a similar
appearance to the adjoining property, it is unclear whether those works have
the benefit of planning permission. Furthermore, that example is very much in
the minority and the existence of development elsewhere does not represent
an appropriate reason to find in favour of a development that I have identified
causes harm.
19. In the context of the Framework, the extent of overall harm of the
development is less than substantial given the nature of the development.
However, less than substantial harm does not equate to a less than substantial
planning objection. Paragraph 202 of the Framework (formerly Para.196)
advises that such harm should be weighed against the public benefits of the
proposals including securing optimal viable use.
20. I note the possible public benefits of the proposal as the new roof covering
replaced the original timeworn slates. The modern materials would potentially
ease the maintenance burden for the property owner in an area where
properties have been converted to flats and houses in multiple occupation.
However, any public benefits therein are very limited. On the basis of the
evidence provided, the described benefits would not outweigh the less than
substantial harm identified.
21. For those reasons, I find that the development fails to preserve or enhance the
character and appearance of the CA. It therefore conflicts with saved
Policy HD10 of the UDP and emerging Policy HD1 of the LLP which, in part,
seek to achieve similar aims.
Appeal Decision APP/Z4310/D/21/3274330
4
Conclusion
22. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
R Hitchcock
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.