Erection of additional storey to an existing single storey detached dwelling. The extension will be erected on the same footprint as the existing external walls of the dwelling and will be constructed of timber frame with external cladding of similar appearance to the cladding currently used on the existing bungalow. The roof pitch and materials will be similar to the existing roof pitch of the bungalow
📊
See the success rate & inspector analytics
Free to view — just create an account, no payment needed.
Sign Up FreeTechnical Issues Heatmap
Policy Weight
Fallback Position
Extensions
Inspector’s Reasoning
Appeal Decision
Site Visit made on 12 May 2021
by Nick Davies BSc(Hons) BTP MRTPI
an Inspector appointed by the Secretary of State
Decision date: 15 June 2021
Appeal Ref: APP/Y1110/D/21/3270045
85 Newcourt Road, Topsham EX3 0BU
• The appeal is made under section 78 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990
against a refusal to grant approval required under Article 3, Schedule 2, Part 1,
Class AA of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (England)
Order 2015 (as amended) (the GPDO).
• The appeal is made by Mr John Parry against the decision of Exeter City Council.
• The application Ref 20/1379/PDA, dated 13 October 2020, was refused by notice dated
16 February 2021.
• The development proposed is described as “erection of additional storey to an existing
single storey detached dwelling. The extension will be erected on the same footprint as
the existing external walls of the dwelling and will be constructed of timber frame with
external cladding of similar appearance to the cladding currently used on the existing
bungalow. The roof pitch and materials will be similar to the existing roof pitch of the
bungalow”.
Decision
1. The appeal is dismissed.
Background and Main Issue
2. Subject to a number of qualifying criteria, paragraph AA of Part 1 of Schedule 2
of the GPDO grants planning permission for the enlargement of a one storey
dwellinghouse consisting of the construction of one additional storey,
immediately above the topmost storey of the dwellinghouse, together with any
engineering operations reasonably necessary for the purpose of that
construction. Paragraph AA.1 sets out the circumstances in which development
is not permitted by Class AA. The council does not dispute that the proposal
would be permitted development against the criteria in AA.1.
3. Paragraph AA.2 requires developers to apply to the local planning authority for
prior approval as to a range of matters in (3) (a) (i) to (iv). Although not
clearly stated on the decision notice, the council’s reason for refusal indicates
that it refused prior approval solely under the matter described in (3) (a) (ii),
which is the external appearance of the dwellinghouse, including the design
and architectural features of the principal elevation of the dwellinghouse, and
any side elevation of the dwellinghouse that fronts a highway.
4. Therefore, the main issue in this appeal is the effect of the development on the
external appearance of the dwellinghouse.
Reasons
5. 85 Newcourt Road is a detached bungalow with a hipped roof. It lies towards
the centre of a row of similar detached bungalows, nearly all of which have
hipped roofs, with roof planes sloping up away from the road. Although there is
Appeal Decision APP/Y1110/D/21/3270045
2
some difference in their configuration, there is little variation in the overall
ridge heights of the dwellings. The roofslopes are all covered in similar plain
tiles and are largely unbroken, apart from two small dormers at Nos 75 and 77.
As the buildings are set on a rigid building line, there is a distinct rhythm to the
street scene and, combined with the high degree of visual consistency between
the dwellings, this gives the row a coherent character and appearance.
6. The additional storey would result in the dwelling being significantly higher
than the neighbouring bungalows. It would, therefore, be markedly out of
character with the row of single storey buildings to either side. Although it
would not be remodelled in the same way as the proposal that was previously
dismissed on appeal1, it would, nevertheless, result in a two-storey building
that would be incongruous in the otherwise coherent street scene.
7. I acknowledge that, unlike the appeal scheme, the proposal does not involve
the provision of a gabled extension over the flat-roofed garage to the side of
the bungalow. Consequently, the existing gap between Nos 83 and 85 would be
maintained. However, there would be a marked step in eaves and ridge heights
between the two buildings. Whilst the hipped roof would be similar to the
common roof form along the row, it would be set at a much higher level, with
the eaves a full storey above that of the other bungalows. It would, therefore,
be a visually disruptive feature, and the external appearance of the resultant
dwelling would not assimilate comfortably into the surrounding built
environment.
8. It is contended that the proposal overcomes the concerns raised by the
previous Inspector regarding the introduction of windows at roof level.
However, there would be a large window at first floor level in the principal
elevation, which would be at a similar height to that proposed under the appeal
scheme. Although there is two-storey development further along the road to
the north, there are no first-floor windows in the bungalows that provide the
context for the appeal site. The prominent first-floor window would, therefore,
serve to accentuate the uncharacteristic two-storey appearance of the resultant
dwelling, which would visually set it apart from the single-storey bungalows to
either side.
9. The cladding proposed for the first floor would not be a typical material of the
locality, and would further contribute to the uncharacteristic external
appearance of the resultant dwelling. This is a matter that could be addressed
by condition. However, a more suitable material would not disguise the
inappropriate height and mass of the building, and the visually disruptive
impact it would have on the existing consistency of the street scene.
10. The appellant has drawn my attention to a recent planning permission for a
first-floor extension at No 95. Although I have not been provided with any
details, I saw that the development appeared to have been largely
implemented. I also saw that No 93 is already two-storey, with a large dormer
window on its front roof slope. This dwelling and No 95 lie beyond the largely
uniform row of hipped roofed bungalows that contains the appeal site. The
context is, therefore, different, so this permission does not alter my conclusion
that the external appearance of the development would be out of keeping with
the character of its immediate surroundings.
1 Planning Inspectorate Ref: APP/Y1110/D/19/3240792
Appeal Decision APP/Y1110/D/21/3270045
3
11. The appellant also draws attention to paragraph 118 of the National Planning
Policy Framework (the Framework), which, in encouraging the effective use of
land, supports the use of airspace above existing residential buildings for new
homes. In this case, however, the proposal would not provide new homes, so
does not derive support from this paragraph. In any event, paragraph 118 goes
on to identify that upward extensions should be allowed “where the
development would be consistent with the prevailing height and form of
neighbouring properties and the overall street scene”. As already set out, I
have found that the proposal would not meet these criteria.
12. For the above reasons, I conclude that the proposal would result in the dwelling
having an external appearance that, by reason of its height and design, would
be incongruous in a row of visually coherent bungalows. The proposal would
not, therefore, be sympathetic to local character, and would not improve the
quality of the area. Consequently, it would conflict with the advice in Section 12
of the Framework, which seeks to achieve well-designed places.
Conclusion
13. For the reasons given above, I conclude that the appeal should be dismissed.
Nick Davies
INSPECTOR
Expert Representation
Don't leave your appeal to chance.
Inspectors are inconsistent. We build a technical defense using precedents from our 182,000+ case archive.
No win, no fee Householder representation — you only pay if you win.